I wanted this one to work for me more than it did, but I never really connected with the characters or got invested in the story. There are some interesting ideas here and the writing has its moments, but overall it kept me at a distance and just didn’t land for me.

This one expands the world without losing what makes the series work. The action is still sharp, but the real draw here is the dynamic between Murderbot and ART. Their back-and-forth is easily the best part — dry, awkward, and weirdly sincere under all the sarcasm.

The story leans more into investigation and self-reflection than pure survival, which slows the pace slightly compared to book one, but it adds depth. You get a stronger sense of who Murderbot is when it’s not just reacting to immediate danger.

It’s smart, tense, funny in that deadpan way, and surprisingly thoughtful about autonomy and identity. Not quite as tight as the first novella for me, but it strengthens the series in a big way.

Contains spoilers

This wraps up the floor in full chaos mode, balancing absurd humor with real consequences in a way the series does best. The stakes jump again, the system keeps changing the rules, and Carl’s wins come with uncomfortable costs that clearly won’t stay contained.

It’s fast, brutal, and funny, but there’s a lingering unease underneath the spectacle that makes the setup for what’s next feel genuinely dangerous rather than just bigger.