Jeffrey B

As always, each reading offers a new round of thoughtful questions, and the reassurance that I don't toil alone. A comforting, beautiful book.

Follows all of the contours of a shonen manga, but pulls no punches in its depictions of violence. It was incredibly fast-paced and action-packed. Felt a little thin in places, but overall, I had a lot of fun with this one.

A superposition of 1-star and 5-stars. There's honestly no other way to describe a book this boneheaded and ambitious.

Reader beware, though: if you want to pick this up because you're interested in the pitch, know that it is not a critique or engagement with Watchmen as a text. It is Geoff Johns yelling at Alan Moore for several hundred pages.

An incredibly imaginative series hampered by bad art.

Plenty of violence, epic and sweeping scope, nice little narrative framing. Not sure if it's as edgy as it thinks.