This one was very good. I gave it 4 stars instead of 5 because with so little Algaliarept, it just doesn't quite make the 5-star level in my rating system. I liked the traditional bad-guy hunting/mystery this novel contained & I like the directions the main characters seem to be going in. Ready for 2013 & the next!
This book is like The Velveteen Rabbit on steroids. It's very good, very sweet and very emotional. I think it's essentially too advanced for a read-aloud to a five-year-old, but Charlie was drawn to the cover, begged for the book at the bookstore, and I gave in, not really knowing what it was about. It is all about Edward's learning to love and appreciate everyone who loves him (Edward is a unique and beautiful toy rabbit) over the years. Though Charlie really seemed to like it and wanted to know what was happening next, he did keep asking me why I was crying, and the flux of characters in and out of the book may have been hard for him to follow. His favorite character was the hobo, and really, he (“Bull”) was the best character in the book. Charlie also thought it was very cool that Bull called Edward “Malone” and he said he would like to be named “Malone.”
First time! This book was so good! I truly missed out by not reading this as a kid. The inner workings of the chocolate factory are just so perfect for inspiring a child's imagination. Charlie loved this book too. I think he related to the obsession with candy, and the drama involved with the kids getting into trouble was a perfect level of intensity (strangely violent, but not cruelly so) for a 5 year old. The routine of each child getting picked off one by one was also predictable/satisfying for Charlie. This has been the best chapter book read-aloud experience yet. Most nights, it was me proposing to read “just one more” extra chapter, and not him!
OK, any book that encourages Charlie to snuggle up to me and then talk excitedly about the plot and characters gets high ratings. But it's really cute, especially the illustrations. (My favorite is one that's also on the cover of of the lion, with his mane combed out, braided and tied in bows.) Charlie and I both enjoyed Elmer Elevator's adventures searching for the dragon on Wild Island.
Beautiful novel. Not so much the prose, which was nice, but the depiction of a breathtakingly beautiful Manhattan. It reminds me of Whit Stillman movies. Loved the female characters. While this was written by a man, it struck me that the women in this book were so much more assertive participants in their destinies than the women in books by contemporary first time female writers like Curtis Sittenfeld & Marisha Pessl. (It may have something to do with the fact that Towles is older than these women were when they published their first novels.) I recommend this to everyone and would love to loan you my copy!
These books keep getting better. The characters and relationships within the small town of Millers Kill are evolving and growing more interconnected. The way the minor/supporting characters maintain their relationships despite conflicts is interesting to me. And the main character, Reverend Clare, I just love her attempts to stay clearheaded and make fair and kind choices, despite being crazy in love with a married man. The everyday morality of this series really shone in this novel, with a deep investigation of the guilty parties' (including Clare & Russ as well as the “bad guys”) rationales and decisions. Spencer-Fleming is like George Eliot light. Less taxing and less rewarding, but so very tender with human failings.