| #1 |  Horns
| 3.68 |
| #2 |  Rot & Ruin
| 4.09 |
| #3 |  Dust & Decay
| 3.89 |
| #4 |  Flesh & bone
| 4.33 |
| #5 |  It Devours!
| 4.21 |
| #6 |  The Southern Book Club's Guide to Slaying Vampires
| 3.8 |
| #7 |  Welcome to Night Vale
| 3.84 |
| #8 |  The Faceless Old Woman Who Secretly Lives in Your Home
| 4 |
| #9 |  Evil Librarian
| 3.6 |
| #10 |  The Girl in Red The Girl in Red
| 5 |
| #11 |  A Dowry of Blood
| 4.06 |
| #12 |  Come Closer
| 3.58 |
| #13 |  What Moves the Dead
| 3.85 |
| #14 |  Tender Is the Flesh
| 3.73 |
| #15 |  The Exorcist
| 4.08 |
| #16 |  Carrie
| 3.72 |
| #17 |  Ushers | 3.5 |
