Eh. I'm not sure why everyone gushes so much about this. Too heavy for kids, too shallow for adults, and ultimately doesn't make much of a point. Yup, we're all gonna die and we can't see beyond that wall - not much use fretting about it.

I wanted to like this, and I can see why others do, but I couldn't get past meh. The fact that it explicitly imposes a male gaze POV on the reader probably didn't help.

I found the concept more intriguing than the execution. This is YA literature, and the writing is simplistic at times. Still, there were some surprising choices along the way and Dr. Erland's moral ambiguity added interest for me.

Mike Carey has me hooked again. I'm not sure if I know exactly what's going on, or I'm completely lost, and that's a lovely tension. I can't wait to see what happens next - hopefully the library has the series, or this could get expensive . . .

This was diverting, but not great. I think Joe Hill's pacing is just not for me - every time I read a novel by him, I feel like it would have been fabulous if edited down to about 70% of its actual length.

Not for me. Stories with a vague sense of something weird or off, but not really horror or “weird fiction” as such. Add an incredibly slow pace, and I just can't make myself read any more of this. Oh well.

Utterly addictive. Moving, funny, and thought-provoking. And the art is genuinely stunning.