Lots of things I liked in this quick read—some of the alien-ness of the aliens was very compelling; i felt some of the threads here (the robot who longs to be a person) were kind of half-baked, but the central mystery and reveals are pretty good. Overall a little less substantial than i hoped, i guess.
I don't know if i should now go restart the book of the short sun, the book of the long sun, or the book of the new sun. I'll reread them all, but now they all have different compelling reasons to do so.
The way Long Sun is recontextualized as an in-universe text written by characters in Short Sun, the way Severian was evidently influenced by a meeting with (????) and (??????) also puts new spin on new sun. Ha
Clearly a transmasc narrative. Maybe half interesting content, 1/4 stuff i skimmed, 1/4 unfortunate colonialism/racism. Sort of enlightened/benevolent on some points but has hideous racial caricatures (like, drawings, actual ones) as well. Super weird stuff, but I can't bear seeing that rating sit so low
I love almost everything RJB has ever written, but I thought Foundryside was weak and this was almost unlistenable due to the combination of narrator and very distracting dialogue.
The #1 worst and most frustrating thing is hearing “reality” spoken approximately 30 times a chapter while they discuss nuts and bolts of scriving.
I thought i should push myself to finish this one, if the trilogy is wrapping, but I really doubt I'll read the third.