The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas
Ratings7
Average rating3.7
15
Ratings7
Average rating3.7
Nine-year--old Bruno knows nothing ofthe Final Solution and the Holocaust. He is oblivious to the appalling cruelties being inflicted on the people of Europe by his country. All he knows is that he has been moved from a comfortable home in Berlin to a house in a desolate area where there is nothing to do and no-one to play with. Until he meets Shmuel, a boy who lives a strange parallel existence on the other side of the adjoining wire fence and who, like the other people there, wears a uniform of striped pyjamas.
Bruno's friendship with Shmuel will take him from innocence to revelation.. And in exploring what he is unwittingly a part of, he will inevitably become subsumed by the terrible process.
Reviews with the most likes.
Oh golly. It's 4:30AM now and I don't think I'll be able to sleep with the ache in my chest. I was sort of anticipating the ending - I guessed as much it would leave the most impact. Wasn't much a fan of the style of writing either. Didn't really like the mixture of seriousness and PG-friendly language. But still so sad :(
J'avais lu ce roman il y a quelques années et il m'avait marqué. Cette deuxième lecture m'a également plu, même si certaines maladresses et incohérences m'ont gêné par rapport à ma première lecture. Je suis devenu moins indulgent, mais ce roman reste une lecture à conseiller à tous.
3.75 (rounded up to 4) - Given how much WWII fiction I read, I'm surprised how long I procrastinated this one. Until joining a buddy read, I wasn't aware of the more problematic themes, so I went into this with some skepticism.
There are definitely major issues with the book, most of them surrounding Bruno's obliviousness and lack of empathy. What was more infuriating was the lack of correction from his family and even Schmuel. The son of a Nazi Commandant would not be in the dark about his father's role in the Holocaust — at the minimum, the Nazis' war against Jewish people — especially living next door to Auschwitz. The Nazi mentality started young. Hitler formed Hitler's youth for a terrible reason. The fact Hilter himself shows up in the story says how involved Bruno's father was. There is no way he would be so naive at the age of nine about what was happening. Not in this setting.
What was more annoying how Bruno's refusal to accept what little correction he did receive. I'm not fluent in German, but ‘Out-With' translated to German would be something along the lines of ‘Aus-Mit'. ‘Fury' would be ‘Zorn'. They aren't fitting with the language that the characters would be speaking. It was errors like this I found distracting and frustrating.
The point of view in which the book is told is where my stars come from. Though Bruno would have realistically known more, I believe he might have had questions about the way the Jewish people were being treated. This would have made a much more powerful story. That's not to say there was no impact with the friendship Bruno and Schmuel do share. At its core, it's a story about two lonely young kids finding an unlikely best friend. There is a level of innocence here that can't be denied.
Another praise is the writing. It flowed fantastically. It's just too bad that it wasn't a little bit longer and more in-depth. There was a lot of potential for more even if it is geared toward a younger audience. I see why it's received so much praise since its publication, but it is good to keep some of the issues in mind when reading. This is not an accurate portrayal of the cruelties the Nazis were capable of despite the ultimate sadness of the book. Without previous knowledge of this time, it could leave an uninformed impression, particularly on younger readers.
**EDIT: The more I've sat with this book, the more I realize I remember more of the inaccuracies than what I did like. I'm dropping the rating a tiny bit from 4 to 3.75.
