 Nestlings
| 35 reads | 4.14 |
 All Her Little Secrets
| 19 reads | 3.81 |
 Horrorstör
| 220 reads | 3.55 |
 The Good Lie
| 79 reads | 3.88 |
 A Dowry of Blood
| 175 reads | 4.07 |
 The Thursday Murder Club
| 556 reads | 3.86 |
 Dead Eleven: A Novel
| 20 reads | 3.62 |
 Monstrilio
| 54 reads | 4.16 |
 Any Man
| 34 reads | 4.37 |
 The Last One
| 31 reads | 3.63 |
 The Soulmate
| 75 reads | 3.66 |
 The Girls on Chalk Hill
| 1 read | 5 |
 Once There Were Wolves
| 58 reads | 4.02 |
 Stay Close
| 20 reads | 3.5 |
 Girl A
| 29 reads | 3.42 |
 The Ex Hex
| 197 reads | 3.53 |
 Something in the Water
| 60 reads | 3.73 |
 No One Gets Out Alive
| 13 reads | 3 |
 Rock Paper Scissors
| 250 reads | 3.82 |
 The Ten Thousand Doors of January
| 312 reads | 4.15 |
 56 Days
| 55 reads | 3.63 |
 Safe
| 5 reads | 3.25 |
 Interview with the Vampire
| 503 reads | 3.81 |
 Rattle
| 2 reads | 4 |
 Pet Sematary
| 551 reads | 3.94 |
 A House at the Bottom of a Lake
| 55 reads | 3.23 |
 The Glass Woman
| 5 reads | 3.88 |
 The Flatshare
| 235 reads | 3.97 |
 Paradise Club
| 2 reads | 3.5 |
 The Perfect Child
| 72 reads | 3.94 |
 The Drowning Kind
| 22 reads | 3.75 |
 Near the Bone
| 58 reads | 3.65 |
 Katherine of Aragón: The True Queen
| 14 reads | 3.67 |
 The Lost Ones
| 2 reads | 1.5 |
 The Girl with a Clock for a Heart
| 6 reads | 2.8 |
 That Night
| 1 read | 4.5 |
 Every Vow You Break
| 26 reads | 3.2 |
 The Burning Girls
| 57 reads | 3.75 |
 The House in the Cerulean Sea
| 910 reads | 4.27 |
 Grace Under Pressure
| 0 reads | 0 |
 Six of Crows
| 951 reads | 4.28 |
 The One
| 192 reads | 4.01 |
 All Geek to Me
| 0 reads | 0 |
 Mrs Death Misses Death
| 13 reads | 3.55 |
 The Last House on Needless Street
| 212 reads | 3.91 |
 Hangman
| 7 reads | 3.67 |
 Little Heaven
| 20 reads | 3.32 |
 His Bloody Project
| 21 reads | 4.2 |
 The Library of the Dead
| 42 reads | 3.66 |
 The necessary death of Lewis Winter
| 4 reads | 4.25 |
 Edge of the Grave
| 1 read | 5 |
 Driftnet
| 4 reads | 4 |
 Murder Movie Murder Movie
| 0 reads | 0 |
 Willow Moss & the Lost Day
| 3 reads | 4 |
 Pet
| 84 reads | 4.34 |
 The Girl in the Mirror
| 11 reads | 3.82 |
 Blood Orange
| 16 reads | 3.54 |
 Nightshift
| 2 reads | 3.5 |
 The Girl Who Drank the Moon
| 131 reads | 4.15 |
 Ready Player One
| 1,867 reads | 3.94 |
 House of Mystery Vol. 1: Room and Boredom | 5 reads | 3.75 |
 The Immortalists
| 143 reads | 3.72 |
 This Time Next Year
| 40 reads | 3.37 |
 The Ex Talk
| 75 reads | 3.68 |
 The Astonishing Color of After
| 33 reads | 4.03 |
 Fangirl
| 456 reads | 3.87 |
 City of the Lost
| 14 reads | 3.62 |
 Fangs
| 90 reads | 4.14 |
 The Ghost Tree
| 13 reads | 3.4 |
 The Only Good Indians
| 208 reads | 3.79 |
 Lakewood
| 34 reads | 3.54 |
 The Hollow Places
| 138 reads | 3.8 |
 Mexican Gothic
| 534 reads | 3.74 |
 The Happy Ever After Playlist
| 74 reads | 3.81 |
 The Friend Zone
| 99 reads | 3.5 |
 Hot Dog Girl
| 18 reads | 3.57 |
 Elatsoe
| 111 reads | 3.97 |
 Black Girl Unlimited
| 10 reads | 4.17 |
 Every Heart a Doorway
| 411 reads | 3.91 |
 The Maltese Falcon
| 112 reads | 3.87 |
 Beach Read
| 608 reads | 3.92 |
 Double Indemnity
| 20 reads | 4.25 |
 The Bat
| 124 reads | 3.34 |
 Circe
| 1,201 reads | 4.26 |
 Dear Child
| 16 reads | 3.94 |
 The Song of Achilles
| 1,292 reads | 4.26 |
 The Nesting
| 9 reads | 3.44 |
 He Started It
| 29 reads | 3.32 |
 Kill Creek
| 53 reads | 3.73 |
 They Never Learn
| 98 reads | 3.94 |
 Darling Rose Gold
| 24 reads | 3.52 |
 Little Secrets
| 73 reads | 3.86 |
 Long Bright River
| 85 reads | 4.13 |
 The Wife Upstairs
| 90 reads | 3.41 |
 The Patient
| 43 reads | 3.4 |
 The Bright Lands
| 13 reads | 3.55 |
 The Troop
| 185 reads | 3.73 |
 Impulse
| 51 reads | 4.06 |
 Eight Perfect Murders
| 92 reads | 3.53 |
 The Whisperer
| 9 reads | 3.61 |