Devi Nair
š±š Read on Kindle | š 320 pages ā± ~4 hours š Read as part of a Book Club pick (February) š·ļø Publisher: Pushkin Vertigo
I tried! Honestly, I did. The Mystery of the Crooked Man had all the ingredients I usually adore: an eccentric protagonist, literary intrigue, and a meta-mystery about a lost manuscript. But twenty percent in, I was still waiting for the story to come alive. Agatha Dorn, despite being pitched as āspiky,ā came across not as deliciously flawed but downright insufferable, like the kind of person who corrects your grammar and drinks the last of your gin while doing it.
Agatha Dorn, our central character, is clearly designed to be āunforgettable,ā but for me, she landed firmly in off-putting territory. Sheās written as unapologetically cold, unsympathetic, and emotionally distant, and while I appreciate flawed characters, I need something to hold onto. Wit, vulnerability, humor, growthā¦ any one of those wouldāve helped. Instead, spending time in Agathaās head felt like work rather than intrigue.
The premise had promise (and the comparisons to The Twyford Code and Magpie Murders make sense), but the pacing felt sluggish, the tone mean-spirited, and I never reached the supposed twist where things finally heat up. Perhaps readers with a higher tolerance for prickly protagonists might find the payoff worth the wait. But I couldnāt hang around long enough to find out. Lifeās too short, and my TBR stack is too tall.
Would I recommend it? Not this time. I love a sharp mystery, but The Mystery of the Crooked Man was more sour than clever for me. I DNF'd at 20%, and it just didnāt click. That doesnāt mean it wonāt work for others. Readers who enjoy deeply abrasive protagonists, slow-burn literary mysteries, or character studies over plot may find more to appreciate here. But if youāre coming for cozy vibes, charm, or early intrigue, this might test your patience. Lifeās too short to force a book that isnāt clicking, and this one just wasnāt for me.
š±š Read on Kindle | š 320 pages ā± ~4 hours š Read as part of a Book Club pick (February) š·ļø Publisher: Pushkin Vertigo
I tried! Honestly, I did. The Mystery of the Crooked Man had all the ingredients I usually adore: an eccentric protagonist, literary intrigue, and a meta-mystery about a lost manuscript. But twenty percent in, I was still waiting for the story to come alive. Agatha Dorn, despite being pitched as āspiky,ā came across not as deliciously flawed but downright insufferable, like the kind of person who corrects your grammar and drinks the last of your gin while doing it.
Agatha Dorn, our central character, is clearly designed to be āunforgettable,ā but for me, she landed firmly in off-putting territory. Sheās written as unapologetically cold, unsympathetic, and emotionally distant, and while I appreciate flawed characters, I need something to hold onto. Wit, vulnerability, humor, growthā¦ any one of those wouldāve helped. Instead, spending time in Agathaās head felt like work rather than intrigue.
The premise had promise (and the comparisons to The Twyford Code and Magpie Murders make sense), but the pacing felt sluggish, the tone mean-spirited, and I never reached the supposed twist where things finally heat up. Perhaps readers with a higher tolerance for prickly protagonists might find the payoff worth the wait. But I couldnāt hang around long enough to find out. Lifeās too short, and my TBR stack is too tall.
Would I recommend it? Not this time. I love a sharp mystery, but The Mystery of the Crooked Man was more sour than clever for me. I DNF'd at 20%, and it just didnāt click. That doesnāt mean it wonāt work for others. Readers who enjoy deeply abrasive protagonists, slow-burn literary mysteries, or character studies over plot may find more to appreciate here. But if youāre coming for cozy vibes, charm, or early intrigue, this might test your patience. Lifeās too short to force a book that isnāt clicking, and this one just wasnāt for me.
š±š Read on Kindle | š 304 pages ā± Approx. 4 hours š ARC provided by Edelweiss š·ļø Publisher: Douglas & McIntyre š Genre: Historical Mystery
Thereās something undeniably fun about a historical mystery that leans fully into its setting, and Curse of the Savoy absolutely does that. Stepping into Curse of the Savoy feels like brushing against the velvet of 1960s London: decadent, smoky, and filled with famous faces behaving badly.From the moment you step inside the Savoy, the novel revels in high society drama, celebrity cameos, and the particular sparkle of 1960s London. Ron Base paints the Savoy with loving precision: you can almost hear the clink of champagne glasses and the low hum of gossip as Alfred Hitchcock trades barbed quips with Cary Grant. Priscilla Tempest remains a compelling guide through this world, juggling hotel politics, demanding guests, and an increasingly complicated murder investigation. Watching her navigate both social expectations and police procedures was one of the strongest parts of the book.
The premise itself is delicious. A cursed dinner party, a superstition involving thirteen diners, and a glamorous guest list that includes real-life icons all set the stage for intrigue. Add in whispers of blackmail, betrayal, and royal interest, and the stakes feel suitably high-profile. The Queenās involvement raises the tension and gives the mystery a broader sense of importance beyond the hotel walls.
But hereās where the novel stumbled for me: length. While the richly textured descriptions built a lush setting, I occasionally found myself wishing for a sharper editorial cut. The mysteryās bones were solid, yet the pacing sagged in the middleālike a soufflĆ© that needed a minute less in the oven. Still, I was hooked enough to see Priscilla through to the final page, even if I probably wonāt follow her into book five. That said, I appreciate how Base throws readers into rooms filled with historical glamour and danger. Itās escapism dressed in haute couture and murder.
Would I recommend it? If you love historical mysteries with strong female leads, glamorous settings, and a heavy dose of real-world celebrity intrigue, this one is worth your time. The Savoy setting is richly drawn, the premise is clever, and Priscilla Tempest is an engaging protagonist. While the pacing kept it from being a standout for me, it was still an entertaining and stylish read. Expect slowāburn suspense and an impeccably dressed lead.
š±š Read on Kindle | š 304 pages ā± Approx. 4 hours š ARC provided by Edelweiss š·ļø Publisher: Douglas & McIntyre š Genre: Historical Mystery
Thereās something undeniably fun about a historical mystery that leans fully into its setting, and Curse of the Savoy absolutely does that. Stepping into Curse of the Savoy feels like brushing against the velvet of 1960s London: decadent, smoky, and filled with famous faces behaving badly.From the moment you step inside the Savoy, the novel revels in high society drama, celebrity cameos, and the particular sparkle of 1960s London. Ron Base paints the Savoy with loving precision: you can almost hear the clink of champagne glasses and the low hum of gossip as Alfred Hitchcock trades barbed quips with Cary Grant. Priscilla Tempest remains a compelling guide through this world, juggling hotel politics, demanding guests, and an increasingly complicated murder investigation. Watching her navigate both social expectations and police procedures was one of the strongest parts of the book.
The premise itself is delicious. A cursed dinner party, a superstition involving thirteen diners, and a glamorous guest list that includes real-life icons all set the stage for intrigue. Add in whispers of blackmail, betrayal, and royal interest, and the stakes feel suitably high-profile. The Queenās involvement raises the tension and gives the mystery a broader sense of importance beyond the hotel walls.
But hereās where the novel stumbled for me: length. While the richly textured descriptions built a lush setting, I occasionally found myself wishing for a sharper editorial cut. The mysteryās bones were solid, yet the pacing sagged in the middleālike a soufflĆ© that needed a minute less in the oven. Still, I was hooked enough to see Priscilla through to the final page, even if I probably wonāt follow her into book five. That said, I appreciate how Base throws readers into rooms filled with historical glamour and danger. Itās escapism dressed in haute couture and murder.
Would I recommend it? If you love historical mysteries with strong female leads, glamorous settings, and a heavy dose of real-world celebrity intrigue, this one is worth your time. The Savoy setting is richly drawn, the premise is clever, and Priscilla Tempest is an engaging protagonist. While the pacing kept it from being a standout for me, it was still an entertaining and stylish read. Expect slowāburn suspense and an impeccably dressed lead.
š±š Read on Kindle | š 212 pages ā± Duration: ~3 hours ARC copy by Edelweiss | š·ļø Publisher: Blair š Release date: June 2, 2026
When we talk about coming-of-age stories, we almost always picture teenagers or twenty-somethings fumbling their way toward adulthood. Fancy Meeting You flips that expectation by giving us a protagonist who is fifty and still figuring herself out, and honestly, thatās its strongest hook. A fifty-year-old woman with a bar tab and a Harvard degree sheās not using is exactly what makes Fancy Meeting You such an intriguing read. Louise Marburg spins a series of vignettes around Laura Harrigan, whose messy imperfections feel painfully and hilariously real. Lauraās voice, equal parts sarcasm and vulnerability, is the glue that holds these episodic encounters together.
Laura herself is acerbic, self-aware, and often entertaining. Her interactions with friends, strangers, and potential love interests are where the book shines most, offering moments of humor and insight in quick bursts. Itās an easy, fast-paced read, structured in a way that makes it ideal for short reading sessions. I found myself curious about where each chapter would take her next, even when I wasnāt emotionally invested in the outcome. Each chapter brings a new connection: a sister she resents, a flirtation that fizzles, a stranger who says far too much. And somewhere between the cheap wine and emotional misfires, Laura starts to evolve. Itās not a neat transformation, but thatās the point. Itās life, in all its blurry, midlife glory.
That said, while the journey is engaging, it doesnāt quite linger. Once finished, the story slips away without leaving a strong emotional or thematic mark. The ideas are interesting, the execution competent, but nothing quite lands with enough weight to feel memorable. Itās enjoyable in the moment, but not a book that follows you around afterward.
Would I recommend it? Enjoyable, smart, and zippy enough to finish in one sitting, but not the kind of story that stays with you once you close the cover. If youāre looking for a quick, character-driven contemporary read with a slightly unconventional angle, Fancy Meeting You is worth a look. Itās smart, readable, and occasionally sharp, even if it doesnāt dig as deeply as it could. I enjoyed the ride, appreciated the perspective, and thenā¦ moved on. Still, for readers who love flawed, funny female protagonists and snapshots of lifeās midlife messiness, itās worth picking up. A solid pick for a palate cleanser between heavier reads, especially if midlife narratives intrigue you.
Originally posted at viewsshewrites.com.
š±š Read on Kindle | š 212 pages ā± Duration: ~3 hours ARC copy by Edelweiss | š·ļø Publisher: Blair š Release date: June 2, 2026
When we talk about coming-of-age stories, we almost always picture teenagers or twenty-somethings fumbling their way toward adulthood. Fancy Meeting You flips that expectation by giving us a protagonist who is fifty and still figuring herself out, and honestly, thatās its strongest hook. A fifty-year-old woman with a bar tab and a Harvard degree sheās not using is exactly what makes Fancy Meeting You such an intriguing read. Louise Marburg spins a series of vignettes around Laura Harrigan, whose messy imperfections feel painfully and hilariously real. Lauraās voice, equal parts sarcasm and vulnerability, is the glue that holds these episodic encounters together.
Laura herself is acerbic, self-aware, and often entertaining. Her interactions with friends, strangers, and potential love interests are where the book shines most, offering moments of humor and insight in quick bursts. Itās an easy, fast-paced read, structured in a way that makes it ideal for short reading sessions. I found myself curious about where each chapter would take her next, even when I wasnāt emotionally invested in the outcome. Each chapter brings a new connection: a sister she resents, a flirtation that fizzles, a stranger who says far too much. And somewhere between the cheap wine and emotional misfires, Laura starts to evolve. Itās not a neat transformation, but thatās the point. Itās life, in all its blurry, midlife glory.
That said, while the journey is engaging, it doesnāt quite linger. Once finished, the story slips away without leaving a strong emotional or thematic mark. The ideas are interesting, the execution competent, but nothing quite lands with enough weight to feel memorable. Itās enjoyable in the moment, but not a book that follows you around afterward.
Would I recommend it? Enjoyable, smart, and zippy enough to finish in one sitting, but not the kind of story that stays with you once you close the cover. If youāre looking for a quick, character-driven contemporary read with a slightly unconventional angle, Fancy Meeting You is worth a look. Itās smart, readable, and occasionally sharp, even if it doesnāt dig as deeply as it could. I enjoyed the ride, appreciated the perspective, and thenā¦ moved on. Still, for readers who love flawed, funny female protagonists and snapshots of lifeās midlife messiness, itās worth picking up. A solid pick for a palate cleanser between heavier reads, especially if midlife narratives intrigue you.
Originally posted at viewsshewrites.com.
š±š Read on Kindle | š 304 pages ā± Approx. 4 hours reading time š·ļø Publisher: Crooked Lane Books š Release Date: June 9, 2026 š ARC provided by NetGalley š Genre: Cozy Mystery
Eva Gates shakes things up in Whose Body in the Library, and longtime fans like me definitely feel it. Swapping out Lucyās familiar first-person narration for a dual POV approach, mostly following newcomer Nichelle, makes this entry feel like walking through your own house but finding the furniture rearranged. Everythingās recognizable, yet slightly off-kilter. Lucyās still around, juggling motherhood and library management, but the emotional center shifts to Nichelleās family drama and her rocky first week surrounded by suspicious small-town secrets.
For longtime readers, that shift is jarring. We know the town, the people, and their secrets, but Nichelle doesnāt, and those gaps arenāt filled in. Familiar characters feel oddly distant, and the emotional shorthand that usually makes this series so cozy just isnāt there. Nichelleās arc is intriguing. A woman confronting a past she thought was buried thirty-eight years ago, but the pacing and investigative beats donāt quite land with the same cozy confidence as previous installments. The addition of Detective Rhonda Thomas, who is rigid and rule-bound in contrast to the easygoing Sam Watson, further unsettles the balance. Her treatment of Lucy, in particular, left me uneasy and not especially excited to see her stick around.
The mystery itself, centered on Nichelleās long-estranged father and the unsettling legacy he left behind, has solid bones, but the execution felt rough. Nichelleās lack of sleuthing experience is understandable, yet the investigation and resolution never fully clicked. Itās like driving a familiar road and suddenly realizing the seatās been adjusted just enough to throw everything off. I wanted to love this one more than I did, but it didnāt quite settle into place. Still, Eva Gatesā atmospheric details and character warmth shine through. Even when the mystery falters, the Outer Banks charm and community affection keep you turning pages. And one slightly off installment in a long-running series as consistent as this? Hardly a dealbreaker.
Would I recommend it? A solid, if uneven, addition to the Lighthouse Library Mysteries. As a standalone or a transitional book, it works, but as a longtime fan of this series, it felt off in ways I couldnāt ignore. That said, one uneven entry wonāt shake my loyalty to Eva Gates (aka Vicki Delany). Iāll absolutely be back for the next installment, hopeful that Lucy returns to center stage and the series finds its familiar rhythm again. If youāre curious to see life at the library through fresh eyes, add this to your TBR. Longtime fans may feel conflicted, but Iām not giving up on this lighthouse just yet.
Originally posted at viewsshewrites.com.
š±š Read on Kindle | š 304 pages ā± Approx. 4 hours reading time š·ļø Publisher: Crooked Lane Books š Release Date: June 9, 2026 š ARC provided by NetGalley š Genre: Cozy Mystery
Eva Gates shakes things up in Whose Body in the Library, and longtime fans like me definitely feel it. Swapping out Lucyās familiar first-person narration for a dual POV approach, mostly following newcomer Nichelle, makes this entry feel like walking through your own house but finding the furniture rearranged. Everythingās recognizable, yet slightly off-kilter. Lucyās still around, juggling motherhood and library management, but the emotional center shifts to Nichelleās family drama and her rocky first week surrounded by suspicious small-town secrets.
For longtime readers, that shift is jarring. We know the town, the people, and their secrets, but Nichelle doesnāt, and those gaps arenāt filled in. Familiar characters feel oddly distant, and the emotional shorthand that usually makes this series so cozy just isnāt there. Nichelleās arc is intriguing. A woman confronting a past she thought was buried thirty-eight years ago, but the pacing and investigative beats donāt quite land with the same cozy confidence as previous installments. The addition of Detective Rhonda Thomas, who is rigid and rule-bound in contrast to the easygoing Sam Watson, further unsettles the balance. Her treatment of Lucy, in particular, left me uneasy and not especially excited to see her stick around.
The mystery itself, centered on Nichelleās long-estranged father and the unsettling legacy he left behind, has solid bones, but the execution felt rough. Nichelleās lack of sleuthing experience is understandable, yet the investigation and resolution never fully clicked. Itās like driving a familiar road and suddenly realizing the seatās been adjusted just enough to throw everything off. I wanted to love this one more than I did, but it didnāt quite settle into place. Still, Eva Gatesā atmospheric details and character warmth shine through. Even when the mystery falters, the Outer Banks charm and community affection keep you turning pages. And one slightly off installment in a long-running series as consistent as this? Hardly a dealbreaker.
Would I recommend it? A solid, if uneven, addition to the Lighthouse Library Mysteries. As a standalone or a transitional book, it works, but as a longtime fan of this series, it felt off in ways I couldnāt ignore. That said, one uneven entry wonāt shake my loyalty to Eva Gates (aka Vicki Delany). Iāll absolutely be back for the next installment, hopeful that Lucy returns to center stage and the series finds its familiar rhythm again. If youāre curious to see life at the library through fresh eyes, add this to your TBR. Longtime fans may feel conflicted, but Iām not giving up on this lighthouse just yet.
Originally posted at viewsshewrites.com.
š±š Read on Kindle š 336 pages | ā±ļø Approx. 4 hours š·ļø Publisher: Dutton | š Publication date: April 28, 2026 āØ ARC provided by Edelweiss šļø Genre: Mystery
āI drink my coffee dark, just like my soulā hits very differently after this one. When my Edelweiss ARC for book three landed, I thought rereading book two would help me ease back into Castle Knoll. Reader, I was unprepared anyway. This is hands-down the darkest, most diabolical entry in the series so far, and I mean that as the highest compliment.
Kristen Perrin leans hard into the psychological here. Francesās diaries arenāt just atmospheric; theyāre unsettling, intimate, and emotionally loaded. Watching her relationship with Ford deepen, understanding why they eventually choose each other after everything theyāve endured, adds so much heart to an otherwise cerebral, mind-bending mystery. Meanwhile, Annieās storyline ramps up the stakes in real time as she pieces together the horrifying link between her motherās present-day danger and Francesās long-buried past.
Perrin crafts a masterclass: Vivid diary narration lets Annie smartly link clues, looping in cop Rowan Crane transparently. No dumb secrets, just team backup. Their synergy cracks the case sharper than solo sleuths in lesser mysteries. The ending teases #4's escalation. I'm hooked. This 336-page ebook flew by in 4 hours, proving ARC hype for Dutton's April 2026 release. This isnāt cozy. Not even close. But it is gripping, emotionally rich, and impossible to put down.
Would I recommend it? Loved this the best in the Castle Knoll Files so far. If youāve been following the Castle Knoll Files, this is the standout instalment. This is the one where Perrin fully flexes her storytelling muscles. Dark, layered, emotionally sharp, and deeply satisfying, this book proves the series isnāt afraid to evolve beyond its cozy roots. Add this to your TBR and mark the date on your calendar. Can't wait for more Annie and Frances!
Originally posted at viewsshewrites.com.
š±š Read on Kindle š 336 pages | ā±ļø Approx. 4 hours š·ļø Publisher: Dutton | š Publication date: April 28, 2026 āØ ARC provided by Edelweiss šļø Genre: Mystery
āI drink my coffee dark, just like my soulā hits very differently after this one. When my Edelweiss ARC for book three landed, I thought rereading book two would help me ease back into Castle Knoll. Reader, I was unprepared anyway. This is hands-down the darkest, most diabolical entry in the series so far, and I mean that as the highest compliment.
Kristen Perrin leans hard into the psychological here. Francesās diaries arenāt just atmospheric; theyāre unsettling, intimate, and emotionally loaded. Watching her relationship with Ford deepen, understanding why they eventually choose each other after everything theyāve endured, adds so much heart to an otherwise cerebral, mind-bending mystery. Meanwhile, Annieās storyline ramps up the stakes in real time as she pieces together the horrifying link between her motherās present-day danger and Francesās long-buried past.
Perrin crafts a masterclass: Vivid diary narration lets Annie smartly link clues, looping in cop Rowan Crane transparently. No dumb secrets, just team backup. Their synergy cracks the case sharper than solo sleuths in lesser mysteries. The ending teases #4's escalation. I'm hooked. This 336-page ebook flew by in 4 hours, proving ARC hype for Dutton's April 2026 release. This isnāt cozy. Not even close. But it is gripping, emotionally rich, and impossible to put down.
Would I recommend it? Loved this the best in the Castle Knoll Files so far. If youāve been following the Castle Knoll Files, this is the standout instalment. This is the one where Perrin fully flexes her storytelling muscles. Dark, layered, emotionally sharp, and deeply satisfying, this book proves the series isnāt afraid to evolve beyond its cozy roots. Add this to your TBR and mark the date on your calendar. Can't wait for more Annie and Frances!
Originally posted at viewsshewrites.com.
š§ Listened in audio | ā± Duration: 9 hours š¢ Narrated by Alexandra Dowling & Jessica Hayles š·ļø Publisher: Books on Tape & Dutton | š Published: April 29, 2025 š Genre: Mystery
Weāre back in Castle Knoll, and Kristen Perrin hasnāt lost a step. How to Seal Your Own Fate once again delivers the dual timelines that made the first book sparkle. We follow Frances and her great-niece Annie as two investigations unfold decades apart, each one carefully braided into the other. Annie, fresh off the events of How to Solve Your Own Murder, feels noticeably more confident, both as a sleuth and as the reluctant heir to her great auntās legacy. That growth grounds the present-day storyline and gives the series a strong sense of forward momentum.
Francesās world unravels through her diaries, adding an emotional weight that deepens her character beyond the sharp-tongued amateur sleuth we met before. Her relationships with Archie Foyle and Ford Gravesdown walk that perfect line between heartbreak and intrigue, and Peony Laneās expanded story gives the whole world a richer, more haunting texture. The emotional tension between who Frances was and who she becomes is handled with care, especially through her diaries. Peony Lane also steps fully into the spotlight, her backstory adding emotional weight and moral complexity. What initially feels like two disconnected mysteries (the Gravesdown family deaths and Peony Laneās murder) slowly reveals itself as something far more intertwined.
Alexandra Dowling and Jessica Hayles bring real nuance to their narration. Dowling embodies Francesās steady resolve and old-world grace, while Hayles captures Annieās pragmatic edge and emotional curiosity. The tonal contrast keeps the timelines crystal clear with no confusion about whether weāre in 1967 or the present day. Yes, the pacing dips in places, especially mid-book, but itās easy to forgive when the payoffs land. Perrin allows the mystery to breathe; she trusts the story to unravel slowly, letting grief, ambition, and fate braid together. Thereās something darker simmering here than most cozy mysteries dare to touch, and I, for one, love that shadow creeping in.
Would I recommend it? How to Seal Your Own Fate is the kind of cozy mystery that balances quaint charm with literary intrigue, warm but shadowy, witty but melancholic, especially if you enjoyed How to Solve Your Own Murder.. Itās not reinventing the genre, but it doesnāt need to. Sometimes, a good mystery is less about new tricks and more about good company, and Annie and Frances make fine company, indeed. If youāre invested in Castle Knoll and curious to see Annie carve out her own destiny, this is well worth your time.
š§ Listened in audio | ā± Duration: 9 hours š¢ Narrated by Alexandra Dowling & Jessica Hayles š·ļø Publisher: Books on Tape & Dutton | š Published: April 29, 2025 š Genre: Mystery
Weāre back in Castle Knoll, and Kristen Perrin hasnāt lost a step. How to Seal Your Own Fate once again delivers the dual timelines that made the first book sparkle. We follow Frances and her great-niece Annie as two investigations unfold decades apart, each one carefully braided into the other. Annie, fresh off the events of How to Solve Your Own Murder, feels noticeably more confident, both as a sleuth and as the reluctant heir to her great auntās legacy. That growth grounds the present-day storyline and gives the series a strong sense of forward momentum.
Francesās world unravels through her diaries, adding an emotional weight that deepens her character beyond the sharp-tongued amateur sleuth we met before. Her relationships with Archie Foyle and Ford Gravesdown walk that perfect line between heartbreak and intrigue, and Peony Laneās expanded story gives the whole world a richer, more haunting texture. The emotional tension between who Frances was and who she becomes is handled with care, especially through her diaries. Peony Lane also steps fully into the spotlight, her backstory adding emotional weight and moral complexity. What initially feels like two disconnected mysteries (the Gravesdown family deaths and Peony Laneās murder) slowly reveals itself as something far more intertwined.
Alexandra Dowling and Jessica Hayles bring real nuance to their narration. Dowling embodies Francesās steady resolve and old-world grace, while Hayles captures Annieās pragmatic edge and emotional curiosity. The tonal contrast keeps the timelines crystal clear with no confusion about whether weāre in 1967 or the present day. Yes, the pacing dips in places, especially mid-book, but itās easy to forgive when the payoffs land. Perrin allows the mystery to breathe; she trusts the story to unravel slowly, letting grief, ambition, and fate braid together. Thereās something darker simmering here than most cozy mysteries dare to touch, and I, for one, love that shadow creeping in.
Would I recommend it? How to Seal Your Own Fate is the kind of cozy mystery that balances quaint charm with literary intrigue, warm but shadowy, witty but melancholic, especially if you enjoyed How to Solve Your Own Murder.. Itās not reinventing the genre, but it doesnāt need to. Sometimes, a good mystery is less about new tricks and more about good company, and Annie and Frances make fine company, indeed. If youāre invested in Castle Knoll and curious to see Annie carve out her own destiny, this is well worth your time.
Updated a reading goal:
Read 300 books in 2026
Progress so far: 75 / 300 25%
š§ Listened in audio | ā± Duration: 9 hours š¢ Narrated by Alexandra Dowling & Jessica Hayles š·ļø Publisher: Books on Tape & Dutton | š Published: April 29, 2025 š Genre: Cozy Mystery
Kristen Perrin returns to Castle Knoll with another dual-timeline mystery, and while the structure itself isnāt new, the execution is confident enough to keep me firmly invested. How to Seal Your Own Fate carries that same Castle Knoll charm and danger we loved from How to Solve Your Own Murder, but with even deeper emotional threads. The dual timelines feel richer this time around. Francesās 1967 story has that smoky, old-English-village melancholy, while Annieās present-day storyline feels brisk, confident, and more self-assured, like sheās finally stepping into her own legacy rather than living in her auntās shadow.
What truly elevates the audiobook experience is the dual narration. Alexandra Dowling and Jessica Hayles donāt just split timelines, they give Frances and Annie distinct emotional textures. Their differences in tone, pacing, and delivery make it instantly clear whether weāre in the past or present, eliminating any confusion that dual timelines sometimes bring. Even beyond clarity, the narration reinforces generational contrasts, highlighting how Frances and Annie approach danger, power, and identity very differently.
That said, there are moments where the pacing dips, particularly in sections that linger a bit too long on exposition. Still, the overall narrative strength outweighs these slower stretches. More importantly, this book feels like a bridge rather than a standalone mystery. It deepens the emotional arc of Annieās journey toward self-definition, separate from her great auntās shadow. And thatās what makes me want to keep going with this series.
Would I recommend it? How to Seal Your Own Fate is the kind of cozy mystery that balances quaint charm with literary intrigue, warm but shadowy, witty but melancholic, especially if you enjoyed How to Solve Your Own Murder.. Itās not reinventing the genre, but it doesnāt need to. Sometimes, a good mystery is less about new tricks and more about good company, and Annie and Frances make fine company, indeed. If youāre invested in Castle Knoll and curious to see Annie carve out her own destiny, this is well worth your time.
š§ Listened in audio | ā± Duration: 9 hours š¢ Narrated by Alexandra Dowling & Jessica Hayles š·ļø Publisher: Books on Tape & Dutton | š Published: April 29, 2025 š Genre: Cozy Mystery
Kristen Perrin returns to Castle Knoll with another dual-timeline mystery, and while the structure itself isnāt new, the execution is confident enough to keep me firmly invested. How to Seal Your Own Fate carries that same Castle Knoll charm and danger we loved from How to Solve Your Own Murder, but with even deeper emotional threads. The dual timelines feel richer this time around. Francesās 1967 story has that smoky, old-English-village melancholy, while Annieās present-day storyline feels brisk, confident, and more self-assured, like sheās finally stepping into her own legacy rather than living in her auntās shadow.
What truly elevates the audiobook experience is the dual narration. Alexandra Dowling and Jessica Hayles donāt just split timelines, they give Frances and Annie distinct emotional textures. Their differences in tone, pacing, and delivery make it instantly clear whether weāre in the past or present, eliminating any confusion that dual timelines sometimes bring. Even beyond clarity, the narration reinforces generational contrasts, highlighting how Frances and Annie approach danger, power, and identity very differently.
That said, there are moments where the pacing dips, particularly in sections that linger a bit too long on exposition. Still, the overall narrative strength outweighs these slower stretches. More importantly, this book feels like a bridge rather than a standalone mystery. It deepens the emotional arc of Annieās journey toward self-definition, separate from her great auntās shadow. And thatās what makes me want to keep going with this series.
Would I recommend it? How to Seal Your Own Fate is the kind of cozy mystery that balances quaint charm with literary intrigue, warm but shadowy, witty but melancholic, especially if you enjoyed How to Solve Your Own Murder.. Itās not reinventing the genre, but it doesnāt need to. Sometimes, a good mystery is less about new tricks and more about good company, and Annie and Frances make fine company, indeed. If youāre invested in Castle Knoll and curious to see Annie carve out her own destiny, this is well worth your time.
š±š Read on Kindle | š 248 pages | ā± 3 hours š·ļø Publisher: Twitching Whisker Press š Publication date: May 4, 2026 š ARC provided by the author
This is a true blue cozy mystery, ticking every box that cozy readers love. When I say this book nails the cozy mystery formula, I mean check, check, check. Small town? Check. A wealthy but introverted heroine? Check. A best friend framed for murder? Absolutely. Add in a bakery at the center of the chaos, a parade of quirky townsfolk, and an assortment of furry and feathery sidekicks, and youāve got a setup that feels instantly familiar in the best way. Kate McGregor is the kind of cozy protagonist many readers quietly aspire to be. Sheās well-off, introverted, creatively inclined, and happiest sharing space with animals and a trusted best friend. But when her best friend becomes the prime suspect, Kateās loyalty (and nosiness) win out. Her relationship with Cindy is the emotional backbone of the story.
Taffy Beach paints Manatee Bay with a warm, shimmering brush. Itās the kind of town that feels real, complete with gossip networks disguised as book clubs and neighbors who simultaneously annoy and protect each other. The dialogue sparkles with Southern flair, and the pacing flows as gently as the tide, though occasionally it lingers a bit too long on description. Still, I found myself soaking it all in like sunshine on a slow afternoon. Even when Kate insists she dislikes the townās nosiness, thereās an undercurrent of protectiveness that makes Manatee Bay feel like a place worth returning to. The mystery itself wraps up cleanly, satisfying both the mystery-minded and the cozy-hearted. The final chapter hints at deeper family secrets to come, which has me already watching the calendar for book two. With five more releases planned, this one promises the start of a series thatāll keep cozy fans well-fed and beach-dreaming.
Would I recommend it? If you love classic cozy mysteries with a beachy twist, this is the kind of book that feels comforting without being dull, familiar without being lazy. Despite a few pacing hiccups, I genuinely enjoyed my time in Manatee Bay and Iām invested in seeing where Kate McGregorās story goes next. This is a warm, comforting coastal mystery with just enough bite to keep it interesting. If youāre looking for a warm, animal-filled, bakery-adjacent cozy with an introverted sleuth at its heart, add this to your TBR and mark the release date.š±š Read on Kindle | š 248 pages | ā± 3 hours š·ļø Publisher: Twitching Whisker Press š Publication date: May 4, 2026 š ARC provided by the author
This is a true blue cozy mystery, ticking every box that cozy readers love. When I say this book nails the cozy mystery formula, I mean check, check, check. Small town? Check. A wealthy but introverted heroine? Check. A best friend framed for murder? Absolutely. Add in a bakery at the center of the chaos, a parade of quirky townsfolk, and an assortment of furry and feathery sidekicks, and youāve got a setup that feels instantly familiar in the best way. Kate McGregor is the kind of cozy protagonist many readers quietly aspire to be. Sheās well-off, introverted, creatively inclined, and happiest sharing space with animals and a trusted best friend. But when her best friend becomes the prime suspect, Kateās loyalty (and nosiness) win out. Her relationship with Cindy is the emotional backbone of the story.
Taffy Beach paints Manatee Bay with a warm, shimmering brush. Itās the kind of town that feels real, complete with gossip networks disguised as book clubs and neighbors who simultaneously annoy and protect each other. The dialogue sparkles with Southern flair, and the pacing flows as gently as the tide, though occasionally it lingers a bit too long on description. Still, I found myself soaking it all in like sunshine on a slow afternoon. Even when Kate insists she dislikes the townās nosiness, thereās an undercurrent of protectiveness that makes Manatee Bay feel like a place worth returning to. The mystery itself wraps up cleanly, satisfying both the mystery-minded and the cozy-hearted. The final chapter hints at deeper family secrets to come, which has me already watching the calendar for book two. With five more releases planned, this one promises the start of a series thatāll keep cozy fans well-fed and beach-dreaming.
Would I recommend it? If you love classic cozy mysteries with a beachy twist, this is the kind of book that feels comforting without being dull, familiar without being lazy. Despite a few pacing hiccups, I genuinely enjoyed my time in Manatee Bay and Iām invested in seeing where Kate McGregorās story goes next. This is a warm, comforting coastal mystery with just enough bite to keep it interesting. If youāre looking for a warm, animal-filled, bakery-adjacent cozy with an introverted sleuth at its heart, add this to your TBR and mark the release date.
Originally posted at www.viewsshewrites.com.
š±š Read on Kindle | š 248 pages | ā± 3 hours š·ļø Publisher: Twitching Whisker Press š Publication date: May 4, 2026 š ARC provided by the author
This is a true blue cozy mystery, ticking every box that cozy readers love. When I say this book nails the cozy mystery formula, I mean check, check, check. Small town? Check. A wealthy but introverted heroine? Check. A best friend framed for murder? Absolutely. Add in a bakery at the center of the chaos, a parade of quirky townsfolk, and an assortment of furry and feathery sidekicks, and youāve got a setup that feels instantly familiar in the best way. Kate McGregor is the kind of cozy protagonist many readers quietly aspire to be. Sheās well-off, introverted, creatively inclined, and happiest sharing space with animals and a trusted best friend. But when her best friend becomes the prime suspect, Kateās loyalty (and nosiness) win out. Her relationship with Cindy is the emotional backbone of the story.
Taffy Beach paints Manatee Bay with a warm, shimmering brush. Itās the kind of town that feels real, complete with gossip networks disguised as book clubs and neighbors who simultaneously annoy and protect each other. The dialogue sparkles with Southern flair, and the pacing flows as gently as the tide, though occasionally it lingers a bit too long on description. Still, I found myself soaking it all in like sunshine on a slow afternoon. Even when Kate insists she dislikes the townās nosiness, thereās an undercurrent of protectiveness that makes Manatee Bay feel like a place worth returning to. The mystery itself wraps up cleanly, satisfying both the mystery-minded and the cozy-hearted. The final chapter hints at deeper family secrets to come, which has me already watching the calendar for book two. With five more releases planned, this one promises the start of a series thatāll keep cozy fans well-fed and beach-dreaming.
Would I recommend it? If you love classic cozy mysteries with a beachy twist, this is the kind of book that feels comforting without being dull, familiar without being lazy. Despite a few pacing hiccups, I genuinely enjoyed my time in Manatee Bay and Iām invested in seeing where Kate McGregorās story goes next. This is a warm, comforting coastal mystery with just enough bite to keep it interesting. If youāre looking for a warm, animal-filled, bakery-adjacent cozy with an introverted sleuth at its heart, add this to your TBR and mark the release date.š±š Read on Kindle | š 248 pages | ā± 3 hours š·ļø Publisher: Twitching Whisker Press š Publication date: May 4, 2026 š ARC provided by the author
This is a true blue cozy mystery, ticking every box that cozy readers love. When I say this book nails the cozy mystery formula, I mean check, check, check. Small town? Check. A wealthy but introverted heroine? Check. A best friend framed for murder? Absolutely. Add in a bakery at the center of the chaos, a parade of quirky townsfolk, and an assortment of furry and feathery sidekicks, and youāve got a setup that feels instantly familiar in the best way. Kate McGregor is the kind of cozy protagonist many readers quietly aspire to be. Sheās well-off, introverted, creatively inclined, and happiest sharing space with animals and a trusted best friend. But when her best friend becomes the prime suspect, Kateās loyalty (and nosiness) win out. Her relationship with Cindy is the emotional backbone of the story.
Taffy Beach paints Manatee Bay with a warm, shimmering brush. Itās the kind of town that feels real, complete with gossip networks disguised as book clubs and neighbors who simultaneously annoy and protect each other. The dialogue sparkles with Southern flair, and the pacing flows as gently as the tide, though occasionally it lingers a bit too long on description. Still, I found myself soaking it all in like sunshine on a slow afternoon. Even when Kate insists she dislikes the townās nosiness, thereās an undercurrent of protectiveness that makes Manatee Bay feel like a place worth returning to. The mystery itself wraps up cleanly, satisfying both the mystery-minded and the cozy-hearted. The final chapter hints at deeper family secrets to come, which has me already watching the calendar for book two. With five more releases planned, this one promises the start of a series thatāll keep cozy fans well-fed and beach-dreaming.
Would I recommend it? If you love classic cozy mysteries with a beachy twist, this is the kind of book that feels comforting without being dull, familiar without being lazy. Despite a few pacing hiccups, I genuinely enjoyed my time in Manatee Bay and Iām invested in seeing where Kate McGregorās story goes next. This is a warm, comforting coastal mystery with just enough bite to keep it interesting. If youāre looking for a warm, animal-filled, bakery-adjacent cozy with an introverted sleuth at its heart, add this to your TBR and mark the release date.
Originally posted at www.viewsshewrites.com.
š±š Read on Kindle š 229 pages | ā± Approx. 2.5 hours š Read as part of the AāZ Cozy Mystery Challenge š·ļø Publisher: Carina Press | šļø Published: April 4, 2016 š Genre: Cozy Mystery
This one leans into cozy with a capital C. Set inside a retirement community, Permanently Booked leans heavily into character-driven charm rather than twisty plotting, and honestly? That works in its favor. Dorothy is every bit the sharp-eyed Miss Marple type, and watching her bounce off younger, spontaneous Summer gives the story real charm. Their unlikely partnership is the bookās heartbeat.
The mystery itself about the murder of a librarian found literally buried in books, is fresh and clever, but what stood out most was how thoroughly explained everything is. Clues, motivations, character dynamics, nothing is rushed or left dangling. This is a book that wants you to relax while reading it. Thereās no mental gymnastics required, which made it incredibly easy to sink into. The simple language and steady pacing give it a soft, welcoming feel that makes it accessible to readers of all ages. The writing is simple and clear, like a sunny afternoon read with a tall glass of lemonade.
What really elevates this story is the atmosphere. The warmth of the retirement community, the petty politics, the book club drama, all adds a light, slightly silly layer that keeps the story engaging even when the mystery itself is straightforward. If you love the community vibes of The Thursday Murder Club or enjoyed the observational humor in The Man on the Inside, this will feel like slipping into a familiar, well-loved armchair.
Would you recommend it? This is a warm, low-stakes mystery perfect for readers who love gentle humor, found family dynamics, and whodunits that never get too grim. This is the kind of mystery you pick up when you donāt want to think too hard, just enjoy good company and gentle sleuthing. The over-explanation (which I personally loved) makes it perfect for comfort reading, palate cleansing between heavier books, or introducing someone new to the cozy mystery genre. Add it to your TBR if youāre craving something that feels like sunshine and sass poured into a mystery novel.
š±š Read on Kindle š 229 pages | ā± Approx. 2.5 hours š Read as part of the AāZ Cozy Mystery Challenge š·ļø Publisher: Carina Press | šļø Published: April 4, 2016 š Genre: Cozy Mystery
This one leans into cozy with a capital C. Set inside a retirement community, Permanently Booked leans heavily into character-driven charm rather than twisty plotting, and honestly? That works in its favor. Dorothy is every bit the sharp-eyed Miss Marple type, and watching her bounce off younger, spontaneous Summer gives the story real charm. Their unlikely partnership is the bookās heartbeat.
The mystery itself about the murder of a librarian found literally buried in books, is fresh and clever, but what stood out most was how thoroughly explained everything is. Clues, motivations, character dynamics, nothing is rushed or left dangling. This is a book that wants you to relax while reading it. Thereās no mental gymnastics required, which made it incredibly easy to sink into. The simple language and steady pacing give it a soft, welcoming feel that makes it accessible to readers of all ages. The writing is simple and clear, like a sunny afternoon read with a tall glass of lemonade.
What really elevates this story is the atmosphere. The warmth of the retirement community, the petty politics, the book club drama, all adds a light, slightly silly layer that keeps the story engaging even when the mystery itself is straightforward. If you love the community vibes of The Thursday Murder Club or enjoyed the observational humor in The Man on the Inside, this will feel like slipping into a familiar, well-loved armchair.
Would you recommend it? This is a warm, low-stakes mystery perfect for readers who love gentle humor, found family dynamics, and whodunits that never get too grim. This is the kind of mystery you pick up when you donāt want to think too hard, just enjoy good company and gentle sleuthing. The over-explanation (which I personally loved) makes it perfect for comfort reading, palate cleansing between heavier books, or introducing someone new to the cozy mystery genre. Add it to your TBR if youāre craving something that feels like sunshine and sass poured into a mystery novel.
š§ Listened in audio š¢ Narrated by Samara MacLaren ā± Duration: 10 hours š·ļø Publisher: Books on Tape & Berkley š Published on: July 15, 2025 š§ Genre: Paranormal Cozy Mystery
Sangu Mandanna is one of those writers who sneaks up on your heart while youāre busy admiring the cozy vibes. Yes, this book has magic, an inn, a talking fox, and all the comforting paranormal trappings I crave, but what it really delivers is an emotional reckoning. I cried. Repeatedly. Not because of spellwork or danger, but because Sera Swanās journey is painfully, beautifully human. Watching her realize that she is stronger, more capable, and more worthy than she ever allowed herself to believe felt like being gently shaken awake. This isnāt about becoming powerful again. Itās about recognizing the power that was always there.
After The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches, I was already sold on Mandannaās storytelling, but this book somehow goes even deeper. Seraās arc through self-doubt, despair, grief, and finally grit is quietly transformative. This is a fairy tale where the princess realizes the savior sheās been waiting for is herself. No dramatic grandstanding. Just the steady, hard-earned courage to stand up for her identity, her people, and her place in the world.
Mandanna also weaves in themes that hit close to home: queer relationships treated with warmth and normalcy, the insecurity immigrants feel even in places they love, and the damage caused by casually ridiculing someoneās identity. Again and again, the book shows how people build protective shells just to survive, sometimes losing themselves along the way. The message is clear without ever being preachy: be kind, be accepting, and let people be who they are. Itās cozy, yes, but itās also quietly radical.
Audiobook Love Samara MacLaren deserves a standing ovation. Every emotion Sangu Mandanna put on the page is fully realized in the narration. Seraās vulnerability, Aunt Jasmineās warmth, the foxās mischief, the ache and hope threaded through the story, itās all there. This is one of those audiobooks where narration and story elevate each other into something genuinely special.
Would I recommend it? A Witchās Guide to Magical Innkeeping will charm fans of magical realism and found family tales alike. Itās heartfelt, wise, and restorative in the best way possible. This is a book to read, listen to, re-read, and press lovingly into the hands of anyone wrestling with self-doubt. Itās cozy without being shallow, emotional without being heavy, and magical in the most grounded, affirming way. If youāve ever waited for someone else to save you, this story gently reminds you that you donāt need saving. You are the light. You are the magic. You are the savior.
š§ Listened in audio š¢ Narrated by Samara MacLaren ā± Duration: 10 hours š·ļø Publisher: Books on Tape & Berkley š Published on: July 15, 2025 š§ Genre: Paranormal Cozy Mystery
Sangu Mandanna is one of those writers who sneaks up on your heart while youāre busy admiring the cozy vibes. Yes, this book has magic, an inn, a talking fox, and all the comforting paranormal trappings I crave, but what it really delivers is an emotional reckoning. I cried. Repeatedly. Not because of spellwork or danger, but because Sera Swanās journey is painfully, beautifully human. Watching her realize that she is stronger, more capable, and more worthy than she ever allowed herself to believe felt like being gently shaken awake. This isnāt about becoming powerful again. Itās about recognizing the power that was always there.
After The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches, I was already sold on Mandannaās storytelling, but this book somehow goes even deeper. Seraās arc through self-doubt, despair, grief, and finally grit is quietly transformative. This is a fairy tale where the princess realizes the savior sheās been waiting for is herself. No dramatic grandstanding. Just the steady, hard-earned courage to stand up for her identity, her people, and her place in the world.
Mandanna also weaves in themes that hit close to home: queer relationships treated with warmth and normalcy, the insecurity immigrants feel even in places they love, and the damage caused by casually ridiculing someoneās identity. Again and again, the book shows how people build protective shells just to survive, sometimes losing themselves along the way. The message is clear without ever being preachy: be kind, be accepting, and let people be who they are. Itās cozy, yes, but itās also quietly radical.
Audiobook Love Samara MacLaren deserves a standing ovation. Every emotion Sangu Mandanna put on the page is fully realized in the narration. Seraās vulnerability, Aunt Jasmineās warmth, the foxās mischief, the ache and hope threaded through the story, itās all there. This is one of those audiobooks where narration and story elevate each other into something genuinely special.
Would I recommend it? A Witchās Guide to Magical Innkeeping will charm fans of magical realism and found family tales alike. Itās heartfelt, wise, and restorative in the best way possible. This is a book to read, listen to, re-read, and press lovingly into the hands of anyone wrestling with self-doubt. Itās cozy without being shallow, emotional without being heavy, and magical in the most grounded, affirming way. If youāve ever waited for someone else to save you, this story gently reminds you that you donāt need saving. You are the light. You are the magic. You are the savior.
š§ Listened in audio š¢ Narrated by Kristin Atherton ā± Duration: 12 hours š·ļø Publisher: Embla Books, Bonnier Books UK Genre: Cozy Mystery
Although this is classified as a cozy mystery, Iād actually slot A Murder of Crows into the ānear cozyā category. It carries a darker undercurrent than your typical tea-and-scones whodunit, with a moody thread of suspense wrapped around a deceptively gentle setting., but it never overshadows the charm or warmth of the narrative.Dr. Nell Ward is instantly likable, with her genuine curiosity, moral center, and sharp observational skills. I couldnāt help but root for her, even when she stumbled into trouble (as one does when dead bodies and manor tunnels are involved).
One of my absolute favorite parts? The bats. Yes, bats. Sarah Yarwood-Lovettās research shines here: the descriptions of habitats, behavior, and even theirā¦ pooping habits are surprisingly captivating. The research shines, and it never once feels forced. Itās seamlessly tied into the story, letting the science complement the mystery instead of overshadowing it. By the end, I was practically a bat enthusiast. But donāt worry, even if you arenāt into bats, the layered murder mystery and well-timed plot twists will keep you hooked. Nellās balancing act between her ecological work, the mystery, and the budding attention from Adam and DI James adds depth to her character, making her incredibly relatable.
The narration by Kristin Atherton deserves a shout-out. She nails both the upper-class and working-class British accents, making every character vivid and believable. I also appreciated the nuanced portrayal of upper-class characters. Theyāre not the typical snooty stereotypes but genuinely kind and engaging. With a rescued bat and an adorable cat thrown into the mix, this book blends eco-conscious themes with cozy mystery elements seamlessly.
The pacing, however, wavered a bit. At just over 12 hours, a few sections couldāve flown by faster, trim a chapter or two, and this might have been a perfect listen. Still, between the character development, layered mystery, and eco-friendly touches, itās an engaging start to a promising series.A Murder of Crows is a confident start to a series Iāll absolutely keep reading.
Would I recommend it? Even with its darker turns, this near-cozy mystery delivers on charm, intrigue, and ecological insight. Dr. Nell Ward is a protagonist youāll want to follow, and Kristin Athertonās narration brings the perfect touch. Iām already eagerly anticipating the next book in the series. Itās smart, atmospheric, and full of heart (and bats). A little darker than your standard cozy, but thatās part of its appeal. Perfect for fans of intelligent mysteries with a strong environmental edge.
š§ Listened in audio š¢ Narrated by Kristin Atherton ā± Duration: 12 hours š·ļø Publisher: Embla Books, Bonnier Books UK Genre: Cozy Mystery
Although this is classified as a cozy mystery, Iād actually slot A Murder of Crows into the ānear cozyā category. It carries a darker undercurrent than your typical tea-and-scones whodunit, with a moody thread of suspense wrapped around a deceptively gentle setting., but it never overshadows the charm or warmth of the narrative.Dr. Nell Ward is instantly likable, with her genuine curiosity, moral center, and sharp observational skills. I couldnāt help but root for her, even when she stumbled into trouble (as one does when dead bodies and manor tunnels are involved).
One of my absolute favorite parts? The bats. Yes, bats. Sarah Yarwood-Lovettās research shines here: the descriptions of habitats, behavior, and even theirā¦ pooping habits are surprisingly captivating. The research shines, and it never once feels forced. Itās seamlessly tied into the story, letting the science complement the mystery instead of overshadowing it. By the end, I was practically a bat enthusiast. But donāt worry, even if you arenāt into bats, the layered murder mystery and well-timed plot twists will keep you hooked. Nellās balancing act between her ecological work, the mystery, and the budding attention from Adam and DI James adds depth to her character, making her incredibly relatable.
The narration by Kristin Atherton deserves a shout-out. She nails both the upper-class and working-class British accents, making every character vivid and believable. I also appreciated the nuanced portrayal of upper-class characters. Theyāre not the typical snooty stereotypes but genuinely kind and engaging. With a rescued bat and an adorable cat thrown into the mix, this book blends eco-conscious themes with cozy mystery elements seamlessly.
The pacing, however, wavered a bit. At just over 12 hours, a few sections couldāve flown by faster, trim a chapter or two, and this might have been a perfect listen. Still, between the character development, layered mystery, and eco-friendly touches, itās an engaging start to a promising series.A Murder of Crows is a confident start to a series Iāll absolutely keep reading.
Would I recommend it? Even with its darker turns, this near-cozy mystery delivers on charm, intrigue, and ecological insight. Dr. Nell Ward is a protagonist youāll want to follow, and Kristin Athertonās narration brings the perfect touch. Iām already eagerly anticipating the next book in the series. Itās smart, atmospheric, and full of heart (and bats). A little darker than your standard cozy, but thatās part of its appeal. Perfect for fans of intelligent mysteries with a strong environmental edge.
The Fish and Chip Shop Detectives
š±š Read on Kindle | š 356 pages ā± Duration: 5 hours | ARC provided by NetGalley š·ļø Published by Hodder & Stoughton Release date: 2 April 2026 Genre: Cozy Mystery
Jenny Kaneās new cozy mystery serves up everything youād expect from the genre: a picture-postcard village, quirky characters, and a murder that ties the community in knots. Maggie and Ryan make an endearing, if slightly mismatched, team, and the premise of clearing Ryanās name gives their partnership believable stakes, and the hook of Ryan being a suspect gives their sleuthing a believable tension.
That said, the story sometimes overstays its welcome. At 356 pages, it felt like a full plate when a half-portion wouldāve satisfied. The flow of events occasionally felt unnatural. Mr. Robbins, the enigmatic shop owner, is so clearly teed up for future installments that his limited presence makes him more question mark than character. And while the village charm is delightful, the investigationās flow strains logic: Maggie seems to appear wherever questions need asking, and townsfolk, including police, and the suspects readily defer to her, or let her ask any questions which didnāt feel plausible for someone with limited experience. Ryan, on the other hand, felt more grounded; his worry about crossing legal lines gave the story moments of tension and realism. The relationships and dynamic are enjoyable, but the believability wavered enough that I struggled to stay fully immersed.
For fans of slow, scenic mysteries with British small-town charm, this one will scratch the cozy itch, even if it sometimes forgets that less can be more. Overall, the story and relationships had potential, but I didnāt feel compelled to continue the series.
Would I recommend it? Interesting characters and a charming Cornish setting, but the believability issues held me back. Unrealistic amateur detectives, and underutilized side characters gave a doozy. This was a pleasant but uneven read, engaging, yet not quite believable enough to hook me for book two. A decent cozy mystery, but I wouldnāt prioritize this one for an encore.
Originally posted at viewsshewrites.com.
š±š Read on Kindle | š 356 pages ā± Duration: 5 hours | ARC provided by NetGalley š·ļø Published by Hodder & Stoughton Release date: 2 April 2026 Genre: Cozy Mystery
Jenny Kaneās new cozy mystery serves up everything youād expect from the genre: a picture-postcard village, quirky characters, and a murder that ties the community in knots. Maggie and Ryan make an endearing, if slightly mismatched, team, and the premise of clearing Ryanās name gives their partnership believable stakes, and the hook of Ryan being a suspect gives their sleuthing a believable tension.
That said, the story sometimes overstays its welcome. At 356 pages, it felt like a full plate when a half-portion wouldāve satisfied. The flow of events occasionally felt unnatural. Mr. Robbins, the enigmatic shop owner, is so clearly teed up for future installments that his limited presence makes him more question mark than character. And while the village charm is delightful, the investigationās flow strains logic: Maggie seems to appear wherever questions need asking, and townsfolk, including police, and the suspects readily defer to her, or let her ask any questions which didnāt feel plausible for someone with limited experience. Ryan, on the other hand, felt more grounded; his worry about crossing legal lines gave the story moments of tension and realism. The relationships and dynamic are enjoyable, but the believability wavered enough that I struggled to stay fully immersed.
For fans of slow, scenic mysteries with British small-town charm, this one will scratch the cozy itch, even if it sometimes forgets that less can be more. Overall, the story and relationships had potential, but I didnāt feel compelled to continue the series.
Would I recommend it? Interesting characters and a charming Cornish setting, but the believability issues held me back. Unrealistic amateur detectives, and underutilized side characters gave a doozy. This was a pleasant but uneven read, engaging, yet not quite believable enough to hook me for book two. A decent cozy mystery, but I wouldnāt prioritize this one for an encore.
Originally posted at viewsshewrites.com.
š§ Listened in audio š¢ Narrated by Philip Battley ā± Duration: 6 hours š·ļø Published by: Tantor Media & self-published by the author š Published: November 8, 2022 šÆ Genre: Cozy Mystery
We all know the trope: city woman lands in small town, resists it, stumbles into murder, gets adopted by quirky locals, and never leaves. Murder on Milverton Square has all the hallmarks of a classic cozy mystery: nosy neighbors, baked goods, and murder served with charm. But what makes it shine is G.B. Ralphās masterful inclusion of a gay protagonist whose queerness isnāt a plot twist, itās just a fact of his life. Addison Harper feels real, grounded, and genuinely lovable.
The story hums with warmth. The setting at a New Zealand town full of busybodies and heart is the kind of place readers will long to visit. Addisonās slow-burn connection with Sergeant Murphy adds just enough spark to keep you rooting for them through every misstep and misunderstanding. Ralph never lets the romance overshadow the mystery; rather, he weaves both into a rich portrait of change, trust, and belonging. And Philip Battleyās narration? Absolute perfection. His grounded tone brings out Addisonās dry wit and the communityās delightfully chaotic energy.
Addison is a standout protagonist. Heās confident in what he wants, but not rigid. I loved how heās willing to reassess his choices when new information comes to light, emotionally and practically. The town of Milverton feels lived-in and warm, and the mystery unfolds at a comfortable pace without dragging. This isnāt a ācozy mystery remade to fit modern boxes.ā It is modern, effortlessly so, and all the better because of it. Comforting, character-driven, and unapologetically queer. This story just works. By the end, I wasnāt just satisfied with the resolution, I was genuinely excited to continue Addisonās journey. This series feels like it knows exactly what itās doing.
Would I recommend it? If you enjoy classic cozy mysteries but are craving something that feels familiar and quietly progressive, this is an easy recommendation. This oneās a warm hug in audio form. The charm is real, the mystery works, and the character development gives this series legs beyond book one. A small-town mystery with heart, humor, and beautifully grounded queer representation. Addison Harper is a character I already miss. Iām genuinely looking forward to where Addisonās story goes next, and thatās always the best sign.
š§ Listened in audio š¢ Narrated by Philip Battley ā± Duration: 6 hours š·ļø Published by: Tantor Media & self-published by the author š Published: November 8, 2022 šÆ Genre: Cozy Mystery
We all know the trope: city woman lands in small town, resists it, stumbles into murder, gets adopted by quirky locals, and never leaves. Murder on Milverton Square has all the hallmarks of a classic cozy mystery: nosy neighbors, baked goods, and murder served with charm. But what makes it shine is G.B. Ralphās masterful inclusion of a gay protagonist whose queerness isnāt a plot twist, itās just a fact of his life. Addison Harper feels real, grounded, and genuinely lovable.
The story hums with warmth. The setting at a New Zealand town full of busybodies and heart is the kind of place readers will long to visit. Addisonās slow-burn connection with Sergeant Murphy adds just enough spark to keep you rooting for them through every misstep and misunderstanding. Ralph never lets the romance overshadow the mystery; rather, he weaves both into a rich portrait of change, trust, and belonging. And Philip Battleyās narration? Absolute perfection. His grounded tone brings out Addisonās dry wit and the communityās delightfully chaotic energy.
Addison is a standout protagonist. Heās confident in what he wants, but not rigid. I loved how heās willing to reassess his choices when new information comes to light, emotionally and practically. The town of Milverton feels lived-in and warm, and the mystery unfolds at a comfortable pace without dragging. This isnāt a ācozy mystery remade to fit modern boxes.ā It is modern, effortlessly so, and all the better because of it. Comforting, character-driven, and unapologetically queer. This story just works. By the end, I wasnāt just satisfied with the resolution, I was genuinely excited to continue Addisonās journey. This series feels like it knows exactly what itās doing.
Would I recommend it? If you enjoy classic cozy mysteries but are craving something that feels familiar and quietly progressive, this is an easy recommendation. This oneās a warm hug in audio form. The charm is real, the mystery works, and the character development gives this series legs beyond book one. A small-town mystery with heart, humor, and beautifully grounded queer representation. Addison Harper is a character I already miss. Iām genuinely looking forward to where Addisonās story goes next, and thatās always the best sign.
š§ Listened in audio š¢ Narrated by Lorna Bennett ā± Duration: 13 hours š·ļø Publisher: Podium Audio & Te Ra Aroha Press š Published: February 28, 2022 š§ Genre: Paranormal Cozy Mystery
When I started reading this book, I expected a bit of a Stacie Ramey vibes with her yet-unpublished Spellbound by Murder: A Mystic Hollow Bookshop Mystery with a quirkly small town vibes, gentle magic, low stakes mystery, and characters you want to spend time with. That spellbindingly wonderful 5-star cozy paranormal gem with actual heart and magic that stuck. (Check that book out!!!) What I got from Accidental Magic? A mother-daughter duo so grating I DNF'd at 50%, shattering my "past 20% I finish" rule.
At the heart of the problem is the motherādaughter dynamic between Rosemary and Athena. Athena is written as arrogantly obnoxious, often aggressively rude, and while her POV occasionally reveals concern for her mother, that emotional depth rarely translates into her actual behavior. Rosemary, meanwhile, insists that Athena is the one keeping her grounded, which feels wildly disconnected from what weāre shown. The logic gaps only add to the frustration. Rosemary is constantly worried about finances and protecting Athena from their money troubles, yet they eat out regularly and Athena already knows her father has swindled their savings. For someone so anxious about stability, Rosemary somehow forgets to inform her workplace of her absence and is fired for skipping work entirely. These moments donāt read as charming chaos; they feel careless and implausible, making it hard to stay emotionally invested.
Emotional reactions throughout the story are similarly uneven. Rosemary is slow and passive when urgency is required, then oddly detached in moments where fear or panic should be front and center. By the time I hit the halfway mark, I found myself thinking, Iām already this far, I can survive the rest. But despite rarely DNFing after the 20% mark, I couldnāt continue. Thirteen hours is a long commitment, and when the central characters consistently push you away, no amount of magic or quirky town flavor can save the experience. Myrtlewoodās magic premise dangled hope, but these characters sandpapered my patience raw.
Would I recommend it? This was a rare DNF for me, and one I donāt regret. While Accidental Magic promises cozy paranormal fun, the execution, especially the character dynamics and inconsistent logic, made it more frustrating than comforting. This paranormal cozy mystery promised witches, tea, and quirky secrets but delivered infuriating leads and logic gaps that killed immersion. Life's too short for grating duos when spectacular books like Spellbound by Murder: A Mystic Hollow Bookshop Mystery exists. If youāre very tolerant of unlikeable protagonists and narrative disconnects, you may find something to enjoy here. Otherwise, this one may seriously test your patience.
š§ Listened in audio š¢ Narrated by Lorna Bennett ā± Duration: 13 hours š·ļø Publisher: Podium Audio & Te Ra Aroha Press š Published: February 28, 2022 š§ Genre: Paranormal Cozy Mystery
When I started reading this book, I expected a bit of a Stacie Ramey vibes with her yet-unpublished Spellbound by Murder: A Mystic Hollow Bookshop Mystery with a quirkly small town vibes, gentle magic, low stakes mystery, and characters you want to spend time with. That spellbindingly wonderful 5-star cozy paranormal gem with actual heart and magic that stuck. (Check that book out!!!) What I got from Accidental Magic? A mother-daughter duo so grating I DNF'd at 50%, shattering my "past 20% I finish" rule.
At the heart of the problem is the motherādaughter dynamic between Rosemary and Athena. Athena is written as arrogantly obnoxious, often aggressively rude, and while her POV occasionally reveals concern for her mother, that emotional depth rarely translates into her actual behavior. Rosemary, meanwhile, insists that Athena is the one keeping her grounded, which feels wildly disconnected from what weāre shown. The logic gaps only add to the frustration. Rosemary is constantly worried about finances and protecting Athena from their money troubles, yet they eat out regularly and Athena already knows her father has swindled their savings. For someone so anxious about stability, Rosemary somehow forgets to inform her workplace of her absence and is fired for skipping work entirely. These moments donāt read as charming chaos; they feel careless and implausible, making it hard to stay emotionally invested.
Emotional reactions throughout the story are similarly uneven. Rosemary is slow and passive when urgency is required, then oddly detached in moments where fear or panic should be front and center. By the time I hit the halfway mark, I found myself thinking, Iām already this far, I can survive the rest. But despite rarely DNFing after the 20% mark, I couldnāt continue. Thirteen hours is a long commitment, and when the central characters consistently push you away, no amount of magic or quirky town flavor can save the experience. Myrtlewoodās magic premise dangled hope, but these characters sandpapered my patience raw.
Would I recommend it? This was a rare DNF for me, and one I donāt regret. While Accidental Magic promises cozy paranormal fun, the execution, especially the character dynamics and inconsistent logic, made it more frustrating than comforting. This paranormal cozy mystery promised witches, tea, and quirky secrets but delivered infuriating leads and logic gaps that killed immersion. Life's too short for grating duos when spectacular books like Spellbound by Murder: A Mystic Hollow Bookshop Mystery exists. If youāre very tolerant of unlikeable protagonists and narrative disconnects, you may find something to enjoy here. Otherwise, this one may seriously test your patience.
š§ Listened in audio š¢ Narrated by: Amy Landon ā± Duration: 4 hours š·ļø Publisher: Macmillan Audio & Tordotcom š Published: June 14, 2022 š§ Genre: Fantasy
Zinnia Grey is back, still racing against a short lifespan, still desperately trying to outrun the endings written for her. In A Mirror Mended, Alix E. Harrow peels back the shiny surface of fairy tales to explore what happens when the villain isnāt all that bad, and the heroine doesnāt want to play her part anymore. Itās short, slick, and brimming with heart, a story that redefines what it means to be both savior and saved.
What really got me was how human the Evil Queen feels. She isnāt softened into something palatable or redeemed through convenience. Instead, Harrow gives her depth, fear, agency, and a heartbreaking awareness of her own fate. Her relationship with Zinnia becomes the emotional backbone of the story with her tentative, sharp, surprisingly tender mannerisms. For a novella, the emotional punch here is impressive. This book doesnāt rush its feelings, even when the plot moves quickly. Amy Landonās narration breathes fire and fragility into Zinniaās voice. You can feel her wit, her exhaustion, and that wild spark of hope pulsing through each scene. Her performance makes Zinnia more alive than any printed page could.
This really feels like the end of Zinniaās journey, and while Iām sad to see her go, itās the kind of ending that feels earned rather than abrupt. I closed this one feeling a little hollowed out and grateful. Fairy tales rarely give us closure, but A Mirror Mended finds a way.
Would I recommend it? This is a short book, but it lingers. If you enjoy morally complex characters, reclaimed villains, and stories that question who gets to be āsaved,ā A Mirror Mended is well worth your time. Listening to it only enhances the experience. Iām sad to close the door on Zinnia Grey, but Iāll follow Alix E. Harrow anywhere she takes fantasy next. if you love fairy-tale retellings with grit and heart, add this to your TBR.
š§ Listened in audio š¢ Narrated by: Amy Landon ā± Duration: 4 hours š·ļø Publisher: Macmillan Audio & Tordotcom š Published: June 14, 2022 š§ Genre: Fantasy
Zinnia Grey is back, still racing against a short lifespan, still desperately trying to outrun the endings written for her. In A Mirror Mended, Alix E. Harrow peels back the shiny surface of fairy tales to explore what happens when the villain isnāt all that bad, and the heroine doesnāt want to play her part anymore. Itās short, slick, and brimming with heart, a story that redefines what it means to be both savior and saved.
What really got me was how human the Evil Queen feels. She isnāt softened into something palatable or redeemed through convenience. Instead, Harrow gives her depth, fear, agency, and a heartbreaking awareness of her own fate. Her relationship with Zinnia becomes the emotional backbone of the story with her tentative, sharp, surprisingly tender mannerisms. For a novella, the emotional punch here is impressive. This book doesnāt rush its feelings, even when the plot moves quickly. Amy Landonās narration breathes fire and fragility into Zinniaās voice. You can feel her wit, her exhaustion, and that wild spark of hope pulsing through each scene. Her performance makes Zinnia more alive than any printed page could.
This really feels like the end of Zinniaās journey, and while Iām sad to see her go, itās the kind of ending that feels earned rather than abrupt. I closed this one feeling a little hollowed out and grateful. Fairy tales rarely give us closure, but A Mirror Mended finds a way.
Would I recommend it? This is a short book, but it lingers. If you enjoy morally complex characters, reclaimed villains, and stories that question who gets to be āsaved,ā A Mirror Mended is well worth your time. Listening to it only enhances the experience. Iām sad to close the door on Zinnia Grey, but Iāll follow Alix E. Harrow anywhere she takes fantasy next. if you love fairy-tale retellings with grit and heart, add this to your TBR.
š§ Listened in audio š¢ Narrated by Rebecca Mitchell ā± Duration: 8 hours š·ļø Published by: Tantor Media & Kensington Cozies š Published on: February 27, 2018 š§© Genre: Cozy Mystery
This is one of those deeply frustrating reads where the story itself is genuinely good, but the format completely sabotages the experience.
Color me Murder has Krista Davis vibes written all over it, with quirky pets, small-town charm, and just-right murders. Georgetown's bookstore setting hooked me fast, and Florrie Fox is the perfect amateur detective. She blunders. She hesitates. She makes mistakes. And all of it makes sense because sheās a shop owner just trying to keep her livelihood intact while protecting someone she deeply admires from landing in prison. Relatable chaos that grounds the whodunit in real feels. No instant-genius sleuth here; her clueless stumbles made perfect sense and kept me rooting.
Unfortunately, the audiobook narration completely flattened the experience. The delivery was so emotionally monotone that it drained tension, humor, and urgency from scenes that should have sparkled. Even moments of danger felt oddly lifeless. This wasnāt a case of ānot my favorite narratorā. This actively made it hard to stay engaged. I found myself wishing I could rewind time and experience this series in print instead, especially because Iāve loved Krista Davisās other cozy mystery series. It genuinely pains me to walk away from this one.
Would I recommend it? Florrie's flawed charm and the clever bookstore murder setup shine in this cozy gem, but the lifeless narration tanks the experience. It's a pass on continuing the series for me, but stick to print or Davis's other hits if you crave voice magic. Solid amateur sleuth fun otherwise. The story, characters, and premise are strong enough to support a series. The story, characters, and premise are strong enough to support a series.
š§ Listened in audio š¢ Narrated by Rebecca Mitchell ā± Duration: 8 hours š·ļø Published by: Tantor Media & Kensington Cozies š Published on: February 27, 2018 š§© Genre: Cozy Mystery
This is one of those deeply frustrating reads where the story itself is genuinely good, but the format completely sabotages the experience.
Color me Murder has Krista Davis vibes written all over it, with quirky pets, small-town charm, and just-right murders. Georgetown's bookstore setting hooked me fast, and Florrie Fox is the perfect amateur detective. She blunders. She hesitates. She makes mistakes. And all of it makes sense because sheās a shop owner just trying to keep her livelihood intact while protecting someone she deeply admires from landing in prison. Relatable chaos that grounds the whodunit in real feels. No instant-genius sleuth here; her clueless stumbles made perfect sense and kept me rooting.
Unfortunately, the audiobook narration completely flattened the experience. The delivery was so emotionally monotone that it drained tension, humor, and urgency from scenes that should have sparkled. Even moments of danger felt oddly lifeless. This wasnāt a case of ānot my favorite narratorā. This actively made it hard to stay engaged. I found myself wishing I could rewind time and experience this series in print instead, especially because Iāve loved Krista Davisās other cozy mystery series. It genuinely pains me to walk away from this one.
Would I recommend it? Florrie's flawed charm and the clever bookstore murder setup shine in this cozy gem, but the lifeless narration tanks the experience. It's a pass on continuing the series for me, but stick to print or Davis's other hits if you crave voice magic. Solid amateur sleuth fun otherwise. The story, characters, and premise are strong enough to support a series. The story, characters, and premise are strong enough to support a series.
š§ Listened in audio š¢ Narrated by Callie Beauliue ā± Duration: 6 hours š·ļø Published by Tantor Media & Berkley Prime Crime š Published: September 1, 2009 Genre: Cozy Mystery
I wanted this to be my kind of cozy: small-town New England vibes, quirky craft classes, and murder tucked neatly between layers of gossip and glue. But twenty percent in, I wasā¦ unstuck. I couldnāt continue listening. The writing felt bland and flat, and the pacing left me completely uninvested. Brennaās struggles to fit into Morse Point could have been engaging, but they came off more tedious than relatable.
For a character constantly reminded she doesnāt belong, Brenna somehow ends up doing everyoneās emotional labor, from appeasing the mayor to managing egos. The supposed budding chemistry between her and Nate missed every mark. It just hovered awkwardly. Even Callie Beaulieuās pleasant narration couldnāt lift the storyās lack of energy. I love a cozy with quirks and heart, but this one never found its rhythm.
Overall, the book felt like it had the pieces for a classic small-town cozy but failed to put them together in a compelling way. Simply put: too much varnish, not enough texture.
Would you recommend it? Nope. I couldnāt finish. The setup promised charm and mystery, but it stayed surface-level and slow. If you love small-town cozies where the craft is the main attraction, maybe youāll vibe more than I did, but for me, this one didnāt stick.
š§ Listened in audio š¢ Narrated by Callie Beauliue ā± Duration: 6 hours š·ļø Published by Tantor Media & Berkley Prime Crime š Published: September 1, 2009 Genre: Cozy Mystery
I wanted this to be my kind of cozy: small-town New England vibes, quirky craft classes, and murder tucked neatly between layers of gossip and glue. But twenty percent in, I wasā¦ unstuck. I couldnāt continue listening. The writing felt bland and flat, and the pacing left me completely uninvested. Brennaās struggles to fit into Morse Point could have been engaging, but they came off more tedious than relatable.
For a character constantly reminded she doesnāt belong, Brenna somehow ends up doing everyoneās emotional labor, from appeasing the mayor to managing egos. The supposed budding chemistry between her and Nate missed every mark. It just hovered awkwardly. Even Callie Beaulieuās pleasant narration couldnāt lift the storyās lack of energy. I love a cozy with quirks and heart, but this one never found its rhythm.
Overall, the book felt like it had the pieces for a classic small-town cozy but failed to put them together in a compelling way. Simply put: too much varnish, not enough texture.
Would you recommend it? Nope. I couldnāt finish. The setup promised charm and mystery, but it stayed surface-level and slow. If you love small-town cozies where the craft is the main attraction, maybe youāll vibe more than I did, but for me, this one didnāt stick.
š§ Listened in audio š¢ Narrated by Kate Coventry ā± Duration: 9 hours š·ļø Publisher: Crooked Lane Books & Spotify Audiobooks š Published: October 21, 2025 Genre: Cozy Mystery
For a series debut, Death on Dickens Island promises the right ingredients: a coastal small town, a tangled web of family drama, and even a ghostly presence to stir the pot. On paper, it shouldāve been my kind of story with all the atmospheric, moody, and character-driven storyline. But the reality didnāt click for me.
Delia Dickens is set up as this idealistic, small-town heroine, yet her personality felt flat and unconvincing. She talks about her values and hopes for her family and community, but her actions and internal reflections didnāt resonate. Even her sonās presence, meant to provide an emotional anchor, didnāt add the depth I was hoping for. I wanted the emotional messiness of generational trauma woven thoughtfully into the mystery, but instead it just sat there, heavy and unresolved. Even the spectral twist failed to enchant. The ghost subplot had potential for charm or spookiness (ideally both), but it ended up feeling like background noise.
Overall, the pacing was steady enough to finish the book, but the emotional engagement was missing. I could appreciate the effort and the setup for a series, but I wonāt be continuing with the next installment. I stayed attentive, hoping the threads would tie together in a satisfying way, but by the end, I was more relieved than intrigued.
Would I recommend it? No, this one didnāt resonate. While fans of small-town mysteries may find something to enjoy, it didnāt connect for me.
š§ Listened in audio š¢ Narrated by Kate Coventry ā± Duration: 9 hours š·ļø Publisher: Crooked Lane Books & Spotify Audiobooks š Published: October 21, 2025 Genre: Cozy Mystery
For a series debut, Death on Dickens Island promises the right ingredients: a coastal small town, a tangled web of family drama, and even a ghostly presence to stir the pot. On paper, it shouldāve been my kind of story with all the atmospheric, moody, and character-driven storyline. But the reality didnāt click for me.
Delia Dickens is set up as this idealistic, small-town heroine, yet her personality felt flat and unconvincing. She talks about her values and hopes for her family and community, but her actions and internal reflections didnāt resonate. Even her sonās presence, meant to provide an emotional anchor, didnāt add the depth I was hoping for. I wanted the emotional messiness of generational trauma woven thoughtfully into the mystery, but instead it just sat there, heavy and unresolved. Even the spectral twist failed to enchant. The ghost subplot had potential for charm or spookiness (ideally both), but it ended up feeling like background noise.
Overall, the pacing was steady enough to finish the book, but the emotional engagement was missing. I could appreciate the effort and the setup for a series, but I wonāt be continuing with the next installment. I stayed attentive, hoping the threads would tie together in a satisfying way, but by the end, I was more relieved than intrigued.
Would I recommend it? No, this one didnāt resonate. While fans of small-town mysteries may find something to enjoy, it didnāt connect for me.
š§ Listened in audio š¢ Narrated by Elise Arsenault ā± Duration: 9 hours š·ļø Published by Crooked Lane Books & Dreamscape Media LLC on May 6, 2025 Genre: Cozy Mystery
This installment of the Lighthouse Library series packs a more intense punch than usual. Where previous mysteries sent Lucy out into the field, this time the chaos comes to her doorstep, literally. Todd Harrisonās murder on Lucyās deck not only shakes the cozy Outer Banks setting but brings a swirl of uncomfortable, creepy elements: fans trespassing, obsessive behaviors, and the widowās political maneuvering. Fair warning: the stalking and harassment are unsettling, so this one leans darker than your typical cozy.
The other emotional thread? Detective Watsonās retirement. Longtime readers know heās been the seriesā steady moral anchor, so his farewell lands with real weight. The scenes with him reflecting on family and change had me misty-eyed between the red herrings. Iām not ready for him to hang up the badge (and neither is Lucy).
Despite the intensity, Eva Gates maintains the seriesā charm: witty banter, small-town quirks, and Lucyās grounded perspective make it easy to stay invested. The pacing is brisk, the stakes feel personal, and the mystery remains cleverly constructed. If the lighthouse felt like home before, this installment tests just how strong its foundation really is.
Would I recommend it? If youāre a fan of cozy mysteries with a twist of darker, more psychological tension, this book delivers. Lucy is as relatable as ever, and the story keeps you on edge without losing the warmth of the series. Add this one to your TBR if you enjoy small-town mysteries with heart and bite.
š§ Listened in audio š¢ Narrated by Elise Arsenault ā± Duration: 9 hours š·ļø Published by Crooked Lane Books & Dreamscape Media LLC on May 6, 2025 Genre: Cozy Mystery
This installment of the Lighthouse Library series packs a more intense punch than usual. Where previous mysteries sent Lucy out into the field, this time the chaos comes to her doorstep, literally. Todd Harrisonās murder on Lucyās deck not only shakes the cozy Outer Banks setting but brings a swirl of uncomfortable, creepy elements: fans trespassing, obsessive behaviors, and the widowās political maneuvering. Fair warning: the stalking and harassment are unsettling, so this one leans darker than your typical cozy.
The other emotional thread? Detective Watsonās retirement. Longtime readers know heās been the seriesā steady moral anchor, so his farewell lands with real weight. The scenes with him reflecting on family and change had me misty-eyed between the red herrings. Iām not ready for him to hang up the badge (and neither is Lucy).
Despite the intensity, Eva Gates maintains the seriesā charm: witty banter, small-town quirks, and Lucyās grounded perspective make it easy to stay invested. The pacing is brisk, the stakes feel personal, and the mystery remains cleverly constructed. If the lighthouse felt like home before, this installment tests just how strong its foundation really is.
Would I recommend it? If youāre a fan of cozy mysteries with a twist of darker, more psychological tension, this book delivers. Lucy is as relatable as ever, and the story keeps you on edge without losing the warmth of the series. Add this one to your TBR if you enjoy small-town mysteries with heart and bite.
š§ Listened in audio š¢ Narrated by Elise Arsenault ā± Duration: 9 hours š·ļø Publisher: Crooked Lane Books & Dreamscape Media LLC on June 4, 2024
I had entirely forgotten about this series (my bad!!) but once I remembered, I dove straight into Nags Head and Lucyās world. Returning to Nags Head felt like stepping right into old friendships: Connorās steady presence, Louise Janeās paranormal flair, and, of course, Charles the cat reigning regally from atop the circulation desk.
The Stranger in the Library balances its art-world intrigue with that familiar, heartwarming rhythm Eva Gates (aka Vicki Delany) always delivers. I enjoyed how the mystery threaded together the missing art, the drowned guest, and Louise Janeās new romantic distraction (because letās be honest, that girl always finds drama with flair). The seaside setting once again shines, painted so vividly that I could almost smell the salt air drifting through every scene.
Thereās also a touch of bittersweetness hereāthose hints about Detective Watsonās retirement tugged at me. Heās such a quiet anchor in this series, and losing him would leave a big hole in the crew. But thatās Gatesās gift: even in a lighthearted cozy, she manages to weave emotional depth you donāt quite expect. Elise Arsenault does a brilliant job bringing Lucy and the crew to life. I love her narration and the way she puts emotions behind her words. The combination of Gates' writing and Arsenault's narration hits the sweet spot.
Gatesā skill lies in balancing cozy charm with real stakes. The Lighthouse Library series never fails to make me care about both the mystery and the people behind it. This installment hits all the right notes: a clever puzzle, lovable characters, and just enough heart to make it stick with you after the final chapter.
Would I recommend it? If you love cozy mysteries with small-town charm, engaging characters, and just the right amount of twisty drama, this one is a win. Itās a delightful return to form for a beloved series, full of mischief, artful secrets, and coastal charm. And Elise Arsenault nails the narration, giving every character just the right personality.
š§ Listened in audio š¢ Narrated by Elise Arsenault ā± Duration: 9 hours š·ļø Publisher: Crooked Lane Books & Dreamscape Media LLC on June 4, 2024
I had entirely forgotten about this series (my bad!!) but once I remembered, I dove straight into Nags Head and Lucyās world. Returning to Nags Head felt like stepping right into old friendships: Connorās steady presence, Louise Janeās paranormal flair, and, of course, Charles the cat reigning regally from atop the circulation desk.
The Stranger in the Library balances its art-world intrigue with that familiar, heartwarming rhythm Eva Gates (aka Vicki Delany) always delivers. I enjoyed how the mystery threaded together the missing art, the drowned guest, and Louise Janeās new romantic distraction (because letās be honest, that girl always finds drama with flair). The seaside setting once again shines, painted so vividly that I could almost smell the salt air drifting through every scene.
Thereās also a touch of bittersweetness hereāthose hints about Detective Watsonās retirement tugged at me. Heās such a quiet anchor in this series, and losing him would leave a big hole in the crew. But thatās Gatesās gift: even in a lighthearted cozy, she manages to weave emotional depth you donāt quite expect. Elise Arsenault does a brilliant job bringing Lucy and the crew to life. I love her narration and the way she puts emotions behind her words. The combination of Gates' writing and Arsenault's narration hits the sweet spot.
Gatesā skill lies in balancing cozy charm with real stakes. The Lighthouse Library series never fails to make me care about both the mystery and the people behind it. This installment hits all the right notes: a clever puzzle, lovable characters, and just enough heart to make it stick with you after the final chapter.
Would I recommend it? If you love cozy mysteries with small-town charm, engaging characters, and just the right amount of twisty drama, this one is a win. Itās a delightful return to form for a beloved series, full of mischief, artful secrets, and coastal charm. And Elise Arsenault nails the narration, giving every character just the right personality.
š±š Read on Kobo š 304 pages ā± Duration: ~4 hours š·ļø Publisher: Kensington Publishing (Kensington Cozies) š Release Date: February 24, 2026 š ARC provided by NetGalley
After feeling underwhelmed by the Josie Way series, I was hopeful when Angela M. Sanders announced a fresh start with A Whiff of Murder. Lise Bloom was introduced in Witch and Tell (Witch Way Librarian #7), and I liked her there enough to feel optimistic about her stepping into the lead role. Her gift of reading āfragrance ribbonsā felt creative and had the potential to set this paranormal cozy apart. I loved the Oregon setting, the quirky side characters, and Sandersās usual knack for smallātown charm.
But somewhere between the incense sticks and the melodrama, things drifted a little too YA for my taste. In this book, Lise comes across as far more childish than expected, especially in how she handles conflict. The rivalry with Detective Signe felt rooted in high school grudges rather than adult motivations, which made both characters feel emotionally underdeveloped. Signeās determination to view Lise as guilty simply because of a shared past rivalry stretched credibility and weakened the investigative tension.
The mystery itself is serviceable, and the clairalience concept remains the strongest element. This feels like a book that wanted to be cozy fun but stumbled in character execution. Still, Sandersās prose remains smooth, and I can see dieāhard cozy fans enjoying the light paranormal twist.
Would I recommend it? If you enjoy cozy mysteries with a sprinkle of magic and smallātown gossip, you might find A Whiff of Murder a pleasant weekend diversion. For me, it didnāt quite capture the spark of Sandersās earlier work, but itās far from a total miss.
Originally posted at viewsshewrites.com.
š±š Read on Kobo š 304 pages ā± Duration: ~4 hours š·ļø Publisher: Kensington Publishing (Kensington Cozies) š Release Date: February 24, 2026 š ARC provided by NetGalley
After feeling underwhelmed by the Josie Way series, I was hopeful when Angela M. Sanders announced a fresh start with A Whiff of Murder. Lise Bloom was introduced in Witch and Tell (Witch Way Librarian #7), and I liked her there enough to feel optimistic about her stepping into the lead role. Her gift of reading āfragrance ribbonsā felt creative and had the potential to set this paranormal cozy apart. I loved the Oregon setting, the quirky side characters, and Sandersās usual knack for smallātown charm.
But somewhere between the incense sticks and the melodrama, things drifted a little too YA for my taste. In this book, Lise comes across as far more childish than expected, especially in how she handles conflict. The rivalry with Detective Signe felt rooted in high school grudges rather than adult motivations, which made both characters feel emotionally underdeveloped. Signeās determination to view Lise as guilty simply because of a shared past rivalry stretched credibility and weakened the investigative tension.
The mystery itself is serviceable, and the clairalience concept remains the strongest element. This feels like a book that wanted to be cozy fun but stumbled in character execution. Still, Sandersās prose remains smooth, and I can see dieāhard cozy fans enjoying the light paranormal twist.
Would I recommend it? If you enjoy cozy mysteries with a sprinkle of magic and smallātown gossip, you might find A Whiff of Murder a pleasant weekend diversion. For me, it didnāt quite capture the spark of Sandersās earlier work, but itās far from a total miss.
Originally posted at viewsshewrites.com.
š±š Read on Kobo š 384 pages | ā±ļø ~4 hours š·ļø Publisher: Dutton š Release Date: May 5, 2026 āØ ARC provided by NetGalley
The concept behind A Zoom with a View is genuinely strong and exactly the kind of setup that cozy mystery readers tend to gravitate toward. A small-town bully turned influencer, a murder tied to real estate rivalries, and a found-family circle rallying together to protect one of their own makes for an engaging foundation. Once the mystery kicked in, I found myself flying through the pages and easily finishing the book in record time.
One element that didnāt quite land for me was the heavy emphasis on Leo being a photographer without that skill ever truly impacting the investigation. Given the title, I expected photography to play a more meaningful role, whether through clues, images, or perspective, but it mostly remained background detail rather than a storytelling tool. The motherās big secret also overstayed its welcome. While I understand the intention to build suspense, by the time the reveal came (literally in the final pages), the reaction didn't fully ring true for me emotionally. The final stretch of the book dragged a bit, and the cliffhanger ending may divide readers depending on their tolerance for unresolved threads.
Still, Cannonās voice sparkles. Her sense of humor, her pacing once the plot kicks in, and her small-town details all sing with potential. For a debut, this one is full of promise, and Iāll absolutely be keeping an eye out for what she writes next. I mean, there's a cliffhanger I need to find resolution for!
Would I recommend it? A cozy mystery with small-town drama, witty banter, and a murder to untangle. While the pacing and some unresolved elements didnāt fully work for me, the core idea and writing style show a lot of promise. For a debut novel, this is a confident start, and Iād absolutely be interested in picking up the next book to see where the story goes.
Originally posted at viewsshewrites.com.
š±š Read on Kobo š 384 pages | ā±ļø ~4 hours š·ļø Publisher: Dutton š Release Date: May 5, 2026 āØ ARC provided by NetGalley
The concept behind A Zoom with a View is genuinely strong and exactly the kind of setup that cozy mystery readers tend to gravitate toward. A small-town bully turned influencer, a murder tied to real estate rivalries, and a found-family circle rallying together to protect one of their own makes for an engaging foundation. Once the mystery kicked in, I found myself flying through the pages and easily finishing the book in record time.
One element that didnāt quite land for me was the heavy emphasis on Leo being a photographer without that skill ever truly impacting the investigation. Given the title, I expected photography to play a more meaningful role, whether through clues, images, or perspective, but it mostly remained background detail rather than a storytelling tool. The motherās big secret also overstayed its welcome. While I understand the intention to build suspense, by the time the reveal came (literally in the final pages), the reaction didn't fully ring true for me emotionally. The final stretch of the book dragged a bit, and the cliffhanger ending may divide readers depending on their tolerance for unresolved threads.
Still, Cannonās voice sparkles. Her sense of humor, her pacing once the plot kicks in, and her small-town details all sing with potential. For a debut, this one is full of promise, and Iāll absolutely be keeping an eye out for what she writes next. I mean, there's a cliffhanger I need to find resolution for!
Would I recommend it? A cozy mystery with small-town drama, witty banter, and a murder to untangle. While the pacing and some unresolved elements didnāt fully work for me, the core idea and writing style show a lot of promise. For a debut novel, this is a confident start, and Iād absolutely be interested in picking up the next book to see where the story goes.
Originally posted at viewsshewrites.com.
š±š Read on Kindle š 268 pages ā± Approx. 4-hour read š·ļø Publisher: BooksGoSocial š Release Date: November 14, 2025 āØ ARC provided by NetGalley
This book ambushed my Sunday in the best possible way. I wasnāt planning to read it. It wasnāt even on my immediate TBR. I opened Death of a Billionaire purely out of curiosity, intending to skim a few pages and move on. That was around 8 a.m. The next time I checked the clock, it was nearly 11, I was sitting upright in bed, and I was deeply invested.
Tucker May builds a billionaire ecosystem that feels disturbingly real. Barron Fisk is exactly the kind of tech mogul you already hate a little on sight, and that familiarity makes the mystery hit harder. He drops readers straight into a razor-sharp world of money, ambition, and moral rot, and does it with such wit that you barely notice youāve been holding your breath for chapters.
Alan and Shayneās dynamic brings just enough friction and reluctant camaraderie to keep things moving, but the true scene-stealer here is the narrator. Snarky, judgmental, and a masterclass in dry humor, their voice is what makes this mystery so distinctly alive. Around the 20% mark, I had a hunch about the narratorās identity, but the final reveal? Didnāt see that one coming. Itās clever, layered, and crafted with a confidence rare for debut authors.
The conclusion is bold, clever, and wildly unexpected. This book is unusual in the best way, confidently different, and meticulously plotted. There wasnāt a single dull moment, a single misstep, or a single choice I questioned. The satire lands perfectly. Every line feels intentional, every twist earned. For a debut (or is it?), this is outrageously assured storytelling.
Would I recommend it? Add this to your TBR immediately. Death of a Billionaire is smart, twisty, and wildly entertaining, with a narrative voice that deserves a standing ovation. If you like mysteries that feel fresh, slightly unhinged in the best way, and sharp enough to leave a mark, this one delivers. Tucker May is officially on my must-read radar, and I will be watching for every future release like a hawk.
Originally posted at viewsshewrites.com.
š±š Read on Kindle š 268 pages ā± Approx. 4-hour read š·ļø Publisher: BooksGoSocial š Release Date: November 14, 2025 āØ ARC provided by NetGalley
This book ambushed my Sunday in the best possible way. I wasnāt planning to read it. It wasnāt even on my immediate TBR. I opened Death of a Billionaire purely out of curiosity, intending to skim a few pages and move on. That was around 8 a.m. The next time I checked the clock, it was nearly 11, I was sitting upright in bed, and I was deeply invested.
Tucker May builds a billionaire ecosystem that feels disturbingly real. Barron Fisk is exactly the kind of tech mogul you already hate a little on sight, and that familiarity makes the mystery hit harder. He drops readers straight into a razor-sharp world of money, ambition, and moral rot, and does it with such wit that you barely notice youāve been holding your breath for chapters.
Alan and Shayneās dynamic brings just enough friction and reluctant camaraderie to keep things moving, but the true scene-stealer here is the narrator. Snarky, judgmental, and a masterclass in dry humor, their voice is what makes this mystery so distinctly alive. Around the 20% mark, I had a hunch about the narratorās identity, but the final reveal? Didnāt see that one coming. Itās clever, layered, and crafted with a confidence rare for debut authors.
The conclusion is bold, clever, and wildly unexpected. This book is unusual in the best way, confidently different, and meticulously plotted. There wasnāt a single dull moment, a single misstep, or a single choice I questioned. The satire lands perfectly. Every line feels intentional, every twist earned. For a debut (or is it?), this is outrageously assured storytelling.
Would I recommend it? Add this to your TBR immediately. Death of a Billionaire is smart, twisty, and wildly entertaining, with a narrative voice that deserves a standing ovation. If you like mysteries that feel fresh, slightly unhinged in the best way, and sharp enough to leave a mark, this one delivers. Tucker May is officially on my must-read radar, and I will be watching for every future release like a hawk.
Originally posted at viewsshewrites.com.
š±š Read on Kindle š 326 pages ā± Approx. 4 hours reading time š·ļø Publisher: Tor Books
After Starter Villain, I was ready for another dose of Scalziās signature humor and charm. A moon made of cheese? Thatās camp-core sci-fi gold right there. The setup had me grinning. The sheer ridiculousness of humanity staring up at a giant dairy orb promised laugh-out-loud moments and clever satire. John Scalzi had already proven he could balance absurd premises with sharp humor and momentum, so a moon turning into cheese felt like a slam dunk.
But somewhere between the setup and the execution, the whimsy got lost in the whey. The premise promised laughs and satire, but the book leaned so hard into realism and global reactionary politics that the fun curdled. Rather than leaning into the absurdity, the story treats it with a straight face, and for me, that sucked the joy right out of the premise.
Itās smart, and I can see why it resonates with others as thoughtful speculative fiction with heart. The characters feel real, and there are flashes of insight about society facing the unknown. But for me, the humor fizzled early, the pacing felt scattered with all the jumping perspectives, and I just wasnāt invested enough to push through. I went in chasing cozy chaos and quirky laughs; what I got was more earnest pondering than the promised cheese-fueled romp. DNFād it, which always stings with an author I usually adore.
Would I Recommend it? If you love Scalziās exploratory side and donāt mind slow pacing, give it a try. But humor-seekersāmaybe skip this one. For me, it was a DNF.
Say Cheeseā¦ or Pass? Were you expecting humor from this book too, or did the serious tone work for you? Is a cheese moon peak sci-fi chaos or a bridge too far? Letās debate it in the comments.
š±š Read on Kindle š 326 pages ā± Approx. 4 hours reading time š·ļø Publisher: Tor Books
After Starter Villain, I was ready for another dose of Scalziās signature humor and charm. A moon made of cheese? Thatās camp-core sci-fi gold right there. The setup had me grinning. The sheer ridiculousness of humanity staring up at a giant dairy orb promised laugh-out-loud moments and clever satire. John Scalzi had already proven he could balance absurd premises with sharp humor and momentum, so a moon turning into cheese felt like a slam dunk.
But somewhere between the setup and the execution, the whimsy got lost in the whey. The premise promised laughs and satire, but the book leaned so hard into realism and global reactionary politics that the fun curdled. Rather than leaning into the absurdity, the story treats it with a straight face, and for me, that sucked the joy right out of the premise.
Itās smart, and I can see why it resonates with others as thoughtful speculative fiction with heart. The characters feel real, and there are flashes of insight about society facing the unknown. But for me, the humor fizzled early, the pacing felt scattered with all the jumping perspectives, and I just wasnāt invested enough to push through. I went in chasing cozy chaos and quirky laughs; what I got was more earnest pondering than the promised cheese-fueled romp. DNFād it, which always stings with an author I usually adore.
Would I Recommend it? If you love Scalziās exploratory side and donāt mind slow pacing, give it a try. But humor-seekersāmaybe skip this one. For me, it was a DNF.
Say Cheeseā¦ or Pass? Were you expecting humor from this book too, or did the serious tone work for you? Is a cheese moon peak sci-fi chaos or a bridge too far? Letās debate it in the comments.