 The Graveyard Apartment
| 2 reads | 3 |
 Twelve Nights at Rotter House
| 16 reads | 3.19 |
 Vampire
| 0 reads | 0 |
 The Haunting of Gillespie House
| 15 reads | 3.17 |
 These Witches Don't Burn
| 40 reads | 3.62 |
 Burning Girls
| 10 reads | 4.1 |
 The Folcroft Ghosts The Folcroft Ghosts
| 2 reads | 3.5 |
 The Once and Future Witches
| 172 reads | 4.15 |
 Literary Witches
| 2 reads | 4.25 |
 Beyond the Woods: Fairy Tales Retold | 2 reads | 5 |
 The Haunting of Ashburn House
| 34 reads | 3.98 |
 The Fog
| 16 reads | 3.5 |
 The Midnight Library
| 1,426 reads | 3.81 |
 When God Was a Woman
| 5 reads | 4.67 |
 The Rats
| 20 reads | 3.47 |
 The Shuddering
| 27 reads | 3.5 |
 Sunflower Sisters
| 3 reads | 3.5 |
 The Witches of New York
| 23 reads | 3.96 |
 Behind Closed Doors
| 194 reads | 3.73 |
 Not Juss Another Oracle Book Not Juss Another Oracle Book
| 0 reads | 0 |
 Blissful Books & Beasts Beneath Blissful Books & Beasts Beneath
| 0 reads | 0 |
 Northern Frights
| 0 reads | 0 |
 Were Wildflowers Freakin' Flourish
| 0 reads | 0 |
 The 25th Key The 25th Key
| 0 reads | 0 |
 An Anomaly In Space
| 0 reads | 0 |
 The Peculiar Poetories The Peculiar Poetories
| 0 reads | 0 |
 The Turn of the Screw
| 195 reads | 3.31 |
 The Graveyard Book
| 616 reads | 4.17 |
 Fledgling
| 83 reads | 3.62 |
 The Hate U Give
| 440 reads | 4.5 |
 Anya's Ghost
| 102 reads | 3.56 |
 The Creepypasta Collection Presents: Voices in the Spirit Box by Michael Marks
| 1 read | 0 |
 Payback Is a Witch
| 0 reads | 0 |
 Later
| 187 reads | 3.76 |
 The Children God Forgot The Children God Forgot
| 2 reads | 4 |
 The Creepypasta Collection: Modern Urban Legends You Can't Unread | 2 reads | 4.75 |
 A Head Full of Ghosts
| 161 reads | 3.88 |
 We Have Always Lived in the Castle
| 365 reads | 4.01 |
 A Bright Enchanted Suffering
| 0 reads | 0 |
 Someone We Know
| 50 reads | 3.5 |
 The Vine Witch
| 30 reads | 3.59 |
 Come with Me
| 32 reads | 3.91 |
 The Creepypasta Collection, Volume 2: 20 Stories. No Sleep.
| 0 reads | 0 |
 The Broken Girls
| 88 reads | 3.98 |
 The Mary Shelley Club
| 20 reads | 3.72 |
The Black Volume of the Dead The Black Volume of the Dead
| 0 reads | 0 |
 And Then There Were None
| 960 reads | 4.24 |
 The Secret Keys of Conjure: Unlocking the Mysteries of American Folk Magic
| 0 reads | 0 |
 The Crooked Path: An Introduction to Traditional Witchcraft
| 1 read | 2.5 |
 The Last of the Moon Girls
| 17 reads | 4 |
 Chain of Iron
| 57 reads | 4.3 |
 The Girl Who Drank the Moon
| 125 reads | 4.14 |
 The Silence of the Lambs
| 268 reads | 4.12 |
 Waking the Witch
| 6 reads | 4 |
 Brother
| 64 reads | 3.96 |
 Sharp Objects
| 540 reads | 3.76 |
 The Chalk Man
| 97 reads | 3.67 |
 Red Dragon
| 236 reads | 3.9 |
 The Devil All the Time
| 41 reads | 4 |
 The Hollow Ones
| 14 reads | 3.25 |
 The Turn of the Key
| 185 reads | 3.85 |
 The Magic of Marie Laveau: Embracing the Spiritual Legacy of the Voodoo Queen of New Orleans
| 2 reads | 3 |
 The Shadows
| 59 reads | 3.55 |
 Keeping Her Keys: An Introduction To Hekate's Modern Witchcraft
| 0 reads | 0 |
 The Ghost Tree
| 12 reads | 3.4 |
 Horns
| 144 reads | 3.65 |
 I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings
| 197 reads | 4.15 |
 Coraline
| 723 reads | 4.08 |
 The Green Mile
| 242 reads | 4.24 |
 Lost Roses
| 7 reads | 3.57 |
 Thirteen Storeys
| 20 reads | 3.82 |
 The Dark Tower (The Dark Tower, #7)
| 252 reads | 4.22 |
 Locke & Key, Vol. 1: Welcome to Lovecraft
| 208 reads | 4.04 |
 We Hear Voices
| 2 reads | 2.5 |
 Heart-Shaped Box
| 126 reads | 3.63 |
 Malorie
| 38 reads | 3.5 |
 The Picture of Dorian Gray
| 882 reads | 4.05 |
 The Guest List
| 505 reads | 3.59 |
 Midnight Sun
| 187 reads | 3.45 |
 Orishas, Goddesses, and Voodoo Queens: The Divine Feminine in the African Religious Traditions
| 2 reads | 4 |
 The Family Upstairs
| 188 reads | 3.8 |
 Lock Every Door
| 243 reads | 3.75 |
 Thinner
| 127 reads | 3.27 |
 Conjure Women
| 17 reads | 3.45 |
 Chain of Gold
| 76 reads | 4.48 |
 After the Bridge
| 7 reads | 4.17 |
 Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde
| 599 reads | 3.71 |
 The Whisper Man
| 137 reads | 3.87 |
 Les Misérables
| 261 reads | 4.2 |
 The Stand
| 690 reads | 4.15 |
 1984
| 3,280 reads | 4.2 |
 A Discovery of Witches
| 335 reads | 3.71 |
 The Descent
| 17 reads | 3.88 |
 Psychic Witch
| 1 read | 0 |
 The Fireman
| 78 reads | 3.78 |
 Ghost Story
| 51 reads | 3.66 |
 Plain Bad Heroines
| 53 reads | 3.68 |
 Needful Things
| 212 reads | 3.76 |
 Rose Madder
| 82 reads | 3.44 |
 Six Women of Salem: The Untold Story of the Accused and Their Accusers in the Salem Witch Trials
| 2 reads | 3.5 |