The Dream Thieves

This was much better than the first for a couple of reasons, namely I find Ronan an infinitely more interesting character than the other 3 (living) leads. There was also a lot more action and less Blue being a typical YA girl even though she's so ~weird~ and has such a ~weird~ life. I also liked the larger role of Persephone and Maura.
Making the magic of dream control and real world manifestation more complicated by adding additional “Greywarens” (or at least allowing other regular Joes to have the same abilities without the control) seems unnecessarily complicated - the rules of the world in the Raven Cycle books are already pretty iffy and this is only book 2. I would like Stiefvater to give more explanation of these rules instead of just adding more and more elements that make things confusing.
The family drama of Mr. Grey's was also weird and went unexplained. If he could have just shot his brother so easily, why didn't he do so years ago? How can the encouragement of a near stranger (Maura) suddenly make him “brave” enough to finally do it, and then it's just so easy? If his brother was so cunning and sociopathic, he wouldn't have just followed in a car and put himself in a vulnerable position, even if he was grossly underestimating Grey. It was a silly subplot that added nothing to the book, though the Mr. Grey character himself was interesting.
In conclusion, Chapter 56 is the best chapter.

Oh, to be wild in the summertime. To eat magic for breakfast and possibility for dessert. To taste immortality at the bottom of a bottle or the tip of a pill. To be seated on top of a roaring engine, to have a bank account like a bottomless pit, to have a well of dreams to build castles for your friends and a prison for yourself.

What it would be, to be a magical teenage boy.

Now that we've set the mood, how about some tunes? Barring actually listening to a symphony of rubber tearing over asphalt, I recommend Kavinsky's OutRun album (preferably “Deadcruiser” or “Testarossa Autodrive,” though Stiefvater slants towards “Blizzard” according to her Tumblr), and we're good to go.

So, Ronan Lynch. This kid's got issues. Still reeling from the horribly violent death of his father and the mandate in the will that's kept him from his childhood home, one of his close friends is a ghost, another made a deal with a magical forest, and the last is revolving around a tenuous future that banks on the location of a centuries dead Welsh King. Meanwhile, Ronan's dreams are becoming reality, many of which are pretty ugly. When he isn't venting his anger through lashing out at his friends and slamming car doors, he's balling his rage into a duel of sexual frustration and combustion engines with Aglionby's resident Buglarian gangster brat, (the aptly named) Joseph Fucking Kavinsky.

Kavinsky and Ronan stalk each other like vultures hungry for each other's meat. Their confusion about themselves becomes a relationship of competition and self-destruction, and even a competition of self-destruction. One second Kavinsky is despicable in Ronan's eyes, the next he's got shoulders as “beautiful as a corpse.” The feeling is clearly mutual. They are two angry lonely boys, but one is much lonelier and angrier than the other, and slowly, with Stiefvater's careful don't-call-it-a-plot-but-I'll-be-damned-if-it-isn't-a-climax pacing, emerges one exhilaratingly obnoxious teenage villain. You don't know whether you want to spit on him, hug him or cheer him on when he throws Molotov cocktails at his own car.

How do you chase death and destruction and be simultaneously convinced that you're invincible? Ronan is realizing his life was nothing but vapor, that he was raised in a house built on dream things, and he keeps falling in love with things that want to eat him. Adam and Gansey are both recognizing the futility of their missions in life, that they may never get what they truly want, but they don't know how to stop. And Blue, the smartest of the bunch, begins to understand that even if her inevitable love story is a tragic one, it's still a love story, one made of magic, wonder and her impossible boys.

Stiefvater has a gift for the impossible, making the intangible feel as real as shit. Her words let you taste the Henrietta air, smoking with magic the way lightning singes the atmosphere. You can feel the ley lines as distinctly as Adam does, you can smell the ammonia in Ronan's dreams. There are freaking psychics running around consulting their tarot cards and turning over stones in people's back yards, while a hit man drives around in a champagne-colored rental car and takes Blue's mother out on a date. Like I said in my Raven Boys review – real and unreal.

I think it should be obvious by now that I absolutely love this book. It's explosive in a way that The Raven Boys wasn't, which suits its primary protagonist, and instead of meandering happily the way the first book did, it barrels forward. Where is it going? Hard to say, this is Stiefvater we're talking about. If you're looking for a refined, organized plot you will never get one from her. She's all about the journey, the ride, fuel burning up in the engine. My advice? Get in the damn car.

it's always nice when you grow to like a character that was previously lacklustre. this happened with Ronan with me in this book. excited to see what happens next.
there were so many scenes i highlighted being like... is this Ronan being gay or is this the author making a point about homoerotic masculinity?? i think it could be both

I enjoyed this book so much more than The Raven Boys. I feel like in this book, I really got to know each of the characters more and I really got to start making predictions about what is to come.

While I have made a few small predictions, I still have no idea where this story as a whole is headed. I know I am only halfway through the series so there is a lot of story left, but I'm still very unsure of the overall direction.

This book started and ended with secrets and I really, really liked that. It was great parallelism that tied the book together. That being said, there was also quite the cliffhanger at the end and I'm very curious to where this leads us for Blue Lily, Lily Blue.