EXCELLENT. An earth shaking debut novel from Gwen Newell. Reminiscent of The Giver and The Winter King in the way that it presents darker themes in the safer medium of story for teens. And while it is definitely dark, it is not grotesque simply for its own sake. Much of the violence happens “off camera”, and while Newell is clearly already a master of mood (it was quite creepy, and cold), it wouldn't be “too much” for a teen who has been properly exposed to heavier subjects like the holocaust, North Korean prison camps, or even more detailed accounts of persecuted missionaries or martyrs.
I would go as far as saying I think this should be required reading for any teen confronting themes of governmental control, the sanctity of life, liberty, heroism, and self sacrifice. Also a good read for anyone who struggles with perfectionist tendencies, legalism, self doubt, or finding courage when faced with adversity.
Finally, it should be noted that the darkness of the story was an appropriate backdrop for the bright light of faith, hope, and love that eventually illuminates even the darkest corner of the Escape. Through the (very compelling) muck, mire, and ugliness of the dystopian world Newell paints onboard the Escape, what the reader walks away with is not despair, but a thrill of hope, and rest from a weary world. A beautiful literary picture of that ancient truth we should all hold dear, that, “The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness has not overcome it.” Highly recommend!