Karsten

The book does not provide anything radically new but a nice template for many conversations along some insights from science and practical advice. I appreciate the compactness and that it does not try to be more than it is. Let's see how well I can apply the main idea in practice.

An interesting book around the idea of tight and loose organizations and societies. It gives a unique perspective on many challenges today especially when tight and loose cultures meet. However, at times the connection feels a bit constructed in a sense that suddenly everything should be viewed through this lens. But nonetheless a worthwhile read to broaden your horizon and vocabulary when it comes to characterizing and interacting with different groups.

Overall, I heard a lot about the book beforehand but found it a bit underwhelming. The psychoanalytic perspective on the author's time in the concentration camps was very interesting but the second part of the book about logotherapy was a bit to esoteric and way to repetitive and anecdotal for my taste. I agree with the main point that meaning in life can be a very powerful force but I'm not sure about centering everything around it. Looks to me like a hammer and nails situation...

The book provides an interesting and refreshing perspective on failures, when to avoid and when to actually embrace them. I especially liked the many examples from real life to illustrate the point. As a scientist, many of the ideas are already second nature, but having them spelled out like this I also saw their application (or my lack thereof) in other areas of life.

Overall a very great and eye-opening book with lots of history from around the world in it. The book has its lengths and sometimes puts too much emphasis on its core idea. But it over all added a very new perspective for me, which is all I hoped for.