Ratings66
Average rating3.4
On the day the government decrees that women are no longer allowed more than one hundred words per day, Dr. Jean McClellan is in denial. This can't happen here. Not in America. Not to her. This is just the beginning. Soon women are not permitted to hold jobs. Girls are not taught to read or write. Females no longer have a voice. Before, the average person spoke sixteen thousand words each day, but now women have only one hundred to make themselves heard. For herself, her daughter, and every woman silenced, Jean will reclaim her voice.
Reviews with the most likes.
Pros: very fast paced, emotional punch, thought-provoking
Cons: minor things, slightly rushed ending
A year ago life changed for 50% of the US population. Women were kicked out of the workforce and made to wear bracelets that counted their words. When they reached their cap of 100 words, they received an electric jolts of increasing intensity until they stopped talking. Members of the LGBT community were shipped off to ‘camps'.
A year ago Dr. Jean McClellan was a top cognitive linguist researching Wernicke's aphasia, an ailment that makes it difficult to form coherent sentences. Now she's a stay at home wife, slowly watching her marriage crumble, her daughter suffer under the word restrictions, and her oldest son become a misogynist.
When the President's brother has an accident that affects the Wernicke area of the brain, she's asked to help find a cure, little knowing that there's another reason the government wants her work.
The book is very fast paced and only look me 2 days to whip through. It's first person narrative makes the world immediate and the clever use of flashbacks fleshes out the characters and how the US changed so quickly.
Loss of freedom is always an interesting plot device, and this book touches on real fears American women have during the present political climate. The book joins other US dystopian novels that focus on how women could be repressed like Margaret Atwood's The Handmaid's Tale, Veracity by Laura Bynum, and When She Woke by Hilary Jordan.
There are some powerfully emotional scenes, some of which were rage inducing, while others made me want to cry. While I often didn't agree with Jean's choices, I could understand why she made those decisions and sympathized with her plight.
While the book explained that Wernicke's aphasia impairs the ability to speak coherently, it would have been good to point out that it doesn't always impair cognitive abilities outside of communication. I was left wondering if people who had it would be able to function or if they would have to be put into care homes.
There were a few minor issues that annoyed me, like cookbooks being banned when you would expect they would be needed. You can't remember every recipe or learn new ones without some sort of help. There's also a scene where Jean had just under 40 words remaining in her day and she had to make a phone call. She prepared her message in advance but used her whole allotment, even though several of the words she used were unnecessary. What if she'd had to respond to a question afterwards? She'd have had to stay silent.
The ending felt a bit rushed in that I would have liked a more complete telling of what happened. I understand why it wasn't comprehensive, but it felt like the author could have provided an alternate viewpoint or arranged to have a witness describe the event in more detail.
It's hard to call a book that does so many horrible things a pleasant read, but it was. Normally dystopian novels leave me horrified by how things could go in the real world while this one left me feeling energized, and feeling that the resistance can succeed if good people fight for their rights.
Interesting concept but the ending felt a little too simplistic and neat.
This book was alright. I admit it took me a while to read because it was a little too relevant to today's times and the world is tough enough as it is.
That being said, my thoughts about the book:
- It was a cool premise. I like dystopian books in general, and the idea of women being limited and restricted sounded scary but cool.
- The story jumped around a LOT, to the point where it was kind of hard to keep up with at times.
- It felt like the twins' characters were kind of wasted. Stephen and Sonia got a LOT more development than they did.
- This gal really got away with her affair. When Patrick didn't react at all to finding out, I was just annoyed. The Lorenzo scenes felt like they were taking away from the larger story too. I kept saying, out loud, “okay calm down lady” every time there was a scene of him looking her up and down (for the 500th time).
- I liked Jacko's character, but I wish she had more “present” time rather than flashbacks. Same with Dell and his family.
- The author did a great job of making me want to also slap Stephen in the face.
I think overall I'll give the book a B/B-. It was a fun one to get through, even with my criticisms.
I felt like I was reading a horror novel instead of a dystopia. The first third of the book, specifically, was enraging. It's the setup - the explanation of how the world is now, and how it came to be that way - that made me have to set the book down twice and walk away to calm down.
The book is the story of Dr. Jean McClellan, cognitive linguist. The forced silence is particularly painful for her, a former scientist who was working on a cure for people who had brain injuries or strokes affecting the Wernicke area of the brain, where we process language. She was about to start restoring language to people who had lost it, only to have it stolen from her and every other woman in the country.
The book opens on Dr. McClellan being asked to return to her work, because the President's brother suffered a brain injury while skiing and can no longer understand language. As one of the most important advisors to the president, the government needs him. In return for the removal of both her bracelet and her daughter's, she agrees, hoping to find some way to sabotage the work.
Vox sets out a sequence of events that seems far too feasible for comfort. The religious right extends its foothold from the Bible Belt to more and more of the country, pushing a return to “traditional family values” while methodically stripping freedoms from women and LGBT people. Women's passports are surreptitiously cancelled, schools are split and classes on Christian theology introduced to the boys' schools. Girls' schools consist of very basic math (so they can continue to do the grocery shopping and cooking!) and a ton of home ec. Sewing, Cooking, Housekeeping. LGBT people are sent to prisons/camps unless they marry someone of the opposite sex and produce kids. Basically, it's the right wing's dream world.
It's a horrifying scenario. Even given all the dystopia I've read, this book rocked me. It definitely belongs in the league of The Handmaid's Tale and The Power. My only complaint is I wish the ending had been a little more drawn out, and explained the fallout in a bit more detail. Other than that, though, amazing book.
You can find all my reviews at Goddess in the Stacks.