Doc

A western for the 2018 Read Harder Challenge. I liked this book about Doc Holliday, Wyatt Earp and Dodge City well enough. It captured a different feel about the old west than many other books–gritty and with a more realistic view of how it must have been for women. But it wasn't as engrossing, alas, as Lonesome Dove, which will always be my standard for westerns.

“‘The Emperor' is pure, virile beauty. It is everything I want you to be, Sugar. Elegant and strong and full of fire.”I was not expecting this to be as good as it was. Goodreads suggested it to me based on a single western I had read, and I am glad for it. While this book does take place in “The West”, I don't consider it a western. I don't even consider it full of action, because it doesn't have that either. Why, then, the 5-star rating? Because I loved every bit of it, in all of its slow, lyrical, deliberate glory. This is a very personal 5-star rating, but I hope you get enjoyment out of reading this book too.The book focuses on John Henry “Doc” Holliday, first as a boy growing up in Georgia, then as a very young man facing a very mortal tuberculosis sentence. A prescription of dry air and the drive to open up a dentistry practice leads Doc to Dodge City, Kansas, where we meet the cast and crew that makes up the bulk of the book. In order to manage expectations, the book does not touch, except in passing, on anything that happens in Tombstone or at the OK Corral. Nor does a whole lot happen in the book. There's a rather flat murder mystery with a dull conclusion, but the real joy and pleasure in this book comes from the various character profiles you get from everyone living in Dodge City. I greatly enjoyed reading about things from the different points of view; everyone from the larger-than-life Earps all the way down to the town's tailor. I especially loved the piano scene near the end of the story in Dodge City. It very nearly made me cry at work.I usually take a break between books in a series to read something else before coming back. This will be a very rare exception, as I have already checked out [b:Epitaph 18739541 Epitaph Mary Doria Russell https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1404411572l/18739541.SY75.jpg 26617057] from my library.

I am NOT the sort of person who reads or watches Westerns. I vaguely knew Doc Holliday, Wyatt Earp, The OK Corral and “Get out of Dodge” as concepts, but I could probably only give you a 50-50 bet on whether they were fictional or not, and I certainly had no clue that they were connected. That the OK Corral was a shootout completely exhausts my a priori knowledge of all things Western.But, Mary Doria Russell is one of those authors for me. If I could only read one book for the rest of my life, it would probably be [b:The Sparrow 334176 The Sparrow Mary Doria Russell http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1333578682s/334176.jpg 3349153], so I wasn't going to let something like a genre get in my way. That was a good move on my part. Doc is filled with rich, vivid characters. None of them are better than they ought to be, but none of them are caricatured lawless villains either. Doc is my favorite - quiet, quick to take insult, but quicker still to lend a helping hand, proud and frail, but simple, virtuous Wyatt and temperamental, brilliant, very rarely tender Kate are also beautifully depicted. To say nothing of a host of supporting characters.I am, by nature, partial to cleft lip/palate stories, and Russell's description of Holliday's cleft repair and his diction difficulties following is precision embodied. It goes without saying, given that Russell taught anatomy at my own alma mater, that her treatment of historical dentistry leaves nothing to be desired. This is, after all, a Russell novel, so it is meticulous in detail, flawlessly researched, accurate to a T. Of course, there are original characters, who, of course, include a Jesuit and multi-ethnic characters who challenge our understanding of race and racial relations. These characters flirt with being a little too perfect, especially in light of their historic setting, but overall add to the flavor (shockingly, there is no unlikely Jew of even more unlikely ethnic extraction. I kept waiting for it.)My only criticism is that, for people like me who come naive to Westerns, the book almost completely omits the OK Corral and the events directly leading up to it. Since it represents everything I will ever know about the genre, probably for the rest of my life, I would have liked Russell's take on that central piece of the Doc Holliday mythos. Nonetheless, it is by far the best book I have read that heavily features Nevadan prostitutes this month (cough [b:The Lonely Polygamist 6944566 The Lonely Polygamist Brady Udall http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1291169474s/6944566.jpg 7178069] cough_

Though a work of fiction, almost all of the characters in Russell's [b:Doc 8911226 Doc Mary Doria Russell https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1320560135s/8911226.jpg 13787599] are historical characters. The main character is John Henry Holliday, better known to most as “Doc” Holliday. When reading historical fiction based on actual historical characters, one always has to wonder how much of it is real. The answer in this case, in Mary Doria Russell's own words, is “not all of it but more than you might think.” This book is not about the famous gunfight at the O.K. corral. It covers Doc Holliday's early life but is mostly about Doc's time in Dodge City. The relationship between Doc and the Earp brothers is central to the story. It is not just a character study, however. It is also a murder mystery, and a good one.We get wild cowboys blowing off steam, gunfights, fistfights, prostitutes plying their trade, gambling for serious stakes, horse racing, murder, revenge, love, religion, and compassion all tied together by Russell's beautiful prose. What's not to like?Good book. Now on to [b:Epitaph 18739541 Epitaph Mary Doria Russell https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1404411572s/18739541.jpg 26617057].