| #1 |  Belle Mer
| 2.75 |
| #2 |  The House on Mango Street
| 3.75 |
| #3 |  Indian Horse
| 4.52 |
| #4 |  The Foundling
| 4 |
| #5 |  The One Hundred Years of Lenni and Margot
| 4.36 |
| #6 |  In the Lives of Puppets
| 4.07 |
| #7 |  Everything I Never Told You
| 3.92 |
| #8 |  Olive, Again
| 4.09 |
| #9 |  Lessons in Chemistry
| 4.11 |
| #10 |  West with Giraffes
| 4.08 |
| #11 |  Unlikely Animals
| 4 |
| #12 |  When Harry Met Minnie
| 3 |
| #13 |  A Piece of the World
| 4 |
| #14 |  Go as a River
| 4 |
| #15 |  Sugar and Spite
| 3.75 |
| #16 |  Dear Martin
| 4.14 |
| #17 |  The Blessing Way
| 3.58 |
| #18 |  Stay
| 4.5 |
| #19 |  The Best Strangers in the World: Stories from a Life Spent Listening
| 4 |
| #20 |  In the Unlikely Event
| 3.21 |
| #21 |  A Spindle Splintered
| 3.7 |
| #22 |  None of This Is True
| 3.93 |
| #23 |  A Mirror Mended
| 3.77 |
| #24 |  Run Away
| 3.64 |
| #25 |  Interpreter of Maladies
| 3.9 |