Tolkien's Modern Reading
Tolkien's Modern Reading
Middle-earth Beyond the Middle Ages
Reviews with the most likes.
[Read 06/08/23] Genuinely quite fantastic. Thoroughly dismantles Humphrey Carpenter's largely inaccurate depiction of Tolkien as an old fart stuck in the past while going through his modern reading WITH clear evidence. While there are a few eyebrow raising claims (when aren't there in this kind of scholarship? see Tolkien's Lost Chaucer) this is an erudite and meticulously researched book that I wish I had gotten to sooner. Super engaging and, as someone who did focus on medieval texts in my own degree, definitely broadened my horizons regarding my own understanding of Tolkien. 4.5