If I could give this book more than 5 stars I would.
I knew immediately upon starting reading it that it would destroy me emotionally and I was right. I am destroyed but I didn't know how beautiful the journey to that destruction would be. Everything about the book is so well crafted: the Elizabeth Bishop poem, the music, and Misbah's chapters and that they are written by Sal! . I found that the drug plot was so well done with the way it was introduced and then kept showing up like Chekov's gun. It just worked!
If this doesn't win the Printz I'll be so incredibly sad!!
I loved this! Not only was it a great history of the franchise but it SHOULD -but it won't - silence all of the annoying fans who moan about “Gene's vision” and what is real Star Trek. It's ALL real Star Trek, especially the Star Trek you don't like.
It made me cry multiple times and made me it all even more.
My one quibble was going to be that the author didn't focus enough on what an absolute piece of shit Rick Berman is but I can see how that's not really the point. Plus most people know. Fuck that guy.
I really like this. It's a bit like if The Fifth Season and Evangelion had a baby and the baby was Joan of Arc. I think Yang does a good job of exploring the fine line between delusion/fanaticism and faith. My one wish was that the side of the Heretics was explored a bit more. It seemed obvious to me that they weren't as “bad” as perhaps the Church/Throne made them out to be but I think the text could have done a little bit more in that regard, but that's just me!
Again, the art in this is what keeps me coming back since we recently watched MSG so I'm familiar with the story. It's gorgeous and the essay at the back talks about how the artists doesn't use storyboards, outlines, and barely a colorist which is incredibly impressive. Some of the Jaburo landscape scenes are really wonderful. I do wish they had cut the parts with Char talking to some Amazonian Native peoples because it sort of uncomfortable.