Katherine
Updated a reading goal:
Read 16k pages in 2026
Progress so far: 1290 / 15600 8%
Updated a reading goal:
Read 8k pages in 2026
Progress so far: 1290 / 7800 16%
Updated a reading goal:
Read 4k pages in 2026
Progress so far: 1290 / 3600 35%
Well written and strongly argued. I really appreciate the decision to cover the Scottish and Irish situations as fully as they are, I only wish they were integrated more into the text rather than being separate chapters, as it breaks up the flow a bit. But I nitpick. Excellent grounding in the sources, overall very persuaded by the thesis and looking forward to tackling the second volume
Well written and strongly argued. I really appreciate the decision to cover the Scottish and Irish situations as fully as they are, I only wish they were integrated more into the text rather than being separate chapters, as it breaks up the flow a bit. But I nitpick. Excellent grounding in the sources, overall very persuaded by the thesis and looking forward to tackling the second volume
Updated a reading goal:
Read 16k pages in 2026
Progress so far: 898 / 15600 5%
Updated a reading goal:
Read 8k pages in 2026
Progress so far: 898 / 7800 11%
Updated a reading goal:
Read 4k pages in 2026
Progress so far: 898 / 3600 24%
Well written and strongly argued. I really appreciate the decision to cover the Scottish and Irish situations as fully as they are, I only wish they were integrated more into the text rather than being separate chapters, as it breaks up the flow a bit. But I nitpick. Excellent grounding in the sources, overall very persuaded by the thesis and looking forward to tackling the second volume
Well written and strongly argued. I really appreciate the decision to cover the Scottish and Irish situations as fully as they are, I only wish they were integrated more into the text rather than being separate chapters, as it breaks up the flow a bit. But I nitpick. Excellent grounding in the sources, overall very persuaded by the thesis and looking forward to tackling the second volume
