Luster definitely has its moments, either of uniquely dark satire or surreal breakneck-speed thriller, but its so insistent on beating the reader over the head with its own style that it can often be just too fatiguing to enjoy. Also nobody talks or acts like a real person which is a personal ick of mine
We're crying today...like any autobio project it can get a bit masturbatory but that's basically the only issue (coupled with the fact that it acknowledges this every other page) and the experimentations with the form and meta narrative are surprisingly amazing at points and only enhance the emotional impact. Quite harrowing though, would definitely be tentative about recommending this to people who've had first hand experience with suicide and suicidal ideation.
5/10 | dnf
I was generally enjoying this, despite the strange feeling that comes with reading something by someone from outside a culture writing as if they know it intimately, for about 300 pages before dnf'ing. I'd heard that there were historical inaccuracies here but the poetic writing style is done very well, and it was nice learning more about geisha culture (even if there are probably better ways to do that) - but ultimately I found the pining of the early-teenage girl towards a middle aged man to be a pretty gross thing for a middle aged man to be writing about and this only gets cemented as soon as the plot becomes about auctioning off a 15 year old girl's virginity to other middle aged men. Run for the hills sis!! Then I realised that literally who cares what happens and I abandoned it with haste
7.5/10
Often framed as some sort of book of a generation, Normal People has a huge reputation to live up to for unfamiliar readers, and it's not entirely successful in that regard - not that it's bad, but it does contain a series of weird moments and a slightly unsatisfying ending. The writing is of course fantastic, incredibly resonant and poignant when it delves into the confused inner worlds of the characters' minds, exposing a numbness that slowly thaws as they become more emotionally mature and open. This is of course the main draw, as well as the unflinching look into their sex lives - this was less successful imo. Especially the stuff in Sweden?! I found that to be a really bizarre way to depict Marianne's self-worth issues intersecting with her sexuality lol
But generally a really interesting and worthwhile read, especially if you're actively searching to associate with a certain kind of cool person lmao
this is the best book ever written and NO i don't just believe that cause i first read it when i was an impressionable eleven years old