Anna G.

Didn't like it as much as The Mitten, or Hedgie's Surprise, or some of Brett's other works, but this one was entertaining, had good basic Spanish exposure, and the illustrations are 5 stars, as always with Jan Brett.

A pleasant, gentle read with no negative attitudes toward any of the characters. In this story, Rabbit gives Pooh a pumpkin seed, and Pooh watches it grow throughout the summer. He learns that the pumpkin doesn’t appear immediately—first a vine grows, then flowers, then a small green ball appears. Pooh is disappointed at each stage because he doesn’t understand the process, but by the end, he finally enjoys his prized pumpkin.

This is a charming fall story for toddlers ages 3–5. It subtly teaches the stages of plant growth for children who are unfamiliar with gardening, while also offering humor for kids who already know the process, as they watch Pooh gradually figure it out.

A very cute book for ages 2–4 about a dog who loves to make messes—until one day, he makes such a big mess that nothing can be found… not even his friends. As he begins to clean up, he rediscovers all of his favorite things along the way.

Of course, once everything is tidy again, he starts the process all over—not quite learning his lesson. It’s humorous and very relatable for toddlers, showing why cleaning up matters while also reflecting their tendency to repeat the same behavior.

My 3-year-old loved this book and asked to read it multiple times.

It wasn't a particularly memorable story on its own, but I'm sure as part of the entire series, it works. The book contains corporal punishment, which I prefer to avoid.

A warm, thoughtful story with a message that lands naturally. I appreciated how Sadie comes from a home of hand-me-downs—it felt relatable for a large family, and it was presented as normal without any complaining. That detail alone sets a grounded, content tone.

Her excitement over choosing her own special pair of shoes feels true to childhood, and the moment when one is lost in the water carries real weight. The resolution is especially satisfying—Sadie’s kindness toward a new girl is returned in a meaningful way when the shoe finds its way back to her.

A simple story built on generosity, gratitude, and kindness, with engaging illustrations to match.