Unsolved

Book Review: “Unsolved” by Heather Critchlow

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐ (3/5 stars)

In “Unsolved” by Heather Critchlow, we delve into the world of Cal Lovett, a man driven by his obsession to uncover the truth behind missing persons cases. As the host of a true crime podcast, Cal dedicates himself to helping others find justice, even as he grapples with the unresolved mystery of his own sister's disappearance. When the distraught family of a missing Scottish woman seeks his aid, Cal embarks on a journey to Aberdeenshire, determined to unveil the hidden secrets lurking in the hills. However, what he uncovers may lead him down a path that intertwines with his own family's past.

The book presents an intriguing premise that immediately captivates readers. The author skillfully portrays Cal Lovett as a complex character whose backstory and motivations are well developed. His relentless pursuit of justice and his personal connection to the case create a compelling narrative thread throughout the story. Cal's dedication to helping others reflects his deep-seated desire to find closure for his own family's tragedy, adding depth and emotional resonance to his character.

One of the book's strengths lies in its vividly depicted setting. The atmospheric descriptions of Aberdeenshire transport readers to the misty landscapes and rugged hills of Scotland, enveloping them in an eerie ambiance that enhances the mystery at hand. Critchlow's attention to detail brings the setting to life, immersing readers in the story's atmosphere and adding an extra layer of enjoyment.

However, “Unsolved” does suffer from some drawbacks that prevent it from reaching its full potential. The writing style occasionally feels clunky and lacks finesse, making some sections of the book less engaging than they could be. Additionally, the pacing of the plot is inconsistent, with moments of suspense and intrigue interspersed with slower-paced sections that detract from the overall momentum. This uneven pacing can disrupt the reading experience and diminish the impact of certain plot twists.

Overall, “Unsolved” is a mixed bag. While it may not be a standout thriller, it offers enough intrigue and well-developed characters to hold readers' attention. The book's atmospheric setting is undoubtedly one of its highlights, drawing readers into the mysterious world of Cal Lovett's investigations. Despite its flaws, “Unsolved” remains an adequate choice for those seeking a moderately engaging mystery novel.

ARC Via NetGalley