This was a nice quick read. The characters seemed straight out of central casting - not a lot of depth and fairly stereotypical. That said, I finished the book in a weekend and found myself engrossed in the story. The parallels between orphan train passengers of the early twentieth century and contemporary foster kids added depth.
It pains me to admit, but I am just not a short story person. I picked this book up anyway since it had so many amazing reviews. While I can admire Saunders' craft and skill, and admire some of the ideas played with in these stories, I just don't like short stories. I think the form is too brief for my taste - too many powerful emotions in a few pages!
I'm glad that Wood returns to Ashton Place for this, the third book chronicling the little wolf children :) Some secrets are revealed while others emerge as new conundrums. After listening to Katherine Kellgren make little yipping sounds and long howls, I can't imagine simply reading any of these books! Kellgren does a wonderful job of pulling the listener in to the story. I'm eagerly awaiting the next installment.
Kizzia explores some interesting dynamics between the Park Service and remote Alaskans. I found Hale's control of his family very disturbing, as well as the fact that his abuse could go on for so long, masked by the family's “quaint” charm and the respect for privacy (particularly in Alaska). Hale was truly a psychopath.
“Like” is not the right word to describe this book (or any book about North Korea, for that matter). I preferred Barbara Demick's Nothing to Envy but this, too, is a story that needs to be told and repeated until the human rights atrocities in North Korea stop. It's sickening what we all allow to happen simply because there is little monetary benefit to be had from entering a war with North Korea.
Oy vey, with the student loan whining already! I'm sympathetic to the cause - throwing people barely out of their teens under mountains of debt to get a college degree - but the cause is certainly more complicated and nuanced than Ilgunas portrays it. He concedes at the end of his book that his education was worth the debt, but this resolution may come too late for those who tired of his arguement by the third chapter. He still sounds like what he is - a young man with a good education who wishes everyone could simply follow their dreams and learn the lessons of simplicity. Noble, to be sure, and much easier to accomplish without the baggage of worries like health insurance, a spouse, or children. Also, I would like to point out that Ilgunas was incredibly lonely living in his van and that not many can handle the monastic, nomadic life (see: spouse, children).
Quite charming and engrossing! Cath reminded me of my younger self, if only I had her drive to write nonstop! Her love interest, Levi, was a little too good but offers young readers an idea of all the wonderful things men can be - thoughtful, caring, and genuine. The book plays with some interesting ideas of art and plagiarism, as well as the nature of family.
I confess that I gave up on this book about 90% of the way through. The premise just spiraled too far from plausibility for my taste - a woman moves in with her obese brother to help him lose weight and essentially cuts off all contact with her husband. Yes, family is important, but so is the family that you chose - i.e, your spouse. Edison's main attraction as a weight loss project for Pandora is that filial tie. Otherwise, he is pretty much a lazy, self-centered lout. So I couldn't listen any more.
I was disappointed by this novel. After focusing on the perspectives of a few main characters, Dalton introduces a new POV in the second half of the novel. If introduced in the first half as well, this character might have offered additional insight and more complicated layers of character development. Instead, a book that could have been a nuanced look at human frailty, the rush to judgement, and the idea of intelligence falls flat and, to be honest, is a little offensive.
I had a difficult time rating this book. On one hand, it was very readable and almost lyrical. On the other hand, nothing happens and there are many missed opportunities for character development and drama. It also ends quite abruptly and unsatisfactorily. All in all, this book has a lot of potential but could have used significant edits.