Samurai William: The Englishman Who Unlocked Japan

Samurai William: The Englishman Who Unlocked Japan

2002 • 400 pages

Ratings1

Average rating3

15
Daren
DarenSupporter

Perhaps misleading with the title, this book is more than the story of William Adams. He fills a large part of the book, but it goes further, exploring the Portuguese and Spanish contacts with Japan, as well as the Dutch and English approaches. It seemed a lot less about Adams and his personal life in Japan - he was after all given a title hatamoto, a vast estate, and many retainers and labourers were his to ‘own' living on his estate, and he remained a close adviser to the Shogun.

What was obvious to Adams, but was not so to the other Englishmen was Japan's reliance on protocols and traditions, on good moral appearances and behaviour and building of relationships. Ultimately they did this less well that the Dutch, although it could be argued that neither the Portuguese, Spanish, Dutch or the English were successful enough to prevent Japan moving into the period known as sakoku the closed country, when she closed her windows on the world and denied foreigners contact for more than 200 years.

I didn't mind the style of writing, which was almost fictionalising (but wasn't) the telling, but more importantly it was nice not to have hundreds of footnotes interrupting the narrative. There was also plenty of source information contained in a separate section at the end of the book, so the lack of reference didn't effect the legitimacy of the book. Overall though it was probably slightly broader than it should have been (on subject) and contained less personal detail on the main man in my opinion, and I found my interest waning in the middle. It did improve and build to the conclusion, and overall an enjoyable enough read.

August 7, 2015Report this review