Chris M

This story felt like opening a memory you didn’t know you’d tucked away. Jasper’s senior trip to Mexico City is painted with all the excitement of youth: bright streets, historic landmarks, the thrill of being somewhere new. You can almost feel his wide-eyed wonder as he soaks it all in.

What really made my heart ache in the best way was the quiet, unexpected romance. It’s not loud or dramatic, just the kind of tender connection that sneaks up on you, the kind you don’t plan for but suddenly can’t stop thinking about. The way Jasper stumbles into love feels so genuine, hesitant, hopeful, a little shy, yet deeply affecting.

It reminded me of those fleeting moments when you’re young and everything feels heightened: the brush of a hand, the nervous laughter, the possibility hanging in the air. By the end, I wasn’t just smiling at Jasper’s journey, I was remembering my own. As the Leaves Turn Red lingers softly, leaving behind that gentle ache of nostalgia, like the memory of a first crush you’ll never quite forget.

Frankly, I struggled writing this review. Everything I tried just didn’t capture how I felt while reading Of Sunlight and Stardust. Cole’s journey to find his footing again after prison, Tanner’s emotional wandering after losing his wife, and the way their lives slowly move toward each other is tender in a way that’s hard to put into words. It feels like something settling into place.

“If anything happens to us…if anyone finds this journal…it was worth it. Charlie will always be worth it, and I know he feels the same.” This quiet promise holds the heart of the story, giving every moment its meaning. It’s a simple vow carrying the weight of courage and hope, turning their journey into a tender testament to love’s enduring power. It lingers softly, a gentle reminder of what truly matters.

This book made me smile and laugh from start to finish. It has that perfect mix of sweetness and nostalgia, the kind that pulls you right back into being young and having a crush that makes you shy for no reason. The awkwardness, the butterflies, the tiny moments that feel huge when you’re that age all felt so familiar in the best way.

It’s light, charming, and genuinely joyful. Just a really lovely reminder of how simple and exciting those early feelings can be. And if you’ve read You, Me, and Mayberry, it’s such a fun little spinoff that adds even more warmth to that world.