Devi Nair

🎧 Listened in audio 📢 Narrated by Ellen Quay ⏱ Duration: 7 hours 🏷️ Publisher: Dreamscape Media 📅 Published: February 10, 2025 🧩 Genre: Cozy Mystery

There are few things cozier than an evening wrapped in a blanket, listening to Ellie Alexander describe chocolate truffles, bookish banter, and small-town secrets. A Victim at Valentine’s hits all the classic cozy notes, but what sets it apart is the clever “blind date with a book” twist. I recently went to an event like that myself, so reading Annie’s version of it felt like stepping right back into that literary matchmaking glow.

The Valentine’s Day atmosphere is layered beautifully throughout the story—romantic, festive, and just a little bit sinister once the dead body shows up. Ellie Alexander balances the tonal shift well, keeping things warm and engaging without dulling the stakes. This installment does something especially satisfying by sprinkling in tantalizing breadcrumbs about Scarlett’s long-running mystery. Those moments added depth and emotional weight, making the overarching series arc feel purposeful rather than background noise.

Ellen Quay's narration brought the small-town charm and emotional layers to life perfectly; her pacing nailed the suspense and the heartfelt moments. But let’s be honest, Fletcher finding someone completely stole the show for me. That subplot delivered the biggest emotional payoff and had me grinning like I’d just read the perfect romance novella tucked inside my murder mystery. Cozy readers, you’ll know exactly what I mean.

Would I recommend it? Absolutely, especially if you like your mysteries sweet with a slice of suspense. Alexander delivers comfort and curiosity in equal measure. This one’s a cozy Valentine’s treat.

What’s Your Match? If you were to go on a “blind date with a book,” what genre would your perfect match be: cozy mystery, dark thriller, or slow-burn romance? Tell me in the comments!