Ratings22
Average rating3.4
In my quest to read all of Agatha Christie's mysteries chronologically, I found this one to be a tad boring. It came as a bit of a surprise to me because I typically like the quiet countryside murders.
Firstly, I think the plot lacked excitement and the romance subplot was a bit thin. There doesn't seem to be a string to Luke's logic so he wings it the entire time and makes assumptions off of little to no evidence. Then he falls for a certain girl in town after knowing very little about her, besides that she looks like a witch when the wind blows...
To call it a Superintendent Battle mystery is misleading, since he only shows up in the last chapter. But what a relief when that happens because the main detective, Luke, is slower than Hastings. His logic throughout the book and his piecing together of the crimes (if you can call it that) are frustrating to say the least.
Sometimes in a novel the characters know more than the reader (e.g. all of Hercule Poirot's mysteries) but in this one, the reader knows more than the characters. I suppose it is a matter of preference, but I found this book infuriating at times because of it.
Overall, I still liked the book. I like all of Christie's books. But this one lacks the pizazz that some of her others (even less popular ones) have.