 Ring Shout
| 4 | |
 Night of the Mannequins
| 4 | |
 The Odds
| 4 | |
 Blood Meridian
| 4 | |
 The Loop
| 4 | |
 Dead of Winter
| 4 | |
 The Invention of Sound
| 4 | |
 Autumn Bleeds Into Winter
| 5 | |
 Rag
| 5 | |
 The Space Between Worlds
| 4 | |
 Set This House in Order
| 4 | |
 The Goal
| 3 | |
 Horrorstör
| 4 | |
 Randomize
| 3 | |
 Summer Frost Summer Frost
| 4 | |
 The Last Conversation
| 4 | |
 Heartbreaker
| 5 | |
 The Drive-in
| 4 | |
 The Drive-in 2
| 4 | |
 The Tomb
| 5 | |
 Blanky
| 4 | |
 Devolution A Firsthand Account of the Rainier Sasquatch Massacre
| 4 | |
 The Perfectly Fine House
| 4 | |
 Survivor Song
| 5 | |
 The Only Good Indians
| 5 | |
 Malorie
| 5 | |
 Mexican Gothic
| 4 | |
 Gwendy's Magic Feather | 4 | |
 Survivor
| 4 | |
 The Light Brigade
| 5 | |
 The End of Policing
| 5 | |
 The Keep
| 4 | |
 The Devil in the White City
| 4 | |
 The Dark Game
| 5 | |
 The Dog of the South
| 4 | |
 If It Bleeds
| 5 | |
 The Southern Book Club's Guide to Slaying Vampires
| 5 | |
 Let's Play White
| 3 | |
 The 7½ Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle
| 4 | |
 Cat's Cradle
| 5 | |
 The Library at Mount Char
| 5 | |
 The Rising
| 4 | |
 A Visit from the Goon Squad
| 5 | |
 Hell House
| 5 | |
 We Sold Our Souls
| 5 | |
 True Crime
| 4 | |
 The Devil All the Time
| 5 | |
 The Fiends in the Furrows: An Anthology of Folk Horror
| 4 | |
 Reception
| 5 | |
 Pines
| 4 | |
 Damn Fine Story
| 4 | |
 Into the Drowning Deep Into the Drowning Deep
| 5 | |
 The Toll
| 3 | |
 Dracul
| 5 | |
 Song for the Unraveling of the World
| 5 | |
 The Unfinished World and Other Stories
| 4 | |
 The Only Harmless Great Thing
| 4 | |
 The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas
| 5 | |
 The Warehouse
| 5 | |
 Me Talk Pretty One Day
| 4 | |
 A Very Scalzi Christmas
| 5 | |
 Ninth House
| 5 | |
 Heads of the Colored People
| 5 | |
 The Black God's Drums
| 4 | |
 Aetherchrist
| 3 | |
 Witching Hour Theatre Witching Hour Theatre
| 5 | |
 A Lush and Seething Hell
| 5 | |
 The Future of Another Timeline
| 5 | |
 The Magic Wagon The Magic Wagon
| 4 | |
Skin to Fur Skin to Fur
| 5 | |
 Full Throttle
| 5 | |
 The Institute
| 5 | |
 Red Mars
| 3 | |
 This Is How You Lose the Time War
| 5 | |
 In Times Like These
| 3 | |
 Growing Things: And Other Stories
| 4 | |
 Wanderers
| 5 | |
 The Wide, Carnivorous Sky and Other Monstrous Geographies
| 5 | |
 Recursion
| 4 | |
 Sour Candy
| 4 | |
 Skidding Into Oblivion
| 5 | |
 The Nightmare Room
| 4 | |
 The Ballad of Black Tom
| 5 | |
 North American Lake Monsters
| 5 | |
 Wounds
| 4 | |
 A Game of Thrones
| 5 | |
 Lovecraft Country
| 5 | |
 Inspection
| 4 | |
 Boy's Life
| 4 | |
 A Collapse of Horses
| 5 | |
 Kill Creek
| 5 | |
 The Merry Spinster: Tales of Everyday Horror
| 4 | |
 An Absolutely Remarkable Thing
| 4 | |
 The Made-Up Man
| 4 | |
 The Bone Weaver's Orchard
| 3 | |
 Last Days
| 4 | |
 The Oracle Year
| 3 | |
 Millennium
| 5 | |
 Disappearance at Devil's Rock
| 5 | |
 Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?
| 5 |
