Carolina Novo
Okay. It's very difficult to talk about this book, because, honestly, I just don't know what can be said about it instead of 'read it '. Might not be your favourite book, might have flaws or whatever, but it's truly one of those that I think cannot be experienced if not by reading it. Schmidt wrote a novel that is so layered and about so many things, that at a certain point - I have to confess -, I, too, didn't know what to think about it. I was a bit lost. But then. Oh well. Then it all makes sense. And then it hits you. And then, after all the things it was about, it becomes about something you didn't see coming. at least I didn't. It is not only a plot twist that made me gasp out loud, shocked. It's a whole turn, it is a new book. And it beats and suffocates you, and seems a bit repetitive but I think it's on purpose, and if you are like me, you'll feel numb for a long time reading it, like the characters, and then, you will be brutally shaken back to life.
Exceed my expectations by far.
Okay. It's very difficult to talk about this book, because, honestly, I just don't know what can be said about it instead of 'read it '. Might not be your favourite book, might have flaws or whatever, but it's truly one of those that I think cannot be experienced if not by reading it. Schmidt wrote a novel that is so layered and about so many things, that at a certain point - I have to confess -, I, too, didn't know what to think about it. I was a bit lost. But then. Oh well. Then it all makes sense. And then it hits you. And then, after all the things it was about, it becomes about something you didn't see coming. at least I didn't. It is not only a plot twist that made me gasp out loud, shocked. It's a whole turn, it is a new book. And it beats and suffocates you, and seems a bit repetitive but I think it's on purpose, and if you are like me, you'll feel numb for a long time reading it, like the characters, and then, you will be brutally shaken back to life.
Exceed my expectations by far.
there are many criteria you can follow to review a book, but I don't feel like I can apply them here, and I don't want to. some books are just brilliant because how they make you laugh, cry, be glad to be alive, wrap around you like a warm hug. this is exactly the book you need if you want a page-turning, lovely and sad story about sisters, if you want to restore your faith in the world. this is a real comfort book, so warm that you can't stop reading it - but it was touches very important themes such as female health and available responses, addiction, pain and grief. it is also very beautiful, emotional, and well and sensibly written. also: potentially extra destructive to people with sisters. be careful.
there are many criteria you can follow to review a book, but I don't feel like I can apply them here, and I don't want to. some books are just brilliant because how they make you laugh, cry, be glad to be alive, wrap around you like a warm hug. this is exactly the book you need if you want a page-turning, lovely and sad story about sisters, if you want to restore your faith in the world. this is a real comfort book, so warm that you can't stop reading it - but it was touches very important themes such as female health and available responses, addiction, pain and grief. it is also very beautiful, emotional, and well and sensibly written. also: potentially extra destructive to people with sisters. be careful.
this was one of those books I only discovered after wandering around the bookstore for hours, waiting for something to catch my eye and beg to be taken home. this one shouted at me - with its title, cover, premise - and I’m so glad I listened. Andrea does something absolutely incredible, something I’ve also recognized in other authors like Layla Martinez and Irene Solà: she writes in a way I’ve simply never, ever seen before.
It’s striking how these women manage to write from the gut; more, with their guts - that’s really what it is. they spill their pain, love, rage, disgust, and violence onto the page exactly as they felt and feel it, with no filter or polish, as if they opened up their stomachs and laid everything bare in front of us, without shame or flinching. that’s how we end up with works like this, unlike anything else — in my opinion. they speak to us face-to-face, in the language of our childhoods and teenage years, or of our aunts and grandmothers, our mothers or the old women of the village.
the author doesn't just tell a story - she creates a world so solid, so close to the one we know (yet with its own peculiarities) that it’s impossible to pass through it to the other side, it’s too thick, too dense. the language and form in this book are brilliant too: a mix of the popular people and from the teenagers who live far from everything and slowly learn about the world through "méssejer" and other ways that bring news, bit by bit, to places where nothing moves or changes, not even the wind.
preserving the unique ways of speaking in the Canary Islands isn’t just a valuable and remarkable political or social act of rebelion - it's literary gold. and here, the excellent translation work must be also acknowledged. the collaboration between the Portuguese and Spanish translators resulted, in my opinion, in one of the best translations I’ve ever read. sure, I didn’t read the original, and I know nothing about translation, but I know that I never once felt like I was reading one (which often happens to me), and at a certain point, I honestly forgot I wasn’t reading Andrea Abreu’s exact, original, words.
the author has been compared to Ferrante, and I get why - it's especially obvious in the friendship-competition-desire dynamic between the female protagonists (Isora and the narrator here, Lila and Elena in Ferrante). I have to say - and maybe this is just a personal thing - that this kind of dynamic isn’t really my favorite thing; in fact, it makes me deeply uncomfortable (which I suppose is partly the point).
maybe it’s because I was once the kind of kid who would “jump off the bridge if she told me to” for my best friend, but I find it hard to relate to the “leaders” of these pairs — Lila and Isora, and their meaningless and casual cruelty. I know the complexity and violence in these relationships is intentional (and masterfully crafted), but it always makes me feel a bit more distant from the characters.
that’s probably one of the only things I “liked less” about the book, although obviously, it’s completely personal and tied to my own feelings, haha. additionally, I just feel like the characters (all of them, really) are so rich that they deserved a bit more development, and that the real ending of the story comes just before the final page. I think it would’ve been stronger if it had ended slightly earlier.
still, I’m giving it five stars — because, once again, I’ve never seen anything like it, and I’m in love with Andrea.
this was one of those books I only discovered after wandering around the bookstore for hours, waiting for something to catch my eye and beg to be taken home. this one shouted at me - with its title, cover, premise - and I’m so glad I listened. Andrea does something absolutely incredible, something I’ve also recognized in other authors like Layla Martinez and Irene Solà: she writes in a way I’ve simply never, ever seen before.
It’s striking how these women manage to write from the gut; more, with their guts - that’s really what it is. they spill their pain, love, rage, disgust, and violence onto the page exactly as they felt and feel it, with no filter or polish, as if they opened up their stomachs and laid everything bare in front of us, without shame or flinching. that’s how we end up with works like this, unlike anything else — in my opinion. they speak to us face-to-face, in the language of our childhoods and teenage years, or of our aunts and grandmothers, our mothers or the old women of the village.
the author doesn't just tell a story - she creates a world so solid, so close to the one we know (yet with its own peculiarities) that it’s impossible to pass through it to the other side, it’s too thick, too dense. the language and form in this book are brilliant too: a mix of the popular people and from the teenagers who live far from everything and slowly learn about the world through "méssejer" and other ways that bring news, bit by bit, to places where nothing moves or changes, not even the wind.
preserving the unique ways of speaking in the Canary Islands isn’t just a valuable and remarkable political or social act of rebelion - it's literary gold. and here, the excellent translation work must be also acknowledged. the collaboration between the Portuguese and Spanish translators resulted, in my opinion, in one of the best translations I’ve ever read. sure, I didn’t read the original, and I know nothing about translation, but I know that I never once felt like I was reading one (which often happens to me), and at a certain point, I honestly forgot I wasn’t reading Andrea Abreu’s exact, original, words.
the author has been compared to Ferrante, and I get why - it's especially obvious in the friendship-competition-desire dynamic between the female protagonists (Isora and the narrator here, Lila and Elena in Ferrante). I have to say - and maybe this is just a personal thing - that this kind of dynamic isn’t really my favorite thing; in fact, it makes me deeply uncomfortable (which I suppose is partly the point).
maybe it’s because I was once the kind of kid who would “jump off the bridge if she told me to” for my best friend, but I find it hard to relate to the “leaders” of these pairs — Lila and Isora, and their meaningless and casual cruelty. I know the complexity and violence in these relationships is intentional (and masterfully crafted), but it always makes me feel a bit more distant from the characters.
that’s probably one of the only things I “liked less” about the book, although obviously, it’s completely personal and tied to my own feelings, haha. additionally, I just feel like the characters (all of them, really) are so rich that they deserved a bit more development, and that the real ending of the story comes just before the final page. I think it would’ve been stronger if it had ended slightly earlier.
still, I’m giving it five stars — because, once again, I’ve never seen anything like it, and I’m in love with Andrea.
