The Bookbinder's Daughter

When I hear “bookbinder,” I think of someone who does just that – binds books so that they can be published. But the books being bound here aren't just for sale at your local bookstore, though. Oh, no. They are so much more.

Sophie's mother died under mysterious circumstances when she was a teenager. Her father took her away from the Ayredale Library, only home she'd ever known, thinking he was saving her from...something. She's got a good job, but she's starting to question her relationship with Victor. Her uncle, Edward Talbot, reappears unexpectedly in her life after her father's death, with an offer of a job at the Library. Sophie takes it, leaving behind the manipulative Victor and all that she's known for years.

When she returns to the Library, memories begin to return in bits and pieces. Sophie hopes she can learn what happened to her mother. She also remembers the attraction she and Will, the Library's guardian, once shared, and wonders/hopes that can be rekindled. The Library is starting to feel like home again, drawing Sophie in, and she's finding her place there, remembering who she was and who she is, when her past comes crashing back in unexpectedly.

The atmosphere Thorne creates is enthralling. It calls to mind The Night Circus and Midnight at the Blackbird Cafe for me. Her word choices are exquisite, and she builds a lush, fantastical world for her characters to inhabit. The magical system she envisions is intriguing, with chaos willingly sacrificing itself for creativity to thrive, and the ideas going forth into the world, to be seeded and discovered and used. And how can you not be sucked in by a description of a tree with leaves glowing gold, swirling and falling into Sophie's hands?

The romance with Will feels a little rushed, especially as Sophie has just broken free of an abusive relationship. I understand, though, that it's made to fit the confines of a story, and there are allowances to be made. I also would have liked to know more about Will – what actually happened to turn him into the Library's guardian?

And Victor (said abusive relationship) is just SO ROTTEN. I wanted to reach into the pages and shake Sophie (just a little) when she turns away from Will to go with Victor. I know abusers can be very charming and manipulative, and I know Sophie was a young woman wounded by her past. But it's hard to imagine how she ever saw anything in him worth her time, because he's written as such a positively awful character.

Tia may have been my favorite character. So much about her seems baffling, until things click into place and her true nature is revealed.

I might have enjoyed this as book one of a duology. A second book might have given Thorne room to expand more on the characters, tell us more of how they came to be part of the Library. But overall, I found it engaging and a worthwhile read. Recommended for people who like magical realism and are willing to suspend their disbelief while they read.

Thank you to Netgalley and Bookouture for an advance reader copy. All opinions here are mine, and I don't say nice things about books I don't actually like.