Ratings3
Average rating3.3
Reviews with the most likes.
Well written and compelling story. Though it was written in 1949, there is little to give that fact away.
Unpopular opinion, but I really didn’t like this book. Ish is an absolutely insufferable protagonist and I couldn’t connect with him or any of the other members of The Tribe. Every time I thought something interesting was actually going to happen, it doesn’t or it’s skipped over. Ish’s self-importance and how he looks down on everyone around him drove me insane.
I was THRILLED when a glimmer of conflict came but that was also quickly washed away. The final section was the most interesting to me, but it couldn’t salvage the majority of the trudge through the most boring post apocalyptic story I have ever encountered. And I LOVE the post apocalyptic genre. From The Postman to The Stand, Mad Max to the Fallout franchise, I love it all.
I hated how Ish would think, “Gee, I should really do something about (insert x problem here),” and then proceed to NOT do anything about it. I’d rather read a book about Jack or the black family Ish contemplated turning into slaves than about the narcissist “god”.
The only good thing to come out of this book was that it apparently inspired Stephen King to write one of my all time favorite books ever, The Stand.