The Bitterroots
2019 • 352 pages

Ratings2

Average rating3.5

15

This originally appeared at The Irresponsible Reader as part of a quick takes post to catch up–emphasizing pithiness, not thoroughness.

Cassie's done with law enforcement (but like Harry Bosch, will always think like a cop), and is making a living as a PI. A blast from the past calls in a favor owed and hires her to do some work as an investigator for the defense in a criminal proceeding. Cassie hates the idea in general, and loathes it in particularthe client is clearly guilty. Clearly guilty of raping his teenage niece, no less. He's also a highly unpleasant personshe wouldn't want to work for him even before the rape charge. But a debt's a debt, and she figures she'll find enough evidence to get him to switch his plea to guilty and work out a deal.

Readers/Listeners know all too well that the clearly guilty part guarantees that Cassie will eat some crow on this point, but that's for later.

So Cassie travels to the very small town in northern Montana where the crime took place and the client's estranged family runs everything from their ranch to the school board and all things in betweenincluding the Sheriff's Office and Courts. Things do not go well for her and her investigationwhich just makes her think there's something for her to find to help the client after all.

I definitely listened to this too soon after In Plain Sight, one of the themes of it is repeated herenot something I'd have noticed (at least not as much) if a few more weeks had passed.

Box ultimately won me over, but I came close to DNFing this a time or two, and I really didn't enjoy most of the book. It was just a little heavy-handed, and the tie-in to a prior nemesis really didn't work for me at all (and I'm not sure the introduction of the tie-in works now that I've seen where Box was taking itit's too complicated to explain, especially for this post, let's just say I didn't like it). But by the end, I liked what Cassie got up to and how she handled herselfand I like the way that Box dealt with the climax and denouementboth were really strong (and semi-unexpected).

July 31, 2020Report this review