Liked. Very hard to review without spoiling, but an interesting take on a familiar concept. Light on character exploration, but the plot goes places.

Was okay. Heavily twist-dependent, but if that's what you're looking for, it's worth the read.

Well-researched, compelling, concise. Elegantly answers the why — somewhat less so the how.

Essential. Not simply the voice of a black man in America but a man at odds with himself, his family, and the world presented to him; an artist who never wanted to be. I may never understand how it felt to write this, but I'll never forget how it felt to read it.

Fantastic world-building. Likeable but almost universally flat characters. Plot meanders but reaches a satisfying conclusion, leaving me very curious about events to come. Looking forward to reading more, although I'm not yet sold on the Sanderson hype.