The Elementalists

The writing was smooth, the characters were varied & believable (although certain guys should decide whom they like and be faithful), & the setting was detailed. Some elements were a little predictable, but more in a “traditional” way than in a boring way.

I liked the minor characters a lot (or hated them when appropriate), including family members and friends. The author did a good job of making one minor character (sure to be a major character in the next book) a believable “enemy.” (High-school-grade enemy, but with hints of sheer genius and complicated motives.) The family interactions were great.

The fantasy elements were a little odd, but fit into the story. Most of the real science blended well with the fantasy.

I do have two complaints: I have read books with disasters, where the characters were over-panicking. In this book, I think they were under-panicking just a bit. As complaints go, it isn't very serious. #2: The Homecoming scene was less believable, although I understand why the author included it.

This series isn't likely to be one of my all-time favorites, but I still enjoyed it and look forward to reading the next book. Three stars from me is still a solid “like.”

I received the book as a Goodreads promotion, but got nothing for my review. My opinions, as always, are my own.