A Nutcracker Nightmare

Book Review: A Nutcracker Nightmare by Christina Romeril

Rating: 3 Stars

First off, let me start by saying that I absolutely adore the festive and eye-catching cover of A Nutcracker Nightmare by Christina Romeril. It immediately drew me in and set the tone for a cozy holiday-themed mystery. However, as much as I wanted to love this book like its predecessor, I found myself slightly disappointed.

The story revolves around twin sisters Hanna and Alex, owners of the Murder and Mayhem book and chocolate shop, as they prepare for Harriston High School's reunion. Excited to reunite with old friends and perhaps avoid old enemies, the sisters find themselves in the midst of a murder investigation when they stumble upon the dead body of a former classmate.

One of the book's strengths lies in its unique setting—a bookstore slash chocolate shop with chocolates named after poisons. This quirky concept adds an intriguing twist to the story and sets it apart from other cozy mysteries. Romeril's attention to detail in describing the shop and its delectable offerings is notworthy, making it a delight to imagine being there.

However, while the setting shines, the same cannot be said for the characters. In comparison to the first book in the series, Hanna and Alex were less likable in A Nutcracker Nightmare. Their actions and decisions at times left me frustrated and disconnected from their journey. Additionally, the sheer number of characters introduced throughout the story made it difficult to keep track of everyone, leading to confusion and a lack of depth in their development.

Furthermore, I found the identity of the culprit glaringly obvious from very early on. There was a lack of suspense and surprises, which are essential elements in a mystery novel. As a result, the plot felt predictable, leaving me wanting more intricate twists and turns.

In conclusion, while A Nutcracker Nightmare didn't quite live up to my expectations, it still had its charms. The unique setting of a bookstore slash chocolate shop is undoubtedly captivating, and I commend Romeril's ability to create an immersive environment within her writing. Although I found the characters less likable and the plot somewhat predictable, I am willing to give this series another chance with book three. Romeril has shown promise in her storytelling, and I hope to see growth and improvement in future installments.

⚠️This review was written based on personal opinions and experiences with the book. Individual preferences may vary⚠️