fay
I picked up this book from my local library because it had an interesting premise. I'll be breaking down my review into segments, focusing on different aspects of the graphic novel.
Starting off with the worldbuilding, I enjoyed what I got to see. The society on Mars gave off major solarpunk vibes, which I'm always up for in sci-fi stories. I like the details of stairs in the university being able to convert to wheelchair ramps when needed, and the library having robotic owls as assistants is soooo cute :3. I just wish we got to see more of the universe, like how humans came to colonize Mars and what life back on Earth is like. There was a tidbit with the museum timeline that mentioned capitalism was overthrown which piqued my interest. The element of human cloning being prominent is an interesting one as well.
The characters are more or less okay, I didn't mind the protagonist. I do feel like her story was under-explored in some aspects as was Kye's (who'll I'll get to in a bit). Like what happened to her mom that made her want a clone of herself to live vicariously through? What was her mom like before Clem's conception? Does Clem have friends or relatives back on Earth that she keeps in touch with?
I also feel like Clem and Kye's relationship felt rushed (even shoehorned in, dare i say, even though it's the focal point of the story). It progressed too fast for me to feel natural, which is something I always look for when it comes to M/F relationships. I get this is a romance novel but why not show more moments of their friendship before their feelings blossom? Honestly, I wasn't feeling the more intimate moments between them (especially the scenes in Dr. Han's house).
Kye is also painfully underwritten. I wish we got to see things from his POV more often, and not just moments between him and Clem and/or Dr. Lin. His personality is a bit flat to me, which is a given considering Dr. Ada raised him to be a lab/personal assistant and nothing more. She probably didn't let him cultivate his own interests besides plants, but c'mon! At least give him something that doesn't involve his mom or love interest.
Speaking of Kye, the backdoor glitch being caused by him thinking about Clem is somewhat confusing to me. I can kiiiinda get the link between the photos she shared to him being of plant matter and nature on Earth and the fact his past/human self had a special interest in plants, but why is Clem the cause? Is it solely because she was the one to share the photos with him? Wouldn't it make more sense for him to think about Earth? Idk i hate how vague certain elements of the plot are.
Additionally, how was Dr Lin able to program her late son's consciousness into Kye? Did she develop an AI based off her son's memories or did she somehow extract a physical component from him and implement it into Kye's code? Does Kye even know the boy he sees whenever he glitches is Dr. Lin's son/his past self? Yet another aspect of the story I felt didn't get enough time to develop.
Overall, I enjoyed the art and the world of the novel, but the characters and the relationship between Clem and Kye left much to be desired. I feel like if the story was longer and more aspects expanded upon I would have enjoyed this graphic novel a lot more.
SENA best boi though i will not deny his cuteness >w<
I picked up this book from my local library because it had an interesting premise. I'll be breaking down my review into segments, focusing on different aspects of the graphic novel.
Starting off with the worldbuilding, I enjoyed what I got to see. The society on Mars gave off major solarpunk vibes, which I'm always up for in sci-fi stories. I like the details of stairs in the university being able to convert to wheelchair ramps when needed, and the library having robotic owls as assistants is soooo cute :3. I just wish we got to see more of the universe, like how humans came to colonize Mars and what life back on Earth is like. There was a tidbit with the museum timeline that mentioned capitalism was overthrown which piqued my interest. The element of human cloning being prominent is an interesting one as well.
The characters are more or less okay, I didn't mind the protagonist. I do feel like her story was under-explored in some aspects as was Kye's (who'll I'll get to in a bit). Like what happened to her mom that made her want a clone of herself to live vicariously through? What was her mom like before Clem's conception? Does Clem have friends or relatives back on Earth that she keeps in touch with?
I also feel like Clem and Kye's relationship felt rushed (even shoehorned in, dare i say, even though it's the focal point of the story). It progressed too fast for me to feel natural, which is something I always look for when it comes to M/F relationships. I get this is a romance novel but why not show more moments of their friendship before their feelings blossom? Honestly, I wasn't feeling the more intimate moments between them (especially the scenes in Dr. Han's house).
Kye is also painfully underwritten. I wish we got to see things from his POV more often, and not just moments between him and Clem and/or Dr. Lin. His personality is a bit flat to me, which is a given considering Dr. Ada raised him to be a lab/personal assistant and nothing more. She probably didn't let him cultivate his own interests besides plants, but c'mon! At least give him something that doesn't involve his mom or love interest.
Speaking of Kye, the backdoor glitch being caused by him thinking about Clem is somewhat confusing to me. I can kiiiinda get the link between the photos she shared to him being of plant matter and nature on Earth and the fact his past/human self had a special interest in plants, but why is Clem the cause? Is it solely because she was the one to share the photos with him? Wouldn't it make more sense for him to think about Earth? Idk i hate how vague certain elements of the plot are.
Additionally, how was Dr Lin able to program her late son's consciousness into Kye? Did she develop an AI based off her son's memories or did she somehow extract a physical component from him and implement it into Kye's code? Does Kye even know the boy he sees whenever he glitches is Dr. Lin's son/his past self? Yet another aspect of the story I felt didn't get enough time to develop.
Overall, I enjoyed the art and the world of the novel, but the characters and the relationship between Clem and Kye left much to be desired. I feel like if the story was longer and more aspects expanded upon I would have enjoyed this graphic novel a lot more.
SENA best boi though i will not deny his cuteness >w<