Sino-Japanese Relations in Space and Time
Ratings1
Average rating3
Joshua Fogel offers an incisive historical look at Sino-Japanese relations from three different perspectives. Using first a wide lens, he suggests a new way to capture the relationship between China and Japan by characterizing the nature of their contact. From the first century CE, the primary reasons for contact moved from political and ceremonial to cultural, and on to commercial ties. This period ends at the dawn of the modern age, when contacts involved treaties, consulates, and international law. Switching to a microhistorical view, Fogel examines several important behind-the-scenes players in the launching of the countries’ modern diplomatic relations. He focuses on the voyage of the Senzaimaru from Nagasaki to Shanghai in 1862—the first official meeting of Chinese and Japanese in the modern era—and the Dutchman who played an important intermediary role. Finally, he examines the first expatriate Japanese community in the modern era, in Shanghai from the 1860s to the mid-1890s, when the first Sino-Japanese War erupted. Introducing the concept of “Sinosphere” to capture the nature of Sino-foreign relations both spatially and temporally, Fogel presents an original and thought-provoking study on the long, complex relationship between China and Japan.
Reviews with the most likes.
These are a series of three Harvard lectures Fogel gave that have been published. The first of them is an excellent overview of Sino-Japanese relations from the Han dynasty to the late 19th century.
I very much like Fogel's conception of the “Sinosphere” as a replacement for the old “Chinese world order” and the more flexible order it suggests. I suspect the term will take off and get used in other scholarship.
The second essay feels a bit out of place but this often happens in the case of these lectures-turned-book projects. It is more of a report on Fogel's progress on his research into the 1862 voyage of the Senzaimaru, and spends most of its time discussing the Dutch side of his archival research.
The third essay, on the Japanese community in Shanghai from the 1860s until the 1890s will be of great interest to anyone studying Sino-Japanese relations in the second half of the century or interested in the many domains of Japanese activity in Shanghai life in the late-19th century.
Featured Series
1 released bookThe Edwin O. Reischauer Lectures is a 3-book series first released in 1992 with contributions by Joshua A. Fogel, Akira Iriye, and Wang Gungwu.