Master of Sorrows

Please check out this review and others on www.grimdarkmagazine.com or my personal blog www.beforewegoblog.com

Master of Sorrows by Justin Travis Call is the book I have been waiting for all year. Ainnevog, let's call him Annev, is a boy with a simple but not easy path before him. He works as a school deacon and takes classes to become an avatar there. An avatar is one who goes out into the world, finds magical items, and brings them back to the school so that they can be safely stored away. In the world that Call has created, magic use is verboten. If one is found to be using magic or has a magical gift, they are flayed alive and stoned. Passing the Avatar of Judgement classes and final tests for Annev is an all-consuming endeavor. Only the best can become an avatar. While taking his classes, Annev also studies and is guided by the school's priest and father figure, Sodar. How will Annev balance the two halves of his life? The public half is an avatar trainee and rule-follower, while the secret half is a magic user and possibly a destined hero. That is the crux of the story: duality.

Furthermore, to add to the duality of the plot, Annev is on the precipice of manhood. Of coming into his own and knowing who he is. But, as it stands, he is not quite a boy nor a man.

Master of Sorrows is in the style of Patrick Rothfuss's epic Name of the Wind and Pierce Brown's Red Rising series. They all share similar trajectories. A boy from dubious circumstances is thrust into a world they can not quite understand, in Master of Sorrows' case, an anti-magic school. This boy is destined for more incredible things but is hampered on all sides by morally grey characters. I say they share similar trajectories, but there is nothing bland or hackneyed in Master of Sorrows.

The plotting and backstory of Master of Sorrows is tightly done and rich in history. Annev comes from a world of gods, precisely three major ones – all siblings. Odar, Lumea, and Keos. Two gods, Odar and Lumea, are still culturally and spiritually revered by the public. But the other god, Keos, is considered the betrayer. Those who are born disabled are said to have been touched by Keos. They are considered to be in Keos's favor and are immediately put to death. But in Annev's case, as he was born without a left hand, instead of death, he was saved and raised by Sodar. This becomes another part of the duality and line that Annev must walk. He is the antithesis of everything an Avatar of Judgement is, yet he battles and struggles to excel and achieve an Avatar position while hiding his disability.

One of the detractors of the story, there are very few, is the love interest between Annev and Myjun. Watching from the position of a reader, one can look at a relationship like Annev's and Myjun's and think it is incredibly unrealistic and sometimes silly. Annev makes buffoonish decisions that make me want to shake him. But isn't that what it is like when you are 17? You make stupid choices because your body is going berzerk with hormones. As much as I cringed when reading about Annev's mooning, it is a realistic detail. To make him a full and round character, Annev needs to experience things like love, loss, and betrayal on his narrative path. This relationship is something that an older and wiser Annev in later books can pull and learn from. Also, the exposition of the story in some parts was lengthy. This is necessary due to the humongous back story and cultural context in which Annev's character exists. Sometimes, I wanted to return to the action, but these chapters are necessary.

Aside from the tight plot, one of the significant strengths of the story was the relationship between Sodar and Annev. Sodar is not all that he seems. He was living a double life; one as a priest to the students, the other as scholar and magic-user. The latter he keeps hidden from all but Annev, whom he has raised from a baby and trusts. Sodar is the stern father figure who attempts to guide Annev to his destiny while similarly protecting him from its details. They have an easiness between them that has developed throughout their shared lives, and is a testament to Call's writing skills that this came off effortlessly. I believed in their relationship, which presented no false notes to me.

Another major strength of this story is the tense action sequences. They flowed like water from scene to scene and are some of the best I have read. Whether Annev is battling wild contraptions in his bid for a position as an avatar or fighting Feurog's (creatures made of metals, stones, and flesh), the pulse-racing, edge-of-your-seat intensity kept me reading into the late hours.

The first narrative arc for Annev is done, but his story is far from over. Master of Shadows can be read as a stand-alone novel if one desires; however, the outcome was a bit of a cliffhanger that had me yearning for more. I want to know where this story is going. I want to know more about Annev and who accompanies him on the next part of his journey.
I hate that it hasn't been written yet!

Master of Sorrows is one of the best books I have read this year and a perfect example of grimdark fantasy. It isn't overly mired in negativity or cruelness. The rawer parts of grimdark and epic fantasy are there, but this story is tinged with hope in the best possible way. It is riveting, exciting, and will stick with me for a while.

I cannot wait to read the next book, a solid five-star novel, and I highly recommend it.

I really enjoyed this! It's a classic coming-of-age story, but with a few twists to make it stand out.

Reading wise, the beginning felt a little long-winded and it took me a while to get through it. I never felt like skimming any descriptions or action scenes though, so I really took it all in. The story was interesting enough and never got overly confusing or too simple.
As for the world, we haven't seen too much of it yet aside from the village, so there's lots more to explore there in the future.

But what always remains most important of all to me: characters!

I appreciate that our main character was allowed to have and make faults and be frustrating, while at the same time not begin rewarded for it and learning from it.

Sodar is the type of character that I normally like (father figure, emotionally vulnerable, protective) so him and Annev's relationship hooked me from the start. Too bad Annev had to be a total young adult about it though.

Titus is the sweetest and needs to be protected at all costs.

I am also strangely invested in a potential Fyn/Annev friendship, or just more Fyn in general. I really liked the growth he went through.

I loved the “romantic” relationship in it. As in, the reader could see that this was not any good, even if your main character couldn't. And you just hope that the writer is on the same page and doesn't try to sell it as the end all, be all of romance. I love that this didn't end up in the traditional way.

There's a lot of potential here and I am definitely keeping a look out for the sequel.

This is a good book, written by a good writer, but with flaws in the world building.The characters, the action, the “magic” system are very well developed, but the setting and world building seem to be very hit and miss. The lore and epochal battle between good and evil seems well thought out, and I liked the idea of a society that considers blasphemous being maimed or scarred. However the reasons for the whole existence of the “village” is not really clear, and its relevance also seems to be very dubious (from the inside it looks like a place that needs to exist for world order to remain, from the outside it's seen as a bunch of ninja goat herders). It feels a bit as though some element were added to provide some plot devices:- The village is entirely devoted to recovering magical artefacts because this way we can have retrieval missions and we can justify why there are so many gadgets to play with.- The ninjas are seen in the highest regard because they recover magical artefacts, so that we can have a reason for the main character to want to become one, also ninja academy- The women ninjas are mysterious and powerful so.... can't really find a reason for it, besides adding some colour (which works) and fleshing out a bit the love interest side of the story.Maybe things will be coming together better later in the saga, but for the time being we're left with a world that has many very cool aspects but no overall explanation why that is.The story is good, and the book is very enjoyable as long as you don't mind having to accept on faith that there are reasons things are as they are.I'll be interested in seeing how things progress in the sequel, I hope that as we shift from the Ender'sGame HarryPotter part of the saga to a more Wheel of Timesque one the world won't have to carry around leftover lore it collected to make for an entertaining Book 1.