Emily

Well, that was a ride! I really love this novel. I think sometimes the detail with which the events are described is a little too much, but overall the premise and the story was really fun, and I really enjoyed it.
I do wish. Perhaps the author had explored more about being main characters double standard on AI. I also wish. Maybe the ending had an epilogue or something to kind of tie it often. Let us know what happened to Hester afterwards.
I overall highly recommend this book for an adventure and sci-fi .

Dang that was the longest cave exploration ever.
Excellent commentary on the sad reality of religious zealotry, and the cruelty of involving children before they are able to choose for themselves.

I love this series but I am tiring of how many times she has to mention Myrna's fatness, or how much the poor makes her uncomfortable. It's not really compassionate or meaningful to the story either.

Incredible, cozy, compassionate...just right.

would have been a solid 4 star read, but that ending was abrupt and weird.

Ugh. Boring and weirdly discriminatory.

I like the little allegories to genesis and etc. the idea of Christianity as a fantasy fable is sweet, even if not what cs Lewis meant.

Second part is boring, first part is one of the creepiest things I have ever read. If you are into conspiracy/paranormal this first section at least is a MUST READ.

Absolutely excellent. Wonderful scholarship.

Excellent, concise, inspired introduction to North Indian Art music. Perhaps best fitted to a music student studying world music.

Plot inconsistencies, resurrections, science lies, and human flaws aside, this is a fun and riveting read and I recommend it to anyone.

This was a fantastic book. It is clearly and simply written, and generally rather accessible for someone who is not familiar with classical music or pianistic technique. That said, classical pianists and musicians of all kinds should read this book. Claudio Arrau was the last of his kind in many ways, and there is much to be learned here. What I found most surprising was the frankness by which he presented his profound spiritual knowledge and then connection with the music he played. I recommend this book to anyone interested in the subject.

I read this at the recommendation of Claudio Arrau in his interviews. From the context of a performer this book is incredibly useful.

I loved Hoffmanns writing in high school. You can count on her for intimate, tragic, and passionate storytelling, with an element of the mysterious and magical. In the context of her writing, this set of short stories seems like a better idea on paper than in the realization. Her storytelling seems to work better with a more developed storyline and intimacy with the characters. Her familiar tactics of emotionally charged writing, in some places, come off as melodramatic and even cheesy in the context of these short stunted story lines.

I could go into why this is such an enduring classic, but it would be to reiterate what thousands of English scholars have better said before me. Just read it.

Idk, having reread it in adulthood, the story is weaker than other young adult fantasies I've read.
The children are a bit two dimensional, especially the girls being prized mainly for their beauty and gentleness. They are also not allowed to participate in the battle, etc.
There are other stories that tell fantasies for children better.
The story of Aslan is moving, as is the story of Jesus Christ...but come on...
Four random British children walk into a new world and suddenly they have divine right to be rulers of it? As dictated by Aslan( and by extension, God?)
Glorification of White saviors, violent colonialism, and even misogyny is not something I really need my children to read.
Pass.

Damn, what I wouldn't give for this kind of welcoming, enveloping, compassionate community again.
This book will shine like sunny springtime in my memory. I love all these characters, even the frogs.