Ratings12
Average rating3.9
A crazy storm is coming and the Lumberjanes have to help their counselor Seafarin' Karen get her boat back from some renegade selkies.
Reviews with the most likes.
The art isn't as good now that the original artists aren't doing it. The stories are still fun and sweet, but aren't as zippy. The series isn't holding up as well but is still cute and readable
I'm so sad to say I think this may be my last adventure with the Lumberjanes. There's a noticeable difference in the story and characters with the departure of Noelle Stevenson, and I haven't been vibing with the new art style for a couple volumes. It's a major bummer, but I'm happy to say the first few volumes will easily remain among my favorite graphic novels of all time.
Story
Another solid entry. It tells a single story over four chapters it contains. The highlight for me was we got a bit more of the larger camp mystery stuff, although not as much as I'd have liked.
I tend to prefer longer arcs, but there was some good character development here along to make up for the shorter arc.
Artwork
So these chapters have another artist, Carey Pietsch who I guess replaced Carolyn Nowak? I'm not really sure. With comics it's not that uncommon for new artists to come in fairly frequently. I like her style more than Carolyn Nowak, but still not as much as I liked Brooke Allen.
I hope they stick with her though, because I'm sure I can get used to her style if they get some consistency over the next few volumes.
Series
15 primary books16 released booksLumberjanes (Collected Editions) is a 16-book series with 15 primary works first released in 2015 with contributions by Noelle Stevenson, Grace Ellis, and 5 others.