The Secret Gondal Society

I loved the concept. I loved that it was epistolary format.

I was disappointed by the execution. There were a lot of events that were either just dropped on us without any real foreshadowing that they were coming, or that were basically outlined and then handed to us. There were other areas of the story that felt like they were left almost completely unexplored, despite how important they were (or should have been) to Tilly. Not just because she's the main character, but because we're getting this story directly through her words and writings, I feel like those should have featured more prominently.

I also wish that more time and exploration had been spent in the written shared world the girls were creating, especially since I was expecting it to be a tool to explore the emotional chaos they were each going through. Instead, it felt like all we got was a brief info dump of each of them periodically instead.

Such a fantastic idea, and I wanted to love it. Unfortunately, it didn't live up to my hopes. :(