Emma in the Night

The story starts with a bang, as 18-year-old Cass Tanner knocks on her family's front door late one night. Cass has been missing and presumed dead, along with her older sister Emma, after they both disappeared one night three years prior. As family and investigators gather around her to hear her account of what happened that night, Cass begins to tell her story – a story that involves a baby and an escape from an island where she and Emma were being held captive. The forensic psychologist assigned to the case of the missing sisters, Dr. Abby Winter, is suspicious of how polished Cass' story seems to be, as she has long believed something else was going on in the Tanner household when the girls disappeared. In alternating chapters, Cass tells investigators how to find her sister while Abby seeks to discover what, if anything, Cass feels she still needs to hide.

The multiple POV style seems to be gaining popularity in the genre and sometimes it feels overused but here it was executed perfectly. You get to hear Cass' inner thoughts as she narrates her story for her audience, all the while following Abby as she becomes increasingly emotionally invested in the case and begins to see herself and her family in Cass'. As the book goes on both characters become less reliable, leaving you on unstable footing as a reader. For a less talented writer this could cause the characters to seem inauthentic or less sympathetic, but in Walker's skilled hand this feels more like two sincere people who cannot both possibly be telling the truth. The narration unspools like this gradually until you suddenly realize that you don't know what has been the truth and what has been a lie. Small revelations appear at just the right time, hinting at something larger that dances just out of view of the reader. When the truth comes out, it's jaw dropping. In most of my reading I can say that I saw bits of the ending coming even if I didn't actually guess the entirety of the outcome. With this one I was completely blindsided and couldn't have been happier to have been so surprised. It was entirely satisfying, especially because the book stayed strongly character driven throughout.

My only real criticism of this novel is that some of the mental illness suffered by the characters was dealt with in a heavy-handed way. I think most readers would recognize the problems this family was facing without it being spelled out so directly and it felt a bit like a “tell” rather than a “show” by the author. However it was such a small problem that the rest of the novel's strengths more than made up for this flaw.

To find a thriller that examines mental illness and it's devastating effects on a family while also maintaining a strong pace and compelling characters is a treat. This is a novel I highly recommend.

(Thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for the advance copy in exchange for an honest review.)

• 3-3.5 stars?
  
  i'm torn on my rating of this. it was really engaging and interesting, and i liked the plot and the way things were revealed. but i had a hard time following the timeline/stories being told for some reason, i actually had to relisten to a few parts, and i think i also feel lukewarm about the ending. also i think the biggest negative to me was that we were told that the narrating sister is desperate to find her other sister, but from what we learn about emma, i kind of hated her lol and just didn't really care. still a good read and i'd recommend it if you're looking for something engaging, but without anything fully shocking.