| #1 |  The Lost Library
| 4.14 | 8 reads |
| #2 |  We Were Liars
| 3.51 | 441 reads |
| #3 |  The Yellow Wall-Paper
| 4.04 | 256 reads |
| #4 |  The Raven King
| 4.08 | 177 reads |
| #5 |  Most Ardently: A Pride & Prejudice Remix
| 3.81 | 24 reads |
| #6 |  When No One is Watching
| 3.59 | 125 reads |
| #7 |  Wilder Girls
| 3.42 | 130 reads |
| #8 |  House of Hollow
| 3.98 | 116 reads |
| #9 |  The Guest List
| 3.58 | 519 reads |
| #10 |  The Last Thing He Told Me
| 3.47 | 255 reads |
| #11 |  All the Dangerous Things
| 3.83 | 105 reads |
| #12 |  None of This Is True
| 3.93 | 294 reads |
| #13 |  Pines
| 3.86 | 248 reads |
| #14 |  Welcome to Night Vale
| 3.76 | 82 reads |
| #15 |  The Reappearance of Rachel Price
| 3.99 | 94 reads |
| #16 |  The Vanderbeekers of 141st Street
| 4.31 | 15 reads |