 Sour Candy
| 74 reads | 3.52 |
 The Collective
| 36 reads | 3.78 |
 The Pallbearers' Club
| 3 reads | 3.67 |
 The Cabin at the End of the World
| 199 reads | 3.35 |
 Too Late
| 52 reads | 3.55 |
 Pretty Girls
| 225 reads | 4 |
 My Heart Is a Chainsaw
| 129 reads | 3.73 |
 The Wife Upstairs
| 102 reads | 3.41 |
 Verity
| 711 reads | 3.74 |
 The Last House on Needless Street
| 218 reads | 3.92 |
 The Boy on the Bridge
| 56 reads | 3.98 |
 The Ritual
| 46 reads | 3.35 |
 Mexican Gothic
| 558 reads | 3.72 |
 The Girl with All the Gifts
| 408 reads | 3.97 |
 Cunning Folk
| 11 reads | 3.8 |
 Such a Pretty Smile
| 11 reads | 3.33 |
 The Maid
| 354 reads | 3.55 |
 A Flicker in the Dark
| 199 reads | 3.48 |
 The Push
| 204 reads | 3.91 |
 The Silkworm
| 250 reads | 3.9 |
 14 Ways to Die
| 18 reads | 3.56 |
 The Deep
| 61 reads | 3.35 |
 Gone to See the River Man
| 51 reads | 3.77 |
 Little Heaven
| 20 reads | 3.32 |
 The Troop
| 191 reads | 3.7 |
 House of Leaves
| 366 reads | 4.11 |
 Billy Summers
| 239 reads | 4.11 |
 The Maidens
| 258 reads | 3.42 |
 The Last Time I Lied
| 145 reads | 3.91 |
 The Devil All the Time
| 48 reads | 3.98 |
 Things Have Gotten Worse Since We Last Spoke
| 168 reads | 3.19 |
 The Only Good Indians
| 213 reads | 3.79 |
 Devolution
| 111 reads | 3.62 |
 I'm Thinking of Ending Things
| 316 reads | 3.69 |
 The Damnation Game
| 14 reads | 3.33 |
 Confessions
| 143 reads | 3.93 |
 Burial Rites
| 77 reads | 4.02 |
 Life After Life
| 171 reads | 3.61 |
 Never Let Me Go
| 765 reads | 3.81 |
 The Elephant Tree
| 4 reads | 4 |
 Swan Song
| 92 reads | 4.11 |
 A Little Life | 520 reads | 4.14 |
 Pet Sematary
| 584 reads | 3.94 |
 'Salem's Lot
| 583 reads | 3.83 |
 The Devil Aspect
| 8 reads | 4.14 |
 Hidden Bodies
| 58 reads | 3.18 |
 Shelter Mountain
| 27 reads | 4.14 |
 A Private Cathedral
| 2 reads | 4.5 |
 The 7½ Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle
| 532 reads | 3.89 |
 Never Let You Go
| 21 reads | 3.5 |