| #1 |  A Fire in the Flesh
| 3.85 |
| #2 |  The Heaven & Earth Grocery Store
| 4.01 |
| #3 |  Butcher & Blackbird
| 4.05 |
| #4 |  Happy Place
| 3.85 |
| #5 |  First Lie Wins
| 4.03 |
| #6 |  Divine Rivals
| 4.13 |
| #7 |  Killers of the Flower Moon: The Osage Murders and the Birth of the FBI
| 4.11 |
| #8 |  The Lightning Thief
| 4.03 |
| #9 |  Ask for Andrea
| 3.7 |
| #10 |  Once Upon a Broken Heart
| 3.94 |
| #11 |  The Women
| 4.38 |
| #12 |  The Sea of Monsters
| 3.95 |
| #13 |  Ruthless Vows
| 4.05 |
| #14 |  The Perfect Child
| 3.98 |
| #15 |  You Shouldn't Have Come Here
| 2.93 |
| #16 |  The Husbands
| 3.57 |
| #17 |  A Little Life | 4.12 |
| #18 |  Funny Story
| 4.22 |
| #19 |  The Other Valley
| 3.71 |
| #20 |  Part of Your World
| 4.26 |
| #21 |  The Taken Ones
| 4.5 |
| #22 |  Yours Truly
| 4.3 |
| #23 | Yours Truly
| 4.3 |
| #24 |  Just for the Summer
| 4.43 |
| #25 |  Home Is Where the Bodies Are
| 3.35 |
| #26 |  The Turn of the Key
| 3.83 |
| #27 | The Turn of the Key
| 3.83 |
| #28 |  The Midnight Feast
| 3.47 |
| #29 |  All the Dangerous Things
| 3.83 |
| #30 |  Middle of the Night
| 3.67 |
| #31 |  Finlay Donovan Jumps the Gun
| 3.61 |
| #32 |  Margo's Got Money Troubles
| 4.56 |
| #33 |  Monday's Not Coming
| 4.29 |
| #34 |  The Love of My Afterlife
| 4.14 |
| #35 |  The Friend Zone
| 3.47 |
| #36 |  The Hanging Tree
| 4.33 |
| #37 |  The Mysterious Case of the Alperton Angels
| 4.21 |
| #38 |  The Lost Story
| 3.38 |
| #39 |  Incidents Around the House
| 3.95 |
| #40 |  Uglies
| 3.59 |
| #41 |  Mary
| 4.03 |