Ratings3
Average rating3.3
Lio Min’s Beating Heart Baby is a love letter to internet friendships, anime, and indie rock
When artistic and sensitive Santi arrives at his new high school, everyone in the wildly talented marching band welcomes him with open arms. Everyone except for the prickly, proud musical prodigy Suwa, who doesn’t think Santi has what it takes to be in the band.
But Santi and Suwa share painful pasts, and when they open up to each other, a tentative friendship begins. And soon, that friendship turns into something more. . . .
Will their fresh start rip at the seams as Suwa seeks out a solo spotlight, and both boys come to terms with what it'll take, and what they'll have to let go, to realize their dreams?
Reviews with the most likes.
I feel like this is a book that dreamy sensitive queer/trans teens will devour and make their whole personality. It's giving [b:The Perks of Being a Wallflower 22628 The Perks of Being a Wallflower Stephen Chbosky https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1650033115l/22628.SX50.jpg 2236198]. it's giving Francesca Lia Block.Personally I loved the armchair travel aspect of the different LA neighborhoods but I like...really had a hard time suspending my disbelief over some of the Music Industry plot points. And I think that's beside the point and maybe it's best to think of that as more like a fairy tale or something. But like. A teen makes a song at home and emails it to another teen, who leaves his phone out where their record label exec aunt finds his phone, takes it to a meeting, plays the latest song on the phone for everyone at at the label, everyone at the label loses their shit and insists on releasing the song even though the teen who created it doesn't want it to be released and doesn't like...sign anything? they just release it as like, found footage I guess? And then it becomes a huge #1 hit? like why couldn't it just go regular online viral. Why is the record label involved. It's the 20s. Hello??And then just like...a LOT of coincidences along the way. Like a lot. But I think teens and other readers who are vibing more with the dreamy characters will be less likely to question that stuff. But I am 30 or 40 years old and I have some questions.
This strong debut YA/NA novel celebrates queerness, found family, marching band, anime, and most of all indie music. “Side A” of the book (you know, like a record) is told from the POV of half Filipino, pansexual Santi, who has just moved to LA with Aya, his mother's best friend/guardian, to repeat his junior year of high school. It's a chance for a fresh start, as Santi has blown off school for the past few years, drifting aimlessly after his mother died and an online friendship ended disastrously. On his first day of marching band practice, he is immediately adopted by a group of seniors, most of whom are queer, and the warm, welcoming band director Cap. For the first time in years Santi has something to look forward to and a stable routine. The only wrong note is the trumpet section leader, Suwa Moon, who seems to have a personal vendetta against Santi for no apparent reason.
But after Santi helps Suwa get through a panic attack, their relationship quickly starts to change. Starting with a shared love of older, obscure anime, the two boys find a lot of common ground, and their attraction sizzles. Suwa plans to audition to be the opening act for Cola Carter, a rising female singer, so the boys will probably have to say goodbye soon, but Santi hopes that they can find a way to keep their relationship going somehow. Until a secret is revealed that changes everything that Santi and Suwa thought they knew about each other.
Side B is narrated by Japanese/Korean transmasculine Suwa, who dealt with negative, punitive reactions from family and schoolmates to his transition, to the point where he is afraid to trust anyone enough to get close. Even the other marching band members don't know the full truth. That changes when he and Santi become involved, but he still reacts impulsively when he thinks he has been betrayed.
The romance between Santi and Suwa is very angsty, especially in the second half, but Lio Min skillfully captures the joy of finally finding someone who gets you after you have been lonely for years. Suwa's lyrics are poetic and emotional, reflecting his trauma and heartbreak. He struggles with when and how to fully come out to his growing number of fans; if talking about his struggle helps others like him live their truth, isn't it selfish for him to hold back?
I know what Cola wants from me. To smile and save at the audience and talk about how grateful and proud I am to be here, and how my being here is something to celebrate. To be the T in her diverse, “queer” coalition. But I'm just a boy who's figuring out how to be a man. And I don't really feel like I have the right to celebrate anything when I'm alive, but so many of my would-be “siblings” aren't.