
The three intertwined timelines in the same physical space was well done, and the interlinked stories easy to follow. For the most part the characters were well written, and the authors intent for your trust, distrust, like, and dislike felt very balanced.
Unfortunately I found the ending unsatisfying, and the relationship between the two “now” characters a bit too 2 dimensional, and their relationship troubles a bit disheartening.
Overall, I'm glad to have read it, and would recommend it.
4.75 out of 5. Absolutely sensational!!
0.25 is only because occasionally the author would jump around perspective between paragraphs, which was confusing, but it was only a small bit, and you'd easily readjust.
For a debut novel, amazing. Well done Emma!
Also, the twist? Holy Mother, I was not ready, and could not predict it. Just wow!

Cons:
- The characters are quite wooden, with their development either rushed, or done “off screen”.
- Some parts of the story are too shallow/glossed over, and others way too detailed; as such, the reading can be stilted, and jarring.
Pros:
- Absolutely wicked fun.
- Overall a good story, with some great action.
- The writing is somewhat simplistic, it's easy to get into the groove and visualise, and so it can be a real page turner.
I enjoyed it, and will likely read it again someday. I'm keen for the sequels.
I wish I could go back and rank the previous books as 4.5 stars, so that I could give this the full 5 stars, but alas.
This is my absolute favourite of the Sandman series. You would benefit from reading the preceding 11 books to provide the firm appreciation of The Dreaming, and the Dream King, but even alone it is a stunning read.
Yoshitaka Amano's art is simply breathtaking. It is so perfectly matched with the text, but completely stand alone in its own right.
Ian Rankin is quoted(1) as describing this book as “A gaslighting masterclass”, and I couldn't agree more!
Some reviewers have stated that the book starts slowly, and it can feel that way, but if you've ever had to deal with a family like Emma's, and the onset of insomnia, Sarah plays it out absolutely superb.
There are aspects of the story telling that frustrate me, but I'm unsure if it's my frustration with the characters (bloody hell men are the worst) or the way the lack of communication is written. I did find myself irritated at times, and not just at the characters.
All in all, a fantastic read, and highly recommended.
Footnotes
1. First edition paperback, rear cover
The negative reviews, I feel, stem from people who've never suffered the traumas that drive this story.
For anyone who has suffered the extreme side of bullying in school, and the punishment you receive when you are finally worn down to nothing, this book hits hard.
To those who've suffered at the hands of a family member abusing the love and trust that is instilled from infancy, and been abused, this book hits hard.
There is some closure I would have preferred, or some more stated justice spoken, but overall this book was sensational.
You seriously don't know what's coming next. The twists in this book are frequent, and just brilliant. They come on so subtly sometimes, and other times BAM, whiplash.
There are aspects that almost make this non-fiction, in how genuinely [expletive] men are. I don't think it's a spoiler, but a fact of the world we live in.
But, this book is amazing, and the ending let's the imagination run wild, and, maybe, there is closure in your imagination...