Ratings123
Average rating4
Liked this book as a whole and the way the author explored the “Culture” goals of utopia and the hubris of imperial ideology when making contact with other civilizations. The author really knows how to do dialogue well, yet you don't feel like you're reading the author's views in a heavy-handed way. I felt I was experiencing truly different opinions from various characters on the themes. I'm anticipating reading the whole series because I really enjoyed the first two, but actually, this one didn't quite live up to my expectations.
The structure of the novel, with alternating chapters dipping into different timelines of the main character's life, one line progressing forward, and the other line working backward from the start of the protagonist's life, just didn't work for me. It kept taking me out of the story as I needed to figure out where the plot was going. Even with the chapter titles written as numbers going forward, and as Roman numerals for the backward line, I still felt confused too often. I tend to prefer one plotline over the other when a book splits like this. I was more comfortable reading the forward-moving plot, but I was more engaged with the character in the regressing plotline.
Didn't really care for the ending, but that didn't spoil the rest of the book for me. If you enjoy military sci-fi, but with a less emphasis on glorifying war, this book works well. The author explains battle tactics and strategy with the right amount of detail that I could visualize easily.
Even though this is only my third book to read in the series, I feel I would recommend this one only after reading at least the first two, and maybe even skipping this one until you have read more.