Big fan of the movie but never read the book, until now. Some give it negative reviews due to the vast differences between the two, the fact that the book concentrates mainly on the troops training and character development, whereas the movie more on the fighting. I liked those differences. In this way, the two complement each other and you can go from one to the other and see a journey.
Others say it is not really science fiction but of course it is, with its battle suits and arachnid beings, just subtly done.
As for Heinlein displaying too much of his political views? Don't a lot of writers? Aren't a writers opinions the basis of many books?
Think this would have been better as a novella rather than a novel. It meandered like the roads the family were stuck on and just seemed to go on and on, to the point where I didn't care about their fates and hoped they would just plummet off one of the freeways they travelled (so many Americanisms in this book, like freeway, asphalt and roadhouse for a book based in Scotland and featuring a British family, annoying). Saying this, I was going to give a 2 star, then about 3/4 of the way through a new character was introduced, a sort of ‘“gunslinger”and the action seemed to build up, hence the 3. I kept thinking, whilst reading this, that Stephen King would have done this material so much justice, the single parent, stuck on a never ending road, trying to protect her family from the dangers all around, right up his street (or down his road).
These books are always by-the-number but that doesn't make them any less fun to read. A bit of mindless nonsense that we need now and again. This wasn't the best but it had it's moments, especially when the history and mythology is brought in (the parts I always love about this type of book). I was just sat thinking, after the description of creature, “this does not sound like an ogre” and then the history of the word ogre is discussed (Tremayne's version anyway).
First book I have read in the series, in fact the first book I have read by Harrison. Maybe I've missed something by not reading previous books, maybe all the humour was used up by time he got this far. ‘The Monty Python of the spaceways' it states on front cover, maybe on a bad day. Absolute rubbish.
Good to read a proper pulpy “nature attacks” book from the 70s, especially one that is written so well (hard to believe that can be said about this genre but it is). What I especially liked was an American writers nod to James Herbert's The Rats, as if it was part of the same world inhabited by his killer spiders: “Bates paused for a moment, selected a news clipping from the pile in front of him.”Here's an item from a newspaper in England. About two years ago the poorer section of London was horribly infested with rats, definitely a threat to human life on account of spreading infection and rat bites. There was even reports of packs of these rats literally tearing small children to pieces. “
Brilliant.