Sarah

This book made me so sad. Most of it was Penelope alone-and whatever apology given was not enough. I am writing this review long after I read the book but I still think about how sad it made me

It was cute. The end was very dramatic, in a way that made me knock a star but it was altogether enjoyable.

The romance in this book was terrible. It felt thrown together. And there was a lot in this book that didn't age well. However I kept on reading for the fantasy story line. I wanted to know how she found the key and that did not disappoint. It would have been so much better if the romance was cut or at least reduced, even if it was a much shorter book. I do wish I could see those painting with my own eyes...

One of my favorites!

This was my favorite of the series by far. I’m writing this review far after I read it (though the stars given are from just after I read it) but I remember liking the ghost. The love story was good. I found this story to be the best in the series.